I'm using a homemade fingernail grind rig to try to get a good grind on my spindle gouges. I get these little "horns" to the side when viewed from above, and the curve along the top edge of the flute as viewed from the side is concave, not convex.
That is a nice video, but I didn't see anything about spindle gouges in there. I also had a few questions, like what was the bevel angle of that bowl gouge at the tip? It looked really steep, like maybe 80º?
I'm a bit confused about spindle gouges and detail gouges myself. Your recent article you did for the AAW site, which I archived here as well, shows several different approaches to bowl gouge grinds, but spindle gouges are another animal. I've seen long, low bevels, 45º bevels and different wing treatments on various detail and spindle gouges, but I've not seen a comprehensive explanation of which grinds work best on which gouge profiles and for which turning tasks.
It sounds like a tall order, but I'd love to see that video.
I'm basing my reply on what I think you are describing -- a photo would be very helpful. It would also be helpful to see the home-made jig you're using. Is the angle between the tool and the pivot arm adjustable, or fixed?
With a particular jig, you'll have to go through a little trial and error to get just the right result. That does use up a little steel, but you should only have to do this once. The shape of the fingernail profile is set by grinding the tool with the flute down, while the ends of the "wings" are probably due to not sweeping the tool far enough to either side.
I believe you need to start with the gouge upside-down, and rocking the tool up and down to get the shape/profile you want -- look down at the flute from above at where the flute intersects the ground surface to visualize the resulting shape. When that shape is what you want to see from above and from the side, you need to decide and set what bevel angle you want at the tip or nose of the gouge. This angle is changed by adjusting the height and position of the pivot point that the jig rests on. I use included angles (meaning the solid steel between the bevel and the inside of the flute) of about 40 degrees for two of my spindle gouges, about 30 degrees for my favorite detail gouge, and a really pointy 25 degrees or so for a 3/8" spindle gouge I use for most of the finer details and tight places.
From your description, you may need to make sure the home-made jig or tool holder allows you to sweep all the way to right and left without hitting the grinder before the bevel reaches the length you want. For one of the "fatter" jigs I made, I had to remove the little steel rest that came with the grinder, as I couldn't sweep the tool far enough without hitting it, or I could set the exposed tool length to 2.5" instead of 2" (and adjust the pivot point further out to arrive at the same bevel angle).
Most commercial sharpening jigs set the height (and yours may, as well), and you are left to adjust the position by shortening or lengthening the arm on which the pivot point rests. Assuming you set the length of the tool sticking out consistently, closer to the wheel means cutting higher on the wheel and a longer bevel with a more acute ("pointy") tip, while further away means a shorter bevel with a larger included angle.
Now you can start removing some of the steel, and stop often to make sure the bevel is developing the way you want. If the included angle between the bevel and flute is not quite what you wanted or expected, adjustments to the position of the pivot point will correct this. You want to grind away metal until the bevel just reaches the flute profile without leaving and flat faces from the original upside-down shaping.
A little trial and error should get you the the desired result; if you have any photos to share, you might get more specific help.
I posted that video because he asked about " horns" or low areas in the grind. He also mentioned cut curve being incorrect. That is usually caused by leaving the tool in one spot too long. I thought the video might show him that he needs to grind longer in the high spots.
I do need to do one on spindle gouges, roughing gouge, and probably find a local turner with several tools all sharpened incorrectly or in need of improving the shape of the edge. I'll look at that as soon as I can.
Randy I not sure what the horns look like or where they are. On my wider spindle gouges I only use the jig for the nose of the tool. As I move the tool to the wider section of the gouge I move the jig out of the V on my Oneway jig and slide up the stone.
In other words, I start at the nose with the flute up. As I rotate the jig to sharpen the out toward the edge where the flute is now pointing left or right I move the Wolverine jig up the stone to bring the outer edge of the spindle gouge back a little bit.
I'll try to do a video this weekend on my different spindle gouges and how I sharpen them.
Thanks for all the replies. I did some reading and made a new jig. Practiced on my old gouges that came with the old Beaver and I think I have it down now.