Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

First Turning tools

Posts

First Turning tools

#1

First  Turning tools

Brian A

Looking to buy my first set of turning tools. Starting with spindle turning then on to bowls like everyone else does ;-)

Looked at 5 pc sets but the size of the Gouges offered in the sets do not seem to be what I need. So... after your years of experience if you were to order 5 turning tools which type and size would you buy first, second, third etc. Which ones do you find yourself using most often. Any other specs you think I should be aware or concentrate on?

Thanks

Brian

Re: First Turning tools

#2

Dick Hines

Re: First  Turning tools

Dick Hines

Don't buy a set. Pick out the tools you are going to use one at the time. In the long run I think it's better to buy tools as you need them.

Don't skimp on tool either. Buy the best you can afford.

Welcome to the turning world. Except for fishing and rideing a motorcyckle it's the most fun you can have with your cloths on.

Re: First Turning tools

#3

JL

Re: First  Turning tools

JL

Set are sometimes inexpensive - so that's a good thing.

I turn mostly spindles, so I'll give you my take on the "must have" spindle tools.

Roughing gouge - I like a 1 1/4".

Oval skew - I prefer 1" or greater

Spindle gouge - 3/8" and 1/2"

Parting tool - 3/16" diamond parting tool

Bedan - 3/8" or greater

You can try WoodRiver by Woodcraft. They've looked reasonable. Most of my tools are Crown or Sorby, though I do have a Delta or two.

Re: First Turning tools

#4

Steven Antonucci

Three answers

steven antonucci

1.) buy something cheap in a set. It won't break the bank, and odds are that they will cut as well as a beginner can.

2.) Buy a few used tools here and there. Better quality, but you need to look for them. Clubs are a great source of discards and upgrades.

3.) Buy the best you can. If you decide you hate turning, you'll get most of your money back, and you'll know it's not the tools fault...

That said, I teach a beginner class. During that class, we use a 1/2" spindle gouge, a bowl gouge, a parting tool, a roughing gouge, and a scraper. Buy a skew and you have what you need.

Steve

Re: First Turning tools

#5

Re: a different answer

bill Crommett

Because I started out with a set of hi carbon tools that came with my Shopsmith, I have learned that tools don't really make the difference until you get some time on the lathe. So my advise is to buy a tool (take your pick of the recommended tools) and spend some time learning to use it well before buying a bunch of good pieces of shiny stuff that looks good on the rack, but don't make you a better craftsman. And - I still use some of my old hi-carbon tools that I have reground for special purpose tools. More important than the brand or steel of a tool is to learn to sharpen well.

Re: First Turning tools

#6

Re: First  Turning tools

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

If money is short, buy only a bowl gouge. It can do anything that a spindle gouge will do. The reverse is NOT true. Learn to sharpen. No tool, whatever quality or type, can be useful if dull.

Re: First Turning tools

#7

I agree with Steve's list of beginning .....

JamieDonaldson

....tools, and would recommend the bowl gouge to be a 5/8," and later add a 1/2" bowl gouge to the collection. Be aware that the English gouges are measured by flute width, and much of the rest of the world measures tools by the diameter of the tool steel. And as stated, the best tools are sharp tools, so learn to sharpen well, and invest in good sharpening equipment such as a Wolverine jig set-up with the Woodcraft 8" slow speed grinder.

Re: First Turning tools

#8

Re: First  Turning tools

Carole Valentine

I have to agree with Bill here. Buy a 3/8" bowl gouge to learn. I never use my spindle gouge...well unless you count my detail gouge. You will need some way to sharpen it and will have to learn how. Until you figure that out, there is no need to buy an expensive gouge and just turn it into dust learning to sharpen it. Find a club or at least a fellow woodturner to mentor you. It cuts the learning curve tremendously.

Re: First Turning tools

#9

Carole, is that a 3/8" flute width.......

JamieDonaldson

...gouge, which we American Yanks would call a 1/2" gouge? ;)

Re: First Turning tools

#10

Re: Carole, is that a 3/8" flute width.......

Carole Valentine

LOL! Yep Jamie. Until Doug started making gouges, all of mine were measured by flute width. It would be 1/2" steel. ;)

Re: First Turning tools

#11

Brad Vietje

I'm With Everybody (?)

Brad Vietje

Hey Brian,

All the responses I've seen are good ones, and have merit -- there are always more than one way to do things!

I would advise a middle ground: Instead of buying up lots of cool tools before you really know which you will use/need/like, if you want to invest carefully (and learn from the large number of us who didn't ;) )you could purchase one or two high-quality tools that you will certainly need, and a sharpening system to start off with. You could also get a less expensive set to practice with, and to learn sharpening without grinding away a lot of expensive tool steel.

Summary: 4 Steps

1. Find an AAW Chapter

2. Start with just a few critical tools

3. Get or build a good sharpening system

4. Practice basic turning and sharpening -- your skills in both need to progress in unison.

American Association of Woodturners (AAW): The chorus is loud and clear that learning about sharpening, and finding a local AAW chapter are keys to your success. This is standard advise for any novice turner. You will probably learn more in a single 2 hour club meeting than 6 months of struggling to learn on your own. If you attend a turning club meeting, don't be afraid to speak up, and introduce yourself as someone who would like to learn all about woodturning. In my experience, most experienced turners would be very glad to advise or mentor you in your shop or theirs, and the experience is the single best way to learn to enjoy the sport with a smile and all fingers attached.

Tools: I'm with Carole; If I could have only 2 tools, they would be a 3/8" (flute) bowl gouge and a parting tool. With a fingernail grind and some practice, a bowl gouge can perform most of the tasks in wood turning. If you intend to start with spindle turning, a good quality 3/8" detail gouge will come in very useful for finer details. If you start with a basic set, beware of tools you will rarely, if ever, use. I got a cheap-o set on-line over 10 years ago for $12 plus shipping, so the tools cost me about $3 each. I used them to try out different grinds on my tools. Once I learned what shaped I liked, I re-ground the high-quality tools, and have mostly stuck with those grinds and sharpening methods. The unneeded tools were then turned into scrapers for different tasks. A basic set from Packard has tools you really will use (spindle roughing gouge, spindle gouge, parting tool, bowl gouge, and skew). Don't forget good safety glasses for spindle work, and a helmet with face shield for bowl work.

Sharpening: There are many ways to go. Find a mentor who's both a good turner and a good teacher (above) and do what they do, at least for now. A good quality 8" grinder will be useful for the rest of your life, so it's a good investment. Get at least one friable Aluminum Oxide wheel to replace the grey wheels that come with most machines. Avoid grinders with small diameter wheels -- they will result in grabby, fragile, and aggressive tools that are harder to use. You can look at the Wolverine jigs from Oneway and either buy one, or fabricate something yourself that does the same thing. A set of 3 diamond hones is around $15 or so, and you will eventually want a set to keep tools sharp and avoid so many trips to the grinder. Check out YouTube videos and you can see a number of shop-built jigs. I prefer and advise using jigs instead of free-hand sharpening. You might also find a few old salts at a club meeting that have a used lathe, chuck or tools for sale.

Practice: have fun and stay safe,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: First Turning tools

#12

Brad - Very wise advice, well expressed!

Jerry Hall

And it should be posited in the WC turning articles too...

Re: First Turning tools

#13

Re: Brad - Very wise advice, well expressed!

Brian A

Just want to say the response to this has been a great learning experience for me. I would not have known what to buy without asking and it was all so confusing once I sat down and started to think about what was actually needed. Here is what will happen for now only because of all of your help. I will buy a cheap set and grinding wheel and learn how to sharpen my tools well. Until that part of the process is mastered, I will be happy learning how to turn.

Last weekend a friend got me hooked on to turning. I mastered a small cherry trunk and turned it into a log with no bark ~ so far. He said that was the hardest part of turning. Now I'm hooked. Think I will make a peppermill out of it. Over the past week, the electric company cut down an ash tree, and had a good find for some walnut and various other woods on craigslist. So the story has begun.

Thank you all for your help. It was confusing wondering what it was that was actually needed to start turning. I will also seek out other turners to learn with including this forum.

Brian

Re: First Turning tools

#14

And don't forget to listen for.....

JamieDonaldson

....the sounds of a chainsaw in the neighborhood! Finding your own turning material is a big part of the enjoyment of turning, and many excellent finished pieces are made of "value added firewood!"

Re: First Turning tools

#15

From a rookie...

Tony - Memphis

I turn mostly furniture parts. I never got the bowl bug. I asked the same question you did and got some good advice. I started with a 3/4 rougher, 1/2 spindle, 1/8 parting, and a 3/4 or 1 skew. I added a 3/8 gouge for smaller details on legs and such. Those have served me well for quite a while now. Later, I added a 1/2 bowl and a couple of scrapers. Honestly, I rarely use those. Recently, I added a couple of the EasyWood tools (carbide tips). I really like those. All of my tools are Sorby that I waited to buy when there was a sale. I'm sure I'll use them for the rest of my days. They are very nice tools. So there you go, I'm not experienced - still learning, but I thought I'd share what worked for me.

Tony

Re: First Turning tools

#16

Brad Vietje

Re: And don't forget to listen for.....

Brad Vietje

For processing green wood, check out the links I provided about 3 days ago, titled "Handling Green Wood". or search for "Turning Urban Lumber". The links take you to 2 of the 4 short segments on cutting up fresh cut wood for turning, and the shrinkage and warping are well explained.

For pepper mills, you'll want to air dry the chunks on either side of the pith, so the end result will be stable and not warp or split. If you want to make a pepper mill now, you'll need some dry wood.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: First Turning tools

#17

Re: First  Turning tools

Philip Duffy

Start by making a couple tools, ie a parting tool out of a rip-saw blade, a scraper out of a discarded planer blade, etc. When you make a tool it is yours and you will soon learn that the best tools are the ones you have confidence in- -- and you can turn anything with them! Philip

Re: First Turning tools

#18

Jim Evans

Re: First  Turning tools

Jim Evans

One tool not mentioned is a DVD by a professional woodturner. It's amazing how much you can learn, I particularly like Alan Lacer & Jimmy Clewes because they are not tied to a certain turning dogma.

Also don't forget videos from youtube, especially those by John Lucas.

Re: First Turning tools

#19

Re: First  Turning tools

BrainA

Taking lots of notes here and waiting for my cheap tools to arrive so I can start to play.