purely subjective design question...
GaryG in MD
OK, everybody weigh in here...
I've got a HF chucked up... standard shape with max diameter about 1/3 way down from the top. It has a short, gently curved lip around the hole.
The hole is 15/16". Right now, the rim width is 3/16". That means the outside of the lip around the hole is just under 1-3/8". I "think" I like the way it looks, but when I look at most HFs posted in albums on WoW, I see the rim thickness is generally very small -- say, only 1/16" around the opening.
So, I'm in a quandary. Do I leave it or turn it thin? The max diameter of the piece is 4-3/4", so the hole is just under 20% [or 0.5* (1 - 1/phi) for numerologists]. The two alternatives for the outside of the neck are 22.4% and 27.6%, so I don't think numerology has any bearing on the answer.
Here's a pic of what I'm talking about (before I completed the hollowing).
In your opinions, should I keep this rim thickness, or take it down to just a little over the hole size? ...and why?
TIA, Gary







LOL



