Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

purely subjective design question...

Posts

purely subjective design question...

#1

purely subjective design question...

GaryG in MD

OK, everybody weigh in here...

I've got a HF chucked up... standard shape with max diameter about 1/3 way down from the top. It has a short, gently curved lip around the hole.

The hole is 15/16". Right now, the rim width is 3/16". That means the outside of the lip around the hole is just under 1-3/8". I "think" I like the way it looks, but when I look at most HFs posted in albums on WoW, I see the rim thickness is generally very small -- say, only 1/16" around the opening.

So, I'm in a quandary. Do I leave it or turn it thin? The max diameter of the piece is 4-3/4", so the hole is just under 20% [or 0.5* (1 - 1/phi) for numerologists]. The two alternatives for the outside of the neck are 22.4% and 27.6%, so I don't think numerology has any bearing on the answer.

Here's a pic of what I'm talking about (before I completed the hollowing).

In your opinions, should I keep this rim thickness, or take it down to just a little over the hole size? ...and why?

TIA, Gary


Re: purely subjective design question...

#2

Jesper, Denmark

Re: purely subjective design question...

Jesper, Denmark

I think it looks fine the way it is. Particularly with the Caspar the friendly ghost figure looking at it with amazement.

Re: purely subjective design question...

#3

Gary G

mjonesrdg

It looks just fine with the opening as you have it designed. I might suggest that (if the wood is dry) you reduce the wall thickness at ,and around, the opening...a guess would be that the wall thickness is around 3/8"... and if it more closely matched the rim width, I think it would all balance just hunky-dory.

Nice work!

Re: purely subjective design question...

#4

Re: purely subjective design question...

charlie belden

Don't know about you, but I find it hard to see the piece as it will look when it's on its side. Upright pieces appearance changes. So I took the liberty of rotating your image. What jumped out at me was

- nice transitions on the outside profile - smooth curves blending into each other. Then I hit the wide flat rim and very thick walls - at least from looking in the opening. I see an incongruity. The outside says Light and delicate - ccntradicted by the wide rim and apparent thickness.

If this were a blown glass piece, the wide flat rim and the apparent thickness of the walls would work - and is often used by glass blowers. With thrown pieces, thin is in - and works really well, while THICK doesn't.

If you took the time to hollow through a 15/6ths inch opening, why make it appear almost twice as big with the wide flat rim?

If you're going to go with the wide flat rim, at least ease the edge of the opening where it meets the inside of the HF.


Re: purely subjective design question...

#5

Re: purely subjective design question...

Dale Miner

Ditto what Charlie said.

Re: purely subjective design question...

#6

Steven Antonucci

100% agree with Charlie

steven antonucci

one small undercut that reduces the "thickness at the opening" is what you need to do. Frankly, I leave a little mass there until the final cuts sometimes, but if you go too thin, it's hard to cut it at the end.

You can get that easily with the bent Hunter or any tool of your choice, and then sand it with the lathe running slowly and a little paper double stick taped to your finger. Cut from the inside of the opening on the corner first to establish a downhill lie, and then repeat until final thickness.

Steve

Re: purely subjective design question...

#7

Re: purely subjective design question...

jon gaynor

I really like the timber and shape. Excellent job.

I think you have good input from others.

I might suggest tapering the lip very slightly into the vessel opening.

I personally like to undercut the opening - I use a Mini-Munroe or Hunter tool to make a delicate cut. To me, this effect (the inward taper and undercut lip) invite the eye into the vessel.

Re: purely subjective design question...

#8

Re: purely subjective design question...

Dick Coers

For a piece that size, I would leave the hole the size you have now, but reduce the outside diameter of the shoulder. I would like to see more of a 3/4 photo to see the height better, but to me the opening makes it look heavy. With your photo, it looks to be a very round shape. That squared off opening competes with the overall look. I have left heavy shoulders like that, but did some pyro on them. Also, on near round shapes, I have always enjoyed the Ellsworth approach of no shoulder on the hole. That really celebrates the round shape.

Re: purely subjective design question...

#9

Lyle Jamieson

Re: purely subjective design question...

Lyle Jamieson

As others have indicated, it is important to send a consistant message. If you want to make a thin walled mouth opening keep the message consistant by following it with a thin wall all the way down including the bottom wall. It may look good on the outside, but you want it to feel good too and have balance in your hands. Heavy rimmed mouth says heavy, and thats OK. Thin rimed mouth says light and thin, and thats OK too. You are the artist, what do you want to convey??

Re: purely subjective design question...

#10

OK, let's try this again...

GaryG in MD

Thanks, all, for your excellent comments.

When this photo was taken, I hadn't finished hollowing -- including thinning the area under the rim. But it still has that basic style, even tho it's a little thinner now.

I now see that I actually have two aspects to deal with, not one.

I have the width of the rim, and I have the "depth" of the rim.

I think what most or all of you are saying is that you have a problem with the depth, not the width, or at least with the "blockiness" of it.

So, as I see it, I have two options as drawn below.

This is the way it is now:


I could taper the interior but keep the rim width, like this:


or I could taper the interior and also reduce the diameter of the collar, like this:


With this new understanding, I would appreciate a second round of comments.

Thanks, Gary

Re: purely subjective design question...

#11

Steven Antonucci

Middle, 100% yes.  Lower, your choice.


Re: purely subjective design question...

#12

Re: OK, let's try this again...

Stuart Johnson

Top if with a finial, middle without. The bottom edge is too sharp.

Re: purely subjective design question...

#13

Either 2 or 3 would work better.........

JamieDonaldson

...aeathetically, but I prefer an inward slope rather than any flat horizontal surface at the rim.

Re: purely subjective design question...

#14

I vote for number 3

Dick Coers

You're working with a pretty small vessel, so details should also be small (or thin in this case).

Re: purely subjective design question...

#15

Please keep those cards and letters rolling in...

GaryG in MD

So far, the votes are a wash...

Let's hear from more of you!

Thanks, Gary

Re: purely subjective design question...

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: Please keep those cards and letters rolling in

Keith Tompkins

HI Gary, My thoughts....if you strived for smooth flowing curves on the exterior, then an abrupt change to a flat opening seems out of place; the eye follows the curve, then stops at the rim. I think the rim should invite the viewer to look, or at least, feel inside. Flat says "stay away", gentle flow says "come closer". :)

Re: purely subjective design question...

#17

OK...Done Deal

GaryG in MD

I've had important feedback on this project from all the above people, and it's been very helpful in getting me to clarify my vision. So thanks to all for sharing your wisdom.

I value Keith's comments, which I think hit the nail on the head.

I also had an input from someone whose input I value strongly...

Ellsworth? Jordan? no... SWGFD (she who gets first dibs)

It became apparent to me that Keith is right -- #2 is clunky.

It's a done deal -- I went with #3 -- thin rim, strongly undercut [with my Hunter #1 tapered-shoulder "back" tool that worked beautifully, as advertised, with no drama]. I'm really getting to love that tool.

The top is now cut and sanded. Time to reverse it onto a Kirsten Kone to remove the tenon and carry the curve around to form a subtle foot. Doing the bottom is going to be scary because the inside of the bottom extends a tad deeper than intended, because I diddled back and forth getting rid of the center nib. I want the outer shape of the bottom to continue in a nice undercutting curve to a small, barely discernable foot, so it's going to get pretty thin down there. I think I have just barely enough material to work with at about 1/16". I'm hoping to put this piece into our MCW S&T next week, which will be critiqued by Mike Hosaluk. Wish me luck!

...Gary

Re: purely subjective design question...

#18

Brad Vietje

Re: OK...Done Deal

Brad Vietje

Good luck pulling off the thin bottom, and with the critique!

This has been an interesting exchange on one of my favorite topics -- wish I'd see it earlier. I'm with both Keith and Jamie on this one. If you make more like this, I'd vote for thin rim that includes an inward slope, as suggested by Jamie. The flat rim in the earlier posts really detracts from the fullness of the curves, and to me spells b-o-r-i-n-g! Glad you ditched that.

I like a little illusion at the opening, so I would tend to differ with Lyle somewhat. I like the inward sloping style used by Robert Chapman (Woodturning: A Fresh Approach), because the inward slope invites you to peer inside, and can give the impression of a thicker wall. Then when the vessel is picked up, it weighs less than the opening suggests, thus the element of surprise, or discovery. I think this adds a dimension like a tiny detail not seen at first glance, that adds depth and appreciation upon closer inspection.

A fine edge can also have a formal look, especially with a polished collar and a sharp transition to the rest of the vessel, while a thin, but rounded rim opening seems less formal, and can be more playful, or even whimsical.

Hope you post a photo of the finished product -- and the blue ribbon!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: purely subjective design question...

#19

Brad!

GaryG in MD

Thanks for your very insightful comments!

I wish you had caught me a couple of hours earlier!

I have that Chapman book and just reviewed the pix.

I wish I had remembered chapters 14 and 15!

I get it. I like it. For the future...

Since I have already steeply undercut this one, doing the inward slope would make the hole bigger, and it's so thin there wouldn't be much width to the inward sloping surface. I don't think it would look good if I did that now. What do you think?

But I'll design a Chapman slope into my next one, for sure.

So now I have pretty much the third drawing in my earlier post, where the flat plateau at the top around the rim is 1/8" wide, and the rise of the lip is about 1/8" above where the line would be if there were no rise. I've tried to redraw it here, but it's hard.



What would you recommend from this point?

Make it 1/16"? I'd have to be very careful because the angle of the outside is a lot more vertical than the undercut, so if I get the horizontal flat too narrow, I could accidentally make the hole a lot bigger! And I don't think I want to lessen the slope of the rise very much, if at all.

So, leave it alone? Other?

Thanks for your thoughts, Gary

Re: purely subjective design question...

#20

Hey, what about the rest of us that said #3?

Dick Coers

I beat Keith by several hours with the #3 vote, where's my credit? :D LOL

Re: purely subjective design question...

#21

Gary, if your sketch is anywhere close....

JamieDonaldson

...to scale, I would still slope the rim inward to eliminate that horizontal flat. It's too static and unrefined, and wouldn't significantly enlarge the top opening if done with care. Easy for me to say !!! :D ;)

Re: purely subjective design question...

#22

Right on, Dick!   


Re: purely subjective design question...

#23

Re: Gary, if your sketch is anywhere close....

GaryG in MD

Jamie, OK, if I'm reading you correctly, you want me to cut it in and down at the hole, like an inward-tilted bowl rim (and like what Chapman has in his book)? Even if it will be quite thin and enlarge the hole slightly? In other words, you want the rim to be a sharp point and go downward in both directions from there, inside and outside; is that correct? Thanks, Gary

Re: purely subjective design question...

#24

OK, it's a done deal; and what a difference!

GaryG in MD

I angled that top flat downward and inward at the hole, and yes(!) what a visual difference. Something so simple can make such an impact.

Thanks to everyone for sticking with me on this project. I'll get a new photo as soon as I can.

Now I've got to get it outside and get the bottom done. ...Gary

Re: purely subjective design question...

#25

Not sharp, but rounded slightly.