Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Reciprocating Carving tool

Posts

Reciprocating Carving tool

#1

Reciprocating Carving tool

Jorge

Have a few projects in mind that could use a reciprocating carver

Which one is your favorite?

Can a Foredom SR reciprocate? There is one locally available if I want to try it before buying it, but the person does not know anything about it and there is no manual.

Thank you!

Jorge

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

#2

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

Don Evans

The answer is yes it can, the recip action is all done in the handpiece that you attach to the flex shaft. The SR is just the motor.

There are several rotary tools available that have the handpiece that recips, I've got a MasterCarver that I like a lot better than a Foredom. Biggest problem with Foredom is their over pricing their stuff.

Do a google search for Master Carver and check the price on it, you can find it with a package deal that includes 3 handpieces and one of them is the recip one. You'll find that it is less expensive than the Foredom. Also, any Foredom handpiece will work with the Master as they both use the same type flex shaft. Also, the Master is more horse power than the SR which I believe is 1/6 hp the Master is 1/3 hp and they just came out with one that is stronger at 1/2 hp. It's built like a tank also.

Don

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

#3

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

John Jordan

The Foredom reciprocating handpiece is a POS. I bought one figuring with that nice motor, it would do some of my heavier carving and save my Automachs some wear and tear. I used it five minutes and sold the whole mess. :D

If you buy an Automach, you'll never regret it. I'm on my third one in the last 25 years. If I wear the current one out, I'll buy another.

John

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

#4

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

John Lucas

I've had 2 different people tell me the foredom was not worth it and the Weecher was better but mostly because the flex shaft was thinner and more flexible. I don't really know how well the handpiece works but they seemed to like it. I looked online and it seems that by the time you buy the handpiece and flex shaft your up to about half the price of the Automac. I have only heard great things about that tool.

I have one of the discontinued Ryobi's. It's not great but is getting me by for now. I'm saving for the Automac. Most of my carving lately has been by hand or with rotary tools.

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

#5

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

Randy Gleckler

Just was using the Weecheer setup tonight. Can't say I have much experience with anything else.. but with the Flexcut chisel in the hand piece it worked very very well for me. I can't see me using it as much as say John would, but it worked well for what I needed on this project and maybe a few others...

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

#6

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

Jorge

Thanks Don, the price is attractive for sure.

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

#7

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

Jorge

John,

I like this best, the tool with no flex shaft to deal with is great.

I am saving for this one.

Thanks!

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

#8

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

Jorge

John, Randy,

Thanks for the input, I am saving for the Automach.

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

#9

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Jorge,

I use a Mastercarver recipro handpiece on my Foredom CC and it does well for small carvings. If, however, you have any history of carpal-tunnel, the vibration will limit the length of time you can go without aggravation. I also reshaped the Flex-cut blades I use to put convex bevels on them for better control. You will also do well to keep the bevels polished and the edges nick-free unless you plan on doing a lot of detail sanding. :\

m

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

#10

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

kruizen

check out smoky mountain woodcarvers, they have refurbished automach recip carvers for around $150.00. I have one and it works well.

the website is http://www.woodcarvers.com

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

#11

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

Jorge

Mark,

For my age I am doing pretty good about hand problems, but they are there, I do better on bigger projects, my hands do not do well with little stuff.

I'll keep your advice and keep the chisels sharp.

Gracias!

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

#12

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

Jorge

kruizen,

That is a very good piece of info, thank you!

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

#13

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

Carole Valentine

My Weecheer has stood me well, although I use my Ryobi more for recip carving, but they don't make the Ryobi anymore. At John J's suggestion I took the spring out of the WeeCheer recip handpiece...much better. My WeCheer is an older heavy duty model with pretty good power (1/3). Foredom was, in my opinion, way to pricey for what you get. Would love to try an Automach.

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

#14

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

Keith Newton

Automach gets my endorsement also. I started off with one of the little light-weight brands, which wore out in one day of moderate use.

I recently ground a new straight cutter after the straight flexcut broke at the shank. Made it out of a .25 x .25 x 2.5" tool steel. It really works great for squaring up the corners of router mortises.

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

#15

Thanks everybody!!

Jorge

Thanks Carole,

Keith, I could use that bit last week, made a coffee table. Thanks for the endorsement, I'll jump to the re-built ones that kruizen told me about.

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

#16

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

John Jordan

Good tip. They keep a complete line of parts, and have lots of other stuff, too. Sometimes I take my Arrowmont classes on a field trip to visit Smokey Mountain Carvers. :)

John

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

#17

Re: Thanks everybody!!

Keith Newton

That sounds like a good deal to me. I sent mine to them for a fix, and it was good as new. Keep grease in the little cam compartment, and don't use excessive force, and you will love this tool, especially on green wood.

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

#18

Re: Thanks everybody!!

Jorge

Good tip,

thank you Keith.

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

#19

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

Jorge

Someday I hope to make it to Arrowmont...

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

#20

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

John Jordan

Jorge, You would never regret it. Big fun! :)

John

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

#21

Bob Moffett

Re: Reciprocating Carving tool

Bob Moffett

I do quite a bit of carving in making bowls and hollow forms with spirals on the outside. I use an Arbortek reciprical carver and love it. Although it is loud when you are right on it, it is fast and stronger than most anything out there. It is a quality tool meant to do a lot of work. No affiliation, just a very satisfied customer.