Food Safe Finish?
jimbo
I am turning a set of 6 small segmented bowls for probable use of "snacks".. Is Shellawax a food safe finish? If not , would you ladies/gents make suggestions. thanks, j. smith
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Food Safe Finish?
jimbo
I am turning a set of 6 small segmented bowls for probable use of "snacks".. Is Shellawax a food safe finish? If not , would you ladies/gents make suggestions. thanks, j. smith
Re: Food Safe Finish?
Nick Tuzzolino
Shellawax is perfect!!
Re: Food Safe Finish?
Gary Asbury
According to trade publications, any retail finish sold in America, once it is cured, is acceptable for food useage. The important part is "cured". Selling special food bowl finishes is a scam.
Just don't use any finish that .........
JamieDonaldson
...builds a surface finish that won't last, and my standard for any food related wood is mineral oil.
Re: Food Safe Finish?
Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN
Gary is 100% correct. All finishes are safe. Also, there is the matter of dose -- how many years would it take a person to consume even one drop of a toxic finish?
Selling "food safe finishes" is a scam.
Re: Food Safe Finish?
Skip Beardsley
While the idea that all finishes are food safe once cured may be correct there is more to the issue than that. There is the idea of perception in the eyes of the consumer. Most folks don't know the coating on M&Ms is shellac. Would they eat them if they knew? I am often asked "can I use this with food?" Rather than get into a long discussion with a customer on the merits of one finish or another, I choose to use one which says "food safe" and FDA approved for use with food on the label. I can then assure the customer of the appropriateness of use of the item with food with a clear conscience. I do this knowing I might get a higher gloss with lacquer or easier application with wipe on poly but am willing to put up with the possible limitations of the food save finish in order to have the customer have complete peace of mind.
Just some thoughts on the on going question.
Re: Food Safe Finish?
Gary Asbury
One might want to be careful with mineral oil, as it doesn't dry/cure well and doesn't protect the wood that good. Virtually all surface finishes when cured are like plastic when ingested by mammals. Their body simply passes the object with no accumlative effects on the body.
Re: Food Safe Finish?
Bill, Jacksonville, NC
Am not trying to be arbitrary or taken as a troublemaker beginning to question once a finish has dried/cured its food safe. Green movement is making a case for safer wood finishes to use in your home.
I too believe mineral oil (food safe laxative) non-drying oil and requires reapplication is what you should use. Do not use baby oil or industrial mineral oil definitely contain stuff not safe for ingestion.
All vegetable, flower seed, and nut oils with exception of Tung oil can and do go rancid.
Some scientific and government references not concerned with finishes going rancid or as harmful to humans.
If go to places like greenhomeguide.com/know-how/article/buyers-guide-to-clear-finishes: will see what being said and guide/links to safer finishes.
Yes, do think woodturners should look at material safety data sheets (MSDS) for favorite finishing products and make up their own minds whether to use or not.
Re: Food Safe Finish?
Bernie Weishapl
I agree with Gary and Emmett that all finishes are food safe. With that said I use walnut oil. Been using it for 6 yrs now with no problems or complaints. I have never seen walnut oil go rancid or I should say at least Mike Mahoney's or Mike Meredith's has never turned rancid on me.
Re: Food Safe Finish?
Gary Asbury
Total agreement with walnut oil. To counterbalance the high cost, it is incredible brushed on barbequing salmon!
Re: Food Safe Finish?
Pete in Holland
Fully cured is the key on most any finish. If you can smell it, it is still degassing the solvent carriers.
Think about it; if you drop a piece of balogna on your counter top, kitchen table, arm of your chair,the floor, or the hood of your car (short of any bacteria you may picked up), are you really afraid of eating it because of the finish it was just resting on? No.
Let most any finish completely dry....and cure.....and you can eat to your heart's delight.
Pete
Re: Food Safe Finish?
Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN
Mineral oil is a tasteless, inert, non-absorbable hydroxarbon, and, unless you happen to inhale some into your lungs during the consumptive process, completely non-toxic. It passes through the digestive tract unchanged.
Also, it does not breakdown and become rancid.
Unless you are consuming tablespoon quantities each day, there will be no lubricant laxative effect.
I had to snicker when Emmett ....
JamieDonaldson
...stated that mineral oil passes through the GI track unchanged, and that is totally TRUE, and it doesn't take long! It is frequently used in the animal kingdom as a GI lubricant for complications such as colic, and vets buy it in a 50 gal. drum, a good source when I can buy it for about $12 a gal. rather than $6 for 6 oz. at the pharmacy.
Re: Food Safe Finish?
Bill Howatt
Emmet Manley is correct in saying how long would it take you to eat a drop of finish. I have salad bowls that are over 25 yrs old and the finish appears to be well intact and I imagine what came off them was more likely due to cleaning than eating.
OTOH, Skip Beardsley is correct, especially when selling a product, that it is great being able to point to a finish that is labelled "food safe". As usual, "the perception is the reality", and if the customer perceives it as being safer than a non-labelled safe finish then it is.
My personal view is that all cured finishes are safe particularly when considering the micro-minute amount that would be consumed but if I were selling, I'd be using a finish labelled as such.
Bill