Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Posts

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#1

Ellis Walentine

***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Ellis Walentine

Creativity

Woodworking and woodturning are creative pursuits that start with an artistic vision or a functional need and end with a solution to the design problem we articulate for ourselves. Whether it’s a piece of furniture or a turned object, or some fixture or process, our creative problem solving ability is what brings it to life.

Creativity is an elusive term. Loosely defined, it is a measure of originality -- in our aesthetics, in our methods of work and in our approach to posing and solving design problems. It is what gives our work its style and individuality.

So, this month's survey is all about creativity and mindsets. How do you design stuff? What styles or embellishments do you prefer? Do you find it easy to come up with new ideas and processes? Is creativity an innate ability or a skill you can learn or both? What else can you tell us about your approach to your work?

As usual, we’ll distill your insights into our next column in Woodworker West magazine.

Thanks for participating!

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#2

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Jim Breeden

Ellis - Woodworker West Magazine?

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#3

George Taylor

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

George Taylor

I approach creativity along 2 different lines:

- production work, which for me is primarily wine stoppers. I start with a general form (basically a knob) and then I see which way the tool and cuts take me. It is free form and for me very relaxing.

- projects, here I do more planning and try to see what I can do a bit differently. In playing with stains right now, I am trying to explore all the color combinations to see what sparks an interest in me.

George

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#4

Ellis Walentine

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***  *LINK*


Woodworker West Magazine

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#5

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

dick gerard

Ellis,

I always have a notebook or sketch pad with me for those moments when I see something or want to scribble down an idea for the shop. Sometimes those ideas come to me in the shower, late at night, or while taking abreak and listening to music. A digital camera sometime is NOT the answer. But paper and pencil almost always work.

As far as embellishments go, I prefer tribal designs such as Africa, Australian Aboriginal, Nortweast Native American. Even designs from tattoo books, decorative arts books, fiber arts designs ... all are fair game. Lately I have begun to study the henna designs used in Indiaand I have been using more and more milk paints and India inks.

New ideas do not come easy for me, but I try to be acutely aware of what is around me. Nature is the best teacher and the ultimate source of creativity and new ideas for me.

Process: ... by this I'm assuming you meean the step by step procedures of doing something. If that is correct, then my process begins at the end. I envision the end product coming together and then I work mentally or on paper) backwards to the very beginning. This allows me to "see" potential difficulties in mounting the work, remounting the semi-finished work, etc.

Some people seem to be innately creative. People such as Clay Foster, Jennifer Shirley, Keith Holt, Derek Weidman, Gerret Von Ness, Michael and Cynthia Gibson, and a long list of others come to mind. But, I also believe that creativity can be learned.

My approach to my work? Eclectic plagiarism!

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#6

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH*** *LINK*

charlie belden

I'm certain we all START OUT creative. Hang out with some 5 and under kids if you doubt that. Then we go to school. By the time we get out of high school, most of our creativity has atrophised, our schools not encouraging or fostering creativity. What hasn't been lost is usually gone if you graduate from college. But - it's not a Use It Or Lose It thing. Creativity can be restarted at any time, and there are all sorts of methods for getting the creative juices flowing. The main obsticle to being creative is overcoming the work CREATIVE. That's often a mental block many find difficult to overcome. So I prefer SYNTHESIS - combining things that are already around - in ways they've not been combined before. Thinking "I'm a pretty good Putter Togetherer person doesn't have the baggage of CREATIVE - and anyone who's worked on a car, or did any gardening, or cooks or has a computer - and uses it - will admit to being a Synthesiser.

I've posted this link before, but since the question is about creativity . . .


Fix for "I'm Just Not Very Creative"

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#7

Steve Kubien

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Steve Kubien

Typically I know what I want to make from a given piece of wood. I mostly make bowls so I have decisions to be made about what its intended use will be. Salad bowl? Fruit? Pasta? Decorative?

For me, embellishments are pretty simple... A couple of beads, a Sorby texturing tool, a stepped rim.... I do some texturing/carving with a rotary tool but it typically consists of a bunch of dimples in some kind of geometric pattern. This may also get done with burner too.

There is also a notebook I carry in my van, if something strikes me. At home, I have my iPad and a drawing/sketching app.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#8

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

John Lucas

I don't think creativity is innate. I think you have to work on it. I work on it every day. I try my best to just look. That's what you learn as a photographer. You have to look. Look at everything. Then you try to imagine what you would do with what you see. Is it a texture on the roof of a car, or the way a Fern coils up at night. Is it a design someone cast into a lamp pole on the side of the road or the shape of a salt shaker at the local diner.

Then make sketches of these things or if they trigger an idea make a sketch of that. After a while you get more focused and the images you see trigger ideas that can be used in your art.

I have hundreds of sketches. What you see in the photo below is the contents of just 2 small folders. I have 3 thick book sized boxes full of these.

What got me into turning. I started making furniture for my house after I got married. I needed knobs for a piece so I turned it. My Grandfather was a good woodworker and made several things with turned details or legs. I just naturally assumed turning was what you learned if you were going to make furniture. Of course I subscribed to the latest woodworking magazines and of course saw David Ellsworths article along with some by Rude Osolnik. Turning started to take hold and just never let go.

I find designing stuff easy sometimes and very difficult other times. I find that if I put restrictions on the design process I come up with better pieces. For example you say I'm going to make a utilitarian piece that has something to do with a heart. I came up with the Cardiac Lamp. It took about 2 months of looking, thinking, planning and a few sketches to find the right ideas. Then of course I had the problem solving of building it. The Tin Man piece was the same. I wanted to enter a piece in the OZ show with the AAW. I was racking my brain and it wasn't working. I went to the flea market and they had an antique oil can. I had been doing a lot of inside-out turning and putting objects inside. The design then went pretty easy. Both of these pieces made it in the AAW shows.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#9

Steven Antonucci

Creativity strikes me when I can't do anything...

steven antonucci

about it!

Often, it's the middle of the night, and I can't just burst out to the shop and do something. I have a notepad next to the bed for those times.

On my flight to San Francisco yesterday, I was sketching with a pen and paper pad for 2 hours. No, the lathe doesn't fit in the overhead or my carry on. I have 2 pages of scribbles based on a few things I thought I might do someday. Creativity isn't always requiring the end step of making. It may just be the thought about how you might make something. I drew two things I might make just to see if I can make them. I drew one thing as an incomplete thought that needs more thought to be a whole idea. Brain games.

I was at a meeting in Sacramento and one of the attendees described how their organization managed a portfolio. Essentially, they said yes to everything, and very few things were completed satisfactorily. Funny thing is, that's how I work too...in the shop.

Creativity isn't necessarily about finishing. It's about starting and exploring.

Steve

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#10

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Mike Gibson

l guess l am lucky that l don't have to carry a sketch book or draw and plan what l intend to turn. Still fairly new to woodturning and have the need to try many things, so when l see something that interest me in magazines, forums, at symposiums or at a demo, l think l must try that, l then scour through my log pile to find a suitable piece to turn and put my own slant on as l turn. As l believe form rules l turn so it looks good to my eye, if it does not look good it most probably isn't. Once finished l usually look at the piece and think l can do that better or do it a slightly different way and find the possibility's are endless.

l think my working life (a carpenter) involved a lot of problem solving and to produce work that is pleasing to the eye and also balanced which has helped.

One thing l do not understand is l see skilled turners that have been turning two and three time as long as l have and their forms are terrible be it a bowl or hollow form or an art form, why do they not see if they were to just take a little off here or there it would look great. Michael

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#11

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

matt overton

I just returned from a three day Woodturning Design class with Jimmy Clewes. It was just Rob Wallace, me and Jimmy in his shop for three Great days. If there was just one thing I took away from this class (believe me, there were hundreds) it is to challenge myself to think of how many different ways a design or design element can be made to work. I get in creative ruts as a result of thinking there is only one way of getting a desired result. Jimmy showed me that as I thought of different ways to accomplish the intended criteria, new and different ideas opened up that were not workable with the original method. From now on I will stop and hear Jimmy say "Is that the only way to do it, mate?". If you get the opportunity, go to Vegas and take this design class with Jimmy. It is by far the best woodturning experience I have had.

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#12

Keith Tompkins

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Keith Tompkins

Hey Mike, your post could start an endless thread. I see the design problem you describe all the time...too many turners focus on what new tool will bring success, rather than really study, and learn to understand good design. I recently read a story by a motorcyclist, who signed up for a road-racing class. With 17 years experience, he expected to excell...what he discovered was he had just one year's experience...repeated 17 times! :O Some people readily see good design, so do not. You are very fortunate!

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

#13

Re: ***SURVEY: THE IDES OF MARCH***

Mike Gibson

Hi Kieth,

Thinking more on this subject and looking back at my earlier turnings they were not too good either but l could see where l needed to improve and still feel every time l turn my skills grow. Do the people who turn an ugly piece really think it is wonderful or because they are proud of producing a piece out of a log on a lathe? Having worked with wood all my life l sometimes forget that there are people who have never used any tools whatsoever before attempting to turn, and must admit l thought l would breeze though learning to turn which was not the case.