Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Hunter help?

Posts

Hunter help?

#1

Hunter help?

GaryG in MD

I'm getting frustrated... I must be doing something wrong... help!

I have a Hunter #1 tapered shoulder "back" tool. I want to use it for removing the material immediately inside the opening in a HF, moving out into the shoulder area -- just like I saw Mark St. Leger, who designed the tool, do it.

It should go at least 1" safely, but I've got to be doing something wrong, because I can't get very far in (less than 1/4") before the tool gets scary -- it starts grabbing and sucking into the hole.

So here's what I'm doing:

I'm working on center.

I'm working with the straight part of the tool on the tool rest.

I'm working with the "elbow" horizontal and being careful to keep it that way.

I'm only pulling, not pushing.

I'm taking light cuts.

So what am I missing here?

If I drop the angle of the elbow down, I guess it might be safer, but then the cut goes below center, which is not a good thing.

I don't know what to try next...

TIA, Gary

Re: Hunter help?

#2

Re: Hunter help? *LINK*

John Lucas

Gary I haven't used the tools in a few months and I'm having senior moments this morning trying to visualize what happens. I have to head out to work but hopefully this video will help. If not I'll pull the tools out later tonight and answer your question.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FFW5ODChWkI

Re: Hunter help?

#3

Steven Antonucci

It's probably making contact on two sides

steven antonucci

It can self feed if you have more than one point of contact. As an example, undercutting in the opening and also trying to go further out. I usually hollow with a straight tool and then use the Hunter to undercut.

The only motion is right to left.

Steve

Re: Hunter help?

#4

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Hunter help?

Lyle Jamieson

Good point Steve. One of the basics of using the Hunter tools is to get the waste wood out from behind before you undercut a shoulder. You can use the bent tool to do that, but the straight works easier. Once the waste wood is out of the way, then the cutting action is that of a pulling motion, not pushing. In fact I think I can safely say you never do a pushing cut with it. The cutter angle is tilted down so a pushing motion toward the headstock will get very aggressive.

Re: Hunter help?

#5

Re: It's probably making contact on two sides

GaryG in MD

Steve,

Agreed. I undercut it first with a normal hollower and then pull the Hunter TS straight back toward me along the axis of the lathe to remove that pesky shoulder. I thought that was the proper way to use the tool. I could be wrong...(?) Something's sure not right...

I'll draw a picture and post it, but I've got David Ellsworth coming in a few minutes (I guess I could ask him, but I don't think he uses these tools), so I'll have to wait until tomorrow to do that.

...Gary

Re: Hunter help?

#6

Re: Hunter help?

GaryG in MD

Lyle,

I agree. As I said in my original post, I'm pulling/drawing back toward me along the axis of the lathe, never pushing back or even sideways (if my hands are doing what I'm trying to tell them to do). I'm working from empty space created with standard hollowing tools into the area immediately under the shoulder. I think that's what the tool is designed for, and it's why I'm so surprised by the behavior. I need to change something, I'm just not sure what.

...Gary

Re: Hunter help?

#7

Re: Hunter help?

GaryG in MD

John,

I watched your video and was surprised to find you pushing the tool. Both Steve and Lyle (below) warned against that, and I haven't been doing it. But you did and got away with it. Now I'm REALLY confused. As I say below, I've been pulling the tool straight toward me along the axis of the late, working from empty space into the shoulder area that I want to remove. The cut is grabbing the tool and sucking it deeper into the HF (toward the periphery) -- just like "run back" toward the rim when using a gouge working in the other direction from the outside.

Why do the others say "don't push", and yet you do it safely and with no ill effects?

This tool has me baffled.

...Gary

Re: Hunter help?

#8

Mike Stafford

Re: Hunter help?

Mike Stafford

I use them on every box I make but if you have access to David Ellsworth I would not dare suggest how to use a tool.....

You can use them backwards, forwards, pushing and pulling as long as the bevel is maintained. I remove huge volumes of wood with the #1 taper swan neck tool and clean up the cuts with the #3 swan neck.

More than likely you are not used to the tool engaging a large portion of its diameter. I had that problem when I first got my tool. That can make the tool grabby. You just have to use more turning muscle, something I have in abundance, to resist the tool's urge to roll. Once you get it cutting the wood shavings, not wood dust, will pour out of the opening.

The biggest problem I have is that they cut so effortlessly that you can have an internal diameter the same size as the external diameter in no time at all.

Re: Hunter help?

#9

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Hunter help?

Lyle Jamieson

You are wrapping a shaving around the cutter taking too much wood at a time. Try making a slight scooping movement of the cut so the boring bar is moving to the right along the tool rest as you pull the cut from the shoulder to the mouth opening, toward the tailstock. This motion would be lightly cutting as you pull the boring bar and cutter out of the hole. The usual motion is from right to left, but you must do the opposite and go left to right. The cutting action will be happening at the 9:00 o'clock position of the cutter, not out at the tip of the cutter.

Re: Hunter help?

#10

Mike Stafford

Lyle, no boring bar involved....

Mike Stafford

I am pretty sure from his description Gary is using the Hunter #1 tapered back cut tool which is handheld....

Someone correct me if I am wrong.....

Re: Hunter help?

#11

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Lyle, no boring bar involved....

Lyle Jamieson

Hand held yes, but there is a shaft (I call a boring bar) that the Hunter carbide cutter is attached to. He has no bevel support with the swan neck tool the way that Mike Hunter has the angle of the cutter with a forward tilt on the shaft/boring bar. With the swan neck model the entire cut is in a scraping mode no matter which way the cut is pushed, pulled or moved. Once you get some experience with it, it is possible to move the cutter any direction and produce an heavy, light, aggressive, or not, and efficient cut.

Re: Hunter help?

#12

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Hunter help?

Lyle Jamieson

JL's video shows how to use the straight hunter tool with bevel support. The swan neck model you have is a completely different tool. It has the cutter with a front end tilt angle that will not produce a bevel supported cut. It needs to be used in a scraping mode only. Mike and John also have a video using the swan neck tool with a cut away hollow form to see the action. It is on the Hunter Tool web site. Tutorial menu "Mini Hollowing tool set"

Re: Hunter help?

#13

Re: Hunter help?

John Lucas

Glad MIke and Lyle have you going in the right direction. I think Mike has answered it. It's way too easy to take a large bite with that tool. You have to start gently and get a feel for what it wants to do. Once you learn the tool you can be more aggressive.

Re: Hunter help?

#14

Re: Hunter help?

GaryG in MD

Lyle, The link John sent this morning has the "back" tool demonstrated at the 1:30 mark. That is what I was talking about in my second post. ...Gary

Re: Hunter help?

#15

Re: Lyle, no boring bar involved....

GaryG in MD

Lyle, I'm no expert, but I have to disagree that it's only a scraping tool. When used back to front inside the lip of a form already partly hollowed deeper in a V from the neck, the cut is a bevel-supported cut, IMO. ...Gary

Re: Hunter help?

#16

Mike and John,

GaryG in MD

I still don't think we're on the same page.

This is not the #1 taper swan neck tool' it's the #1 taper shoulder ("back") tool. There are 3 of them -- one straight, one swan neck with the cutter at a "normal" angle, and this one with the cutter canted up at a steep angle and meant to be used to remove the inside of the shoulder area around the neck hole.

I must be using it at an incorrect angle because it is getting sucked in and sent toward the periphery of the form, just like a gouge kicks outward if the bevel is not properly supported but not enough of a scrape either.

As noted in my first email, I am already gun shy with this thing and taking gentle, light, small cuts. It still grabs and pulls it in deeper.

I'll try to draw a diagram and post it. ...Gary

Re: Hunter help?

#17

Re: Mike and John,

John Lucas

Gary Your going in the wrong direction. That tool is used basically perpendicular to the ways. It is not a bevel rubbing tool. It gets very grabby when pulled parallel to the ways and trying to cut with the 9 oclock position and that's because you can't really get on the bevel.

When I first started using this tool I found it very much on the edge of a catch when hollowing Christmas ornaments when I reach that transition area between bottom curve and the top curve. The wall that runs parallel to the lathe has to be approached very carefully with either the hook tool or the back tool.

If I remember correctly I used the tool by pushing right to left or left to right, never parallel to the bed. It will cut on the push or the pull but should be about 45 degrees to bed or less. As it approaches that area that is changing toward parallel you have to take very light cuts.

I will have to go out in the shop and see exactly how I get around that because I haven't used these tools in a few months. I'll try to get out there tonight. Last night I had too many phone calls to make and didn't even get in the shop.

Re: Hunter help?

#18

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Lyle, no boring bar involved....

Lyle Jamieson

Gary, I have to disagree with you on this one. The reason that it wants to skate and gets grabby is the fact that the cutting edge is touching the wood without bevel support AND at an angle more then 90 degrees to the surface. A scrape that does not skate or get a catch has to be scraping at an angle less then 90 degrees, without the bevel support. This is a defination of a scrape in my vernacular.

I believe an advanced turner like John L. could find a way for the Hunter back cutting tool to get bevel support but it is not designed to work that way. The angle that the cutter is machined onto the shaft is tilting down in all directions to be used in a scraping mode. It will be scraping or rubbing on the shaft that is not sharp. If the "hook" of the shaft is kept parallel to the floor the cutter will be scraping in the bottom, sidewall, and undercutting the shoulder. Its only when the user starts to twist the shaft that it gets copmplicated. Not only does the twist change the cutting action the handle has to be moved up or down to compensate for the cutting happening above or below the center line. This gets really complex to try to describe verbally.

Re: Hunter help?

#19

Phil Stivers

Re: Lyle, no boring bar involved....

Phil Stivers

Lyle you've said in the past that a scraping cut with these cutters is in efficient and undesirable, yet here you contradict that statement.

Mike Jackofsky's tools scrape but do produce very efficient and smooth cuts. They can also be very aggressive when desired. No matter the tool or technique the Hunter cutters work very well.

Your boring bars work well and many of the other hollowing tools work well (including Mike's). It is a matter of personal preference. I use Hunter tools on small forms, Mike's tools on anything with a smallish opening (1"), and your boring bar setup with larger openings or deeper forms. It's all good.

Re: Hunter help?

#20

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Lyle, no boring bar involved....

Lyle Jamieson

Hi Phil, There is no conflict here, I have always been consistant. Yes, I have always said a slicing bevel supported cut will leave a better surface behind on the wood, no matter what tool you choose. Used in the undercut tool from Mike Hunter we are taliking about in this thread, it is a scraping mode. It is a very good finish surface but not as good as a bevel supported cut. The Hunter carbide cutter I have designed for my hollowing system has the ability to use a bevel supported cut and therefore is the best of both worlds. Carbide cutter and a slicing bevel supported cut...It does not get any better then that. Most of the other carbide cutter designs, accept mine, like Mike Jackowski's are used in a scraping cut.

Re: Hunter help?

#21

Thanks, John...

GaryG in MD

I'm beginning to understand that my results are predictable and "don't do that". I'm going to have to play more and get the feel. I've got to get my head wrapped around all the various angles and directions to make sure I'm thinking what you're saying. Thanks, Gary

Re: Hunter help?

#22

Thank you, Lyle...

GaryG in MD

I stand corrected. My mental image of the cutting action is wrong. I obviously haven't gotten this thing figured out yet. You're right about "too many angles". I'm going to read your comments very carefully and digest them and hope I'm working in the same coordinate frame mentally with you. I appreciate your patience in helping me work through this problem. ...Gary