Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

A Piercing Question- Dental tool vs PowerCarver?

Posts

A Piercing Question- Dental tool vs PowerCarver?

#1

A Piercing Question- Dental tool vs PowerCarver?

Louis K

Having a difficult time coughing up $300 for a PowerCarver, any reason not to try a $30 dental tool from eBay? Also, I typically turn 16"- 18" platers which to stand up to the rigors of daily usebe usable, really want to be 3/16"-1/4" tk, is this expecting too much from such a tool?

thanks,

Lou

Re: A Piercing Question- Dental tool vs PowerCarver?

#2

Re: A Piercing Question- Dental tool vs PowerCarve

john lucas

I can't answer the first part of your question but I have tried to pierce thicker wood. It is amazing how much harder it is to pierce through 1/8" thick wood compared to 1/16". I've done some piercing through 1/4" wood but it took a million years using my Foredom or my Dremel. I don't think a high speed drill would do any better on wood this thick. You have the rpms but don't have any power.

The best tool for wood that thick is a scroll saw.

Re: A Piercing Question- Dental tool vs PowerCarver?

#3

Re: A Piercing Question- Dental tool vs PowerCarve

Terry Scott

I love the standard Dremel as the speed is 32000 were the cheaper versions are often around 20000 .

Fordom and bosch are lower speed

Burs cut better when run at full noise

Here dremels are cheep as chips get one with the flexible shaft and put on a keyless chuck and you will be away '

I have the Nsk for detail work and probably do far to much heavy work with it as its so nice to use and crisp cutting

I get so much for my work that I can right off an nsk turbine on each piece l.o.l

You get what you pay for Id kill a $30 power carver in 10 mins

Re: A Piercing Question- Dental tool vs PowerCarver?

#4

Re: A Piercing Question- Dental tool vs PowerCarve

Donna Banfield

Not only will it take forever and longer to pierce through wood that thick, you'd better buy several hundred dental bits on ebay, too. You'll be snapping and breaking them every few minutes.

Re: A Piercing Question- Dental tool vs PowerCarver?

#5

Re: A Piercing Question- Dental tool vs PowerCarve

Lou K

Ouch, I'm thinking there must be a better way; scroll saw is a pain, dentil bits by the truckload is over the top, my dremel has a mind of its own when it hits funky grain, wonder if a small die grinder at 50k rpm makes a difference? I don't mind the burn & think the contrast is nice, but will it cut smoothly?

Thanks all for your assistance, more comments welcome!

Lou

Re: A Piercing Question- Dental tool vs PowerCarver?

#6

Re: A Piercing Question- Dental tool vs PowerCarve

John Lucas

Lou I find very little difference in the grain following with a 50K grinder vs 23K to 30K Dremel. The biggest difference is the size of the grinder, they are smaller than the Dremels.

There is obviously a tradeoff. Very high speeds cut with ease but won't remove a huge amount of wood and the bits are tiny and break easily if used for hogging cuts. When carving through thick wood (relative term 3/16" vs 1/16) the small tools are really slow and even though they don't follow the grain you still need patience and it's hard on your hands.

Big tools like the Foredom's will hog off lots of wood but tend to follow the grain when doing cuts like piercing. The smaller faster tools like Dremel's and die gringers will take heavier shanked tools but still follow the grain when piercing. I find that I can do a pretty decent job by pushing a hole and then cutting in a clockwise direction. Still slow and tedious.

A good example, I pierced a rim of a walnut vessel about 4" across with the dremel. The piercing was a band about 3/4" wide. I could only do about 1/4 of the way around before I had to stop and rest because you have to be so careful to keep it from following the grain and enlarging the hole. It took about an hour or more to do that small bit of piercing. On the same thickness of vessel (about 1/16 to 3/32) I could have pierced the whole thing in about 15 minutes with a 400K grinder.

Thicker turnings go even slower with the High speed grinders but again they don't follow the grain. However if you force the cut very much you break the blades. They also burn the wood so you either need to sand or paint the edges on thicker carvings. The Dremel's don't burn the wood and if your holes are larger will remove wood quicker. You just have to fight them more, cut in the proper direction and assume that it will try to bite in when the grain runs in certain directions.

One thing that I've though about trying but haven't, is to come up with a different kind of blade to put in my air saw. It's a reciprocating action so I thought some sort of round wood rasp might work. I doubt that it will pierce, but would enlarge a pierced or drilled hole very rapidly and with good control I think. I've used it with a the saw blades that come with them and it's like cutting butter when you cut through 1/4" wood.

Re: A Piercing Question- Dental tool vs PowerCarver?

#7

Re: A Piercing Question- Dental tool vs PowerCarve

Hal Taylor

Unless you are a glutton for punishment I'd stay away from trying to pierce wood that thick. Having said that a friend has used a rotozip with success on thicker wood.