Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Hunter help 2

Posts

Hunter help 2

#1

Hunter help 2

GaryG in MD

OK, this is a follow up of my previous post -- I thought I'd start a new, clean thread...

All the same conditions as before, but now two drawings clearly detailing the conditions. In both of these situations, I can feel the Hunter #1 TS "back" tool being sucked into the hole. That's not good. It shouldn't be doing that. It means it's right on the hairy edge of a catch. This is directly analogous to what happens when a gouge is presented in no-mans land between a bevel riding cut and a scrape. It skates to the outside.

In my mind's eye, I see the 9:00 o'clock edge (farthest part of the edge away from the tool axis) of the tilted-back cutter doing a bevel-riding cut in both cases, as soon as it makes entry into the wood step or wall (just like the bevel of a gouge automatically establishes a bevel-riding cut when it enters a tiny fraction into a surface).

I'm pulling the tool (not pushing it), more or less parallel with the ways, toward me, from the headstock to the tailstock. I'm on center height. The elbow of the swan neck is horizontal. I'm angling the shaft of the tool slightly to the left to get the cutter to the desired location, but I can't get very far to the left before this problem develops.

This is the cut this tool was created to perform. So what am I doing wrong to cause it to misbehave?

TIA, Gary


Re: Hunter help 2

#2

Steven Antonucci

My answer is the same

steven antonucci

I would use the swan neck Hunter in picture #1 on the left, and cut from the opening towards the wall. It's simple because the point on the cutter that touches the wood is alway the same point. (call it 6 o'clock)

In the right diagram, the tool has to extend AND transition from the 6 o'clock to 9 o'clock position on the cutter. I believe that it's this transistion and the extended reach that you get the result you describe. It woulbe even worse if you went to far forward, because then the cutter contacts at 12 o'clock.

If I wanted to use the Hunter in the second picture, I would hollow a recess under the rim first, and then cut from the center of the vessel into that void to avoid having the two points of contact. Work in small increments, perhaps 1/4-1/2" at a time, and this will go away.

Steve

Re: Hunter help 2

#3

Re: Hunter help 2

john lucas

Gary That particular cutter doesn't really ride the bevel. it's a scraper. Cutting parallel to the bed will make it grab because it's not rubbing the bevel. You should be scraping at an angle to the bed. Cut(or scraper) from either the outside toward the lip or the lip toward the outside. Try to think 45 degrees or less when your cutting, not parallel to the bed.

That's why I try to hollow with the straight tool so that there is an angular section of wood going from the bottom left side of the sphere up to the lip. Then you can scraper in a sort of angled line going from deep out to the lip. Sort of like little arc's. The beginning of the cut will feel grabby but once you start it's pretty controlled. Take it down in stair steps this way until you have the sphere close to final dimension. Then you can go from lip toward the outside to finish the final thickness. You can go this direction in stages but be aware that if you bump into a step that runs parallel to the bed you need to either stop and whittle it away at an angle, or go very lightly.

Obviously as you round out the ball you will get closer and closer to that parallel cut so use lighter pressure as you approach the side angle.

You can cut parallel to the ways but it has to be very light and with the understanding that if you force the cut it will grab the wood and try to feed backwards just like a gouge would do. You can tilt the cutter down, but to do so means you have to raise the angle of the bar because you don't want it cutting below center.

Re: Hunter help 2

#4

Steve and John,

GaryG in MD

Thanks for you replies.

Lots of different angles represented in these discussions.

I'm going to have to take some time to read your replies carefully and make sure I'm thinking in the same directions and angles that you are.

Can't do it over the weekend due to other commitments, but I'll get back to it next week.

Thanks for hanging in there with me, Gary

Re: Hunter help 2

#5

Re: Steve and John,

SteveWorcester

If it is self feeding, slow down the rpms

Re: Hunter help 2

#6

Re: Steve and John,

John Lucas

Generally speaking if you run the lathe at higher rpm's the Hunter tools cut better. The Hunter tools work better when they are taking small cuts. If you speed up the lathe you can move the tool at what feels like a more comfortable rate.

Re: Hunter help 2

#7

Steve and John,

GaryG in MD

I've been using the slowest speed -- about 800 rpm on my Jet 1236.

I wouldn't dare go faster with it being so grabby, BUT...

maybe if I get it working properly, I'll be able to speed up a bit.

I'll start a new thread next week after I get a chance to play some more, but I think I now know what the problem is.

Mark St. Leger says that I should NOT be presenting the tool with the elbow flat to the floor. I think you've said the same thing. Gotta come in from below and rotate into the cut. That violates my rule about not scraping below center in general (DAMHIK), but, apparently, that's the way this tools works.

I'll let you know when I make some curls -- hopefully Monday. ...Gary

Re: Hunter help 2

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Steve and John,

Lyle Jamieson

I prefer to think about where the cutter is in the vessel over what I am doing with the twist of the handle. The simplest way to figure out how the cutter works is to cut on the center line. After you get it under control then experiment with twisting it and lowering and raising the handle. Even with all these variables one constant will be keeping the cut on the center line. Start off with the handle and bend parellel to the floor.

Re: Hunter help 2

#9

Lyle,

GaryG in MD

That has always been my feeling too, and what I have been doing until now (with bad results with this tool).

But now I'm getting diametrically opposed advice...

Mark St. Leger, who designed the tool, says:

"When I enter the cutter and start the cut I have the cutting edge at 7:30 and then raise it 8:00 to 8:30 to find the sweet spot for the cut. Entering at 9:00 is uncontrolable and aggressive so I don't do that."

And, in response to my reiteration that this approach would put me below center, he replied: "The cutting edge contact is below center for the entire cut as I described with the clock. The swan neck is overhanging the toolrest with the straight part of the shaft supported on the toolrest, and yes they are angled as the clock desrciption. I am never above center when hollowing a piece."

All I can do is try it and see what happens. Hopefully on Monday, but I've got roofers coming, so I'm not sure I'm going to be able to get out... Then I'm going to talk to Mike Hunter. ...Gary

Re: Hunter help 2

#10

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Lyle,

Lyle Jamieson

Mark is absolutely correct...IF he wants to maintain bevel support the cutter HAS to be cutting below center. Heres where the BUT comes in, The tool is designed to be used in a scraping mode. If you are very skilled and can keep the bevel supported by twistinmg your wrist in the correct and evolving position, and lowering and raising the handle appropriately, to keep the bevel support you will be cutting below center. Another BUT...you better have the bevel support!! there is no forgiveness. You will either be on the bevel and cutting cleanly or get a nasty catch. You must use the A-B-C method, Anchor, Bevel, and then (and only then) a cut. Find the bevel without a cut happening, and sneek up on the position the cut will happen, before you proceed down the side of the vessel.

You have heard from me, John and others say we believe that this is a scraping tool orientation that Mike Hunter has for this tool. I have talked to Mike about it. The confusing thing, and conflict is, most of the other Hand held tools Mike has developed can and will be used with bevel support. And in conflict with that... Most of the captured systems accept mine are set up as scraping tools only. Wonder why its so confusing??