Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

***New Contest: Ornaments*** *LINK*

Posts

***New Contest: Ornaments*** *LINK*

#1

Ellis Walentine

***New Contest: Ornaments*** *LINK*

Ellis Walentine

Tonight I'm pleased to announce a new WoodCentral turning contest, "Turned Ornaments." It's going to be a great one. Our blue-ribbon judging panel consists of Kurt Hertzog, Dick Sing and Cindy Drozda, so you can be sure of knowledgeable officiating.

You have until October to plan and construct your entries, so I'm expecting some wonderful new work. Click the contest link below to read about the contest rules. Prizes and sponsorship are courtesy of Packard Woodworks, one of our major WoodCentral turning sponsors.

Cheers and may the best ornaments win.

Ellis Walentine, Host


Turned Ornaments Contest

Re: ***New Contest: Ornaments*** *LINK*

#2

A Question About The Rules

charlie belden

"Digitally-controlled construction or decorative technologies and processes are not allowed."

By "digitally-controlled construction or decorative technologies and processes", I assume you mean

no CNC machining

no laser engraver piercing

no laser "printing" of images or patterns

no laser engraved "low relief carving"

no 3D "printed" pieces or components

because these are all DIGITALLY controlled processes.

Would analog-controlled construction or decorative technologies and processes - like Rose Engine created pieces - or pattern followed pieces meet the contest rules requirements?

Silver or brass or copper wire inlays would be permitted, but fiber optics wouldn't?

Would internally lit, by battery powered LEDs, pieces be permitted?

Would breeze driven kinetic pieces be permitted?

Is DIGITALLY CONTROLLED the criteria for not qualifying or is it the use of modern technology being incorporated into a turned piece?

Re: ***New Contest: Ornaments*** *LINK*

#3

CHARLIE! I've been missing you!


Re: ***New Contest: Ornaments*** *LINK*

#4

Ellis Walentine

You got it, Charlie

Ellis Walentine

We wanted to rule out computer controlled processes, e.g., CNC routing, digital laser work, etc. I'll have to check with the judges as to whether rose engines and ornamental lathes are fair game. Meanwhile, anyone who has any doubts or questions may e-mail me in advance with a detailed description of what you plan to do, and I will consult with the judges. Any clarifications will be added to the contest description.

The general idea here is to encourage ornaments that are turned and decorated by hand. We realize that there is sometimes a fuzzy line between workmanship of risk and workmanship of certainty. The lathe itself is a tool of the latter but it is a necessary component according to the contest rules. Rose engine work may be over the line,and we'll have to get back to you on that. For a reasonably level playing field, ornamental lathe turnings may need to have their own contest someday.

Each entry will be either accepted or rejected for judging. Rejected entries will get a full refund of the entry fee.

Good questions, Charlie.

Ellis

Re: ***New Contest: Ornaments*** *LINK*

#5

Ellis Walentine

Re: A Question About The Rules

Ellis Walentine

Regarding analog vs digital processes, the judges have determined that using a rose engine or ornamental lathe doesn't violate the CNC rules and is acceptable.

Thanks for the question.

Cheers,

Ellis