I am building a wind screen shelter for my tomato plants out of storm window plastic which I presume is acrylic, and is too thin to cement to itself. So I am using pine 3/4 in squares for corners and support. From those of you who are converted flat wood people and are still bi-pedal, bi-axial, or bi-anything that would give you any expertise in glues can you give me any advise at what glue or cement will stick acrylic to pine wood corners. Because my manual dexterity is rapidly declining I hate the thought of drilling and screwing the parts together.
If the acrylic is like glass panes, drill it and screw it to the posts. Use grommets or washers under the screw head to relieve stress and prevent cracking. I put acrylic on my screened porch for 30 years. It will shrink some with age and gets more brittle as it gets older.
I assume you're talking about using rigid plastic sheets of 1/8" thick window acrylic (aka "Plexiglas") or something similar. If it is the true sheet-stock acrylic, I would not advise using staples - this will crack the plastic immediately and subsequently propagate cracks throughout the pieces. On the other hand, polycarbonate plastics [e.g. LEXAN (tm)] can tolerate staples; polycarbonate is not at all brittle, particularly when compared to acrylic/'plexiglas' (...but you may not be able to tolerate the cost of polycarbonate compared to acrylic!)
If the plastic you are using is the thin polyethylene or polypropylene sheets that come in rolls, then staples would work OK; many temporary greenhouses are constructed in this manner.
For the "rigid' acrylic sheets, silicone adhesive (such as those kinds sold in caulking tubes) would likely stick well to both acrylic plastic and wood, and would be relatively weather impermeable. For example, the type of adhesive that is sold for adhering plastic manufactured countertops to wooden cabinets should work fine, as long as you can hold the pieces in place while the adhesive sets.
When gluing acrylic to itself, I use solvents such as 1,1,1 trichloroethane or methyl ethyl ketone, which dissolve some of the acrylic and fuse the plastic pieces together. Such a solvent system would not work well with gluing acrylic to wood.
Epoxy will certainly work. Polyurethane - Gorilla glue & the like - would probably do the job. Construction glue is another possibility. We are not, after all, talking life support equipment here.
It looks like the most workable solution is going to be the silicone adhesive. I may be able to now utilize the dozens of spring clamps I have accumulated over the years -- if I still have enough strength to squeeze them open.
Thank you all for your generosity in sharing your experiences.
Silicons are fine most of the time but in an expanding contracting situation they delaminate. Try 5200 rubber, an industrial strength adhesive use widely in boat building, it has an uncanny ability to bond very different materials, rocks, glass metal wood ceramics etc. It remains flexible. It takes a while to set. You can find it in boatyards and marine trades related places.
I have used Phenoseal for all sorts of outdoor applications. It is an adhesive caulk which can be painted, is UV stable, waterproof, and while it cures to a very tough product, it maintains some flexibility. It is also very shock resistant, and it won't crumble or get brittle like CA or many other adhesives. I've used it to glue together everything from ice boats to wooden telescope tubes. It is available in any hardware store or building supply, displayed with the tubes of caulking. Fairly inexpensive, and very good stuff. I've only used white, but I believe other colors are also available.
Most adhesives are not designed to be stable in sunlight because they never see sun buried in the joint. (Urethane Gorilla glues are among the least stable.) Most will quickly disintegrate when exposed to bright sun for any length of time. However, there may be adhesives used in plastic greenhouse construction that will hold up. Check greenhouse supply places.
....I doubt this structure will need to last for 25 years.
Thin acrylic plastic will likely break down in the sun and become brittle sooner than the adhesives being suggested. How long do you expect this structure to last, Bill??
This isn't an archival or architectural job. He just needs to stick plastic to wood, and he wanted to do so without mechanical fasteners. Good information provided in general. I have recorded the names of some of the products to try in the future - thanks for the info! You never know what you will learn on Woodcentral!
Bill I have a set or wooden ramps I made for loading heavy stuff into my truck. I made them by gluing a 2x4 to the side of a 2x10 with a rabbit joint using Gorilla Glue. They often sit in the sun on my porch because I don't have a place to store them. I did this just a few years after Gorilla glue was introduced. They are still as solid as Day 1. I'm not a big Gorilla glue fan because of it's mess but for this outdoor application it sure has proven itself.
Not to mention I'm moved pianos, 500lb metal lathes, my 700lb powermatic and loads of other stuff with these ramps. The glue doesn't show any signs of weakening. Even when the ramps are flexed under these weights.
I bought and rebuilt an older style DN that was probably built on Lake Morey, in my hometown of Fairlee, VT, in the late-50's. Original sail number is DN505. It's the older style rig with a more vertical mast, and a more upright seating position. Instead of the modern "Y" yolk, the boom was made with an iron ring that slipped over the base of the mast, so I made a new boom and kept the oddity for an old-timers meet or ice boating rally someday. I have yet to see another one like that.
I have never raced, and don't really want to. I've had some great fun as a fair-weather ice boater -- if there is such a thing. A good friend in CT works as a boat builder and has made several DN's, and is very active in the New England Ice Yachting Assoc., and has twice gone to Europe for the worlds. When I have attended sanctioned events with him, I usually volunteer, but don't want to get into the drive like mad every weekend circuit (circus?). I need to replace the bearings on the tiller post, so I haven't had it out on the ice in a few years. I'm actually trading a small turning job for this repair work.
Acrylics are one of the best plastics to endure sun exposure. If the stuff used is for outdoor application it may last many years. I have a sheet formulated for outdoor use that is still fine after 5 years. The problem in this case is that because the plastic is transparent the glue joint will be exposed to the sun. Now it could be that the stabilizers added to the plastic will shield the glue joint.
But the bottom line is that adhesives are typically not formulated to endure sun exposure because what is being held together is typically opaque. For example urethane adhesives last for many years outdoors when the application is gluing wood together. The joint is shielded. Expose this same adhesive to the sun and it will rapidly turn brown and get crumbly.
Acrylics are transparent to visible radiation, but absorb UV light. An acrylic sheet surrounding a fluorsecent light will protect against UV. And UV is the radiation that attacks glues and paint.
So this why my epoxy repair to my mailbox keeps failing. First I thought it was due to old epoxy. Guess I have to figure a mechanical fastener or spring for a new $20.00 Mailbox.