Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

sharpening/grinding systems

Posts

sharpening/grinding systems

#1

sharpening/grinding systems

Carol

I am thinking about an 8" slow speed grinder. I have a 1" belt sander that I use for turning tools. I have a 6" high speed grinder I used for hogging metal, like lawn mower blades and axes. I use the Wolverine with both as the situation dictates, but am getting better with free hand sharpening. I also have the WorkSharp 3000 which does a wonderful job on chisels and plan irons. I have 8" wheels. I did once buy an 8" slow speed grinder but took it back as the shaft was bent and there were no more in stock.

So the question is, what does the 8" slow speed get me that I don't already have. The reason I am asking is that I am designing a cabinet to store sharpening stuff and I need to know if I need to design in a space for this.

Re: sharpening/grinding systems

#2

Mike Stafford

Re: sharpening/grinding systems

Mike Stafford

Carol,

I have one high speed grinder and I have one slow speed grinder. While I can grind tools on both of them it seems that I have better control and remove less material when I am touching up tools on the 1750 RPM grinder which is what I use all the time.

When I first started turning I sharpened my tools on the 12" disc sander using a jig that was available from Shopsmith. The tools were sharp but all the bevels were flat. I suppose that does not make a difference but I prefer the bevel to have a heel and a toe. I touch the heel first and raise the handle to engage the toe cutting edge. The 12" discs offered by Shopsmith were expensive and did not seem to last very long.

I think whatever system you use you should be good with it because ultimately the quality of your turnings and the longevity of your tool will depend on the skill with which you can sharpen. I sharpen frequently but I remove very little metal. As soon as the tool will not remove frog hair shavings I like to sharpen.

Others will have a different opinion.

Re: sharpening/grinding systems

#3

Re: sharpening/grinding systems

John Lucas

Carol I have grinders all over my shop. One of those things you can't have too many of. I don't really see much of a difference in 8" and 6". The biggest difference is it takes longer to wear out the wheels. I haven't actually done a price comparison on 6" vs 8" wheels to see if I truely am saving money but in my mind I am and that's all that really counts. :)

8" grinders take up more space but since the cost of some have come down they aren't necessarily more expensive.

Re: sharpening/grinding systems

#4

Re: sharpening/grinding systems

robo hippy

I figure the biggest advantage to the 8 inch slow speed grinder is the intimidation factor, especially for some one who isn't familiar with grinders. I would guess that if I did a lot of shaping, I would want high speed and a 20 grit wheel.

Wheels are as important as the grinder. The CBN wheels from D Way tools are head and shoulders above anything else out there, quality wise, and for economy as well. Zero risk of them ever blowing up. They come spin balanced. You never have to clean them or true them up. They will outlast by far the same dollar amount of wheels from any other manufacturer.

I prefer free hand sharpening as well. Much faster.

robo hippy

Re: sharpening/grinding systems

#5

Re: sharpening/grinding systems

David Walser

Carol,

That's quite an arsenal of metal shaping and sharpening tools. Given that you already have a 6" high speed grinder, a 1" belt sander, and a WorkSharp 3000, I don't think that an 8" slow speed grinder would add much to your capabilities. Here are some things to consider:

I prefer an 8" wheel to a 6" wheel. The 8" wheels are wider and produce a shallower hollow-grind. I find both features beneficial for sharpening -- but, except for lawn mower blades, you don't use your grinder for sharpening! I think, under most circumstances, I'd still prefer the larger wheel for metal shaping. Most of my metal shaping involves bringing a new gouge or scraper into the desired profile (before sharpening on a Tormek). If you do the same (before sharpening on your 1" belt sander), you might like the larger wheel. The additional width makes shaping a new tool easier and the shallower hollow-grind leaves less metal to be removed by your 1" belt. For removing the head from a bolt and similar tasks, I doubt the size of wheel makes much difference.

I like a slow speed grinder because most of my grinding tasks involve shaping turning tools. The slow speed grinder makes it easier for me to control the amount of metal I take off (even with a jig). I also prefer a slow speed grinder for sharpening a mower blade or any other task where excess heat might be a problem. (This isn't a concern with HSS used in turning tools.) For my uses, a slow speed grinder is plenty fast, particularly when compared to my Tormek.

However, if most of my grinding tasks involved removing the head from a bolt, removing hacksaw marks from a metal bar, or shaping a set of hand-made hinges, I might might prefer the extra speed provided by a high speed grinder. (I'd still prefer that high speed grinder have 8" wheels.)

I have both a 6" high speed grinder and an 8" slow speed grinder. My 8" grinder is used frequently. In fact, I've used the slow speed grinder within the last couple of months for all the tasks for which I just said I'd rather use a high speed grinder. I've not used my high speed grinder in about 3 years. Why not use the high speed grinder, when I have one, for the tasks for which it is better suited? Because my slow speed grinder is on my sharpening station where it's easily accessible. The high speed grinder has been relegated to a shelf and would need to be gotten out before it could be used. I keep meaning to give the high speed grinder to GoodWill. (I could use the space for wood!)

Hope this helps.

Re: sharpening/grinding systems

#6

The Woodcraft 8" low speed grinder......

JamieDonaldson

...is hard to beat for value, but frequently benefits from better wheels when replacements are needed. They often go on sale for about $90 including the 60 and 120 grit AlO wheels, and adding a jig system like the Oneway Wolverine really serves the needs of most turners very well.

Re: sharpening/grinding systems

#7

Ken Vaughan

Worksharp 3000 will also work

Ken Vaughan

The Worksharp people are now selling a tool bar for the 3000 that allows it to be more flexible -- and to allow the Tormek/Jet jigs on the 3000.

The cost for the tool bar is about $60 from Amazon and the Tormek jigs for gouges is about the same as the basic wolverine -

Worth thinking about --

Note -- I use both 6 inch and 8 inch grinders with wolverine and both work well. The "hollow grind" is a bit more shallow on the smaller wheel. -- Seems to be a lot of "what you get used to" as long as the edges are sharp.

Re: sharpening/grinding systems

#8

Re: sharpening/grinding systems

Bill Neddow

If you are not really happy with the"cheapie" grinders we all use, but cannot afford a Baldor -- have a look at the Dayton grinders. They are good, tough machines costing half of the Baldor.

Re: sharpening/grinding systems

#9

Re: sharpening/grinding systems - thanks, all

Carol

Thanks, Bill. I am not unhappy with what I have. My 6" high speed grinder is a 60 year old Craftsman with unbelievable bearings. It would be hard to improve upon it.

What I was wondering was what I was missing by not having an 8" slow speed grinder. It would appear, not much, given what else I own. Not enough to invest in one at any rate.

Thanks for you offerings, folks.

Re: sharpening/grinding systems

#10

Phil Stivers

Re: sharpening/grinding systems - thanks, all

Phil Stivers

Not to be the last to chime in, but.......

Your current set up (discounting the 6" HS grinder) does very well for most sharpening tasks. What is missing is the ability to hollow grind. The 6" grinder is discounted because of it's speed. Still a fine tool for "rougher" tasks and tool shaping. The 8" Slow will give you a hollow grind that you can use to feel the edge for hand touch-ups with a diamond card - in my pea sized brain, an advantage.

In most cases I disagree with those that say hand sharpening is quicker. It is only if you are very skilled and practiced. If you are comfortable with a particular jig set up (except the Tormek system IMHO) that is just as fast. But having said that hand sharpening does have it's advantages. The biggest in my mind it the ability to fine tune a grind you can't get with a jig.

The Tormek is a fine tool and does awesome work on my flat blades. I know of some turners that can make their tools dance on one. Not me. I can't get the shape I want and don't understand the directions. I even had the conversion bars for the dry grinder. Didn't help.

Alan Batty said it best: While learning to hand sharpen, use a jig to get your grind. Then use hand sharpening techniques to touch up the edge. You can always go back and fix the grind on the jig. Pretty soon you'll have the muscle memory and won't need the jig.

You know the shop..... The tool junkie has chimed.

Re: sharpening/grinding systems

#11

Re: sharpening/grinding systems - thanks, all

Carol

Hmmmm... You and Mike Stafford with the hollow grind issue. Thus far I haven't developed turning skills to appreciate what you are both talking about, though I understand it.

So perhaps I'd better design in the space and keep an eye pealed fora deal I can't turn down.

Timing is everything.

Maybe a shop tour during the Del Mar Fair? Haven't been in years. Wonder if past presidents are still eligible for a pass?

Re: sharpening/grinding systems

#12

Mike Stafford

Concave grind....

Mike Stafford

The hollow grind issue....

Think of the shape of the grind on the underside of the flute after it comes off the grinder. It should have some concave curvature reflecting the convex curve of the grinding wheel.

What I like about that curve is that it establishes a heel and a toe. The heel being the point on the concave curve farthest away from the cutting edge. By positioning the heel gently against the revolving piece of wood and slowly raising the handle the toe/cutting edge can be brought to bear against the wood. The more I pivot against that heel the more of the cutting edge that will be exposed to the wood.

Some new turners hear the phrase ride the bevel and push so hard with the tool against the wood that the steel gets hot. I like to think of gliding along on the bevel or on just the heel part of it. I think I get better control by finding the heel of the bevel and then slowly engaging the cutting edge, i.e. the toe.

I am sure there are others who can express what I am trying to say much better.

Re: sharpening/grinding systems

#13

Re: Concave grind....

John Lucas

Ditto what Mike said. I also like the hollow grind because when I do use the diamond hones to clean up an edge there are two positive points of reference for the hone to sit on. This makes honing the edge easier with less chance of rolling the edge with the hone.

As for a hollow grind being weaker. Well maybe in theory but I have never had a problem with them. Also the hollow grind from a 6" wheel and 8" wheel differ almost microscopically. Your only talking about a grind area of 1/4" to 3/8" maximum. When you compare the circumference of the 6 and 8" circle on that small portion of the arc you will see what I mean.