I have come into a large stash of red oak logs and I've never worked it green. I recall reading that it will crack and check as you look at it. Have I got that right? Am I mistaking it for something else? I want to make a few display-type bowls and some hollowforms (which I will finish turn green).
I think oak is normally like that. One thing about the red oak, it is very open grain. Saw Roy Underhill split off a billet and stick one end in a bucket of water, and blew on the other end. Bubbles came out of the water end.
I've turned lots of red & white oak. Take the normal precautions about being quick about getting bowls roughed out as soon as you can & no plinth. Dry it slowly. Quick methods have not worked well for me. If your logs are big enough, harvest blanks so the inner bottom lies radially from the log center for some cool quarter sawing effects.
The fore-mentioned lemon is very true. The oak, and contact with cast iron, will turn your hands black. Normal soaps & cleaners will not touch it. A bottle of lemon juice is just the trick though.
Green oak is very bad for cast iron. Green shavings on a nice cast iron top of a lathe/table saw/ band saw / drill press will rust them in several minutes. Cover any tool that may get shavings in it while you are having fun turning. Clean your lathe at the end of the turning session that day with steel wool & WD-40, then spray a light coat of WD-40 on it before you leave.
I turn red oak quite a bit. Two large red oaks fell last fall and I'm enjoying using it for some spindle work and some hollow forms. Even though it has an open grain, I have had very little checking. I think this tree differs in various regions. I was just in Okahoma, where the grain seemed much less tight than my red oaks. I have learned through the years to try every wood that comes my way rather than listening to the ideas of others...sometimes thay are right and sometimes thay are wrong. Have fun.
We have a variety of oaks in Central Texas, Live Oak, post Oak, Black Jack, Spanish oak, Pin Oak, etc. it has been my experience that all oak is "looking " for someplace to "go". Our only "Red Oak" is the Black Jack, very gnarly and you can actually see sparks fly from a chainsaw on real dry stuff, very pretty grain tho!
Good luck and enjoy watching it assume its own shape!!
Robo, ya, I knew that about the "straws" of red oak. dont worry, I'm not intending this stuff for wet stuff like salad with dressing. Fruit bowls is what I have in mind.
Ok, clean up right away, lemon juice for my hands, dry it slow. Cool beans!!
I got some red oak logs from a friend last summer, with coring they've been turned into 50+ rough-outs. My first real experience roughing lots of green wood. It was lots of fun, but I spent nearly half of my time cleaning it seems. I did a handful per day, and then spent an hour+ each day cleaning. Wet shavings went everywhere and they turn everything black. I'd WD40 my lathe before turning each day, cover the ways with towels as best I could, and then use WD40 and steel wool at the end of each day. Also found that it created some black stains on my epoxy-painted cement floor. I took to wearing nitrile gloves while turning even to try and keep my hands from getting too black. Wish I knew about the lemon thing then...
At the end of each day I anchor sealed the bowls and they've been sitting in the garage since. For the first few weeks I'd check for cracks and put poly-glue in them to try to keep from spreading. After a couple months didn't notice any new cracks, but probably 10-15% have some cracking, most of which doesn't appear too deep.
I'd hoped to try turning some about now, but other household projects and flatwork are going to prevent me from getting to these for a few months yet.
I've had some good success with Red Oak. I especially like it for natural edge pieces, since the bark (up here in VT) tends to be thin and tight. I also like using it for end grain hollow forms. Like Barbara, I try whatever wood comes my way.
I've never had trouble with black stains on my hands, but it can stain and rust exposed steel.
I've needed lemon or lime juice to remove black blotches that develop on the surface of the wood, probably from tiny bits of steel from the sharpening process. Someday I figure I'll experiment with some process to clean the bevel (maybe a buff with Tripoli?) to see if that helps.
I made a series of rather thin green turnings with Red Oak a few years ago, and after wet sanding with water, found that the black staining had spread all over the outer surface of the bowl, and it looked pretty bad. I cleaned it with water, then I grabbed a half a lime from the kitchen, and squished it into the wood, waited about 45 minutes, then rinsed and dried the surface with a towel. The result was like a subtle patinating wax -- every pore stained black, while the surface looked normal. I'll look for a photo of that bowl -- I think its on WOW's from about 6 years ago.
I found the photo of the natural edge Red Oak bowl with the staining and lemon treatment in my WOW's album -- have long since lost the original when a former computer died -- so I'll try to attach it here. Looks like it was almost 9 years ago -- yikes!
I'd forgotten that the iron staining and lemon treatment also added a lot of contrast to the medullary rays, which is another effect I like.
If you compare that to another N.E. Bowl from the same log, but without the staining and lemon, the medullary rays are much less pronounced, and the pores are not as dark. Why one stained, while the other didn't is a mystery to me.
I'd encourage you to try that Oak and have a blast. It's not the easiest wood to turn, tends to be pretty grainy and coarse textured, but it does sand and polish up pretty well. For liquids, you could always make multiple applications of Danish Oil until the pores are all filled up.
1) red oak has a very high warpage factor, so for twice-turned bowls, make sure your roughouts are at least 10% thick or you won't be able to get them round again.
2) red oak is notorious for the soft wood sanding away preferentially and leaving a wavy surface (instead of the grain pattern) that is generally unattractive, so create your final shapes carefully with cutting tools and don't sand any more than necessary.