Boshield... No, Top Coat!
Brad Vietje
Went to Woodcraft about a month ago on a trip to Boston, looking for Top Coat. They didn't have any, but did have a can of Boshield, which was represented as a similar product; and good for lubricating bed ways, rust and corrosion protection, etc...
So, I tried it on my pretty sticky PM3520B tailstock, ways, tool rest banjo, and even lubricated the tailstock ram, and the sliding headstock. The instructions tell us to spray on and allow to dry for a heavy coating, or wipe on/wipe off for a lighter coating. So, I spray it on there, spread it around with a paper towel, and start working all the moving parts back & forth.
At first, it was like magic -- the tail stock just floated on a sheet of slippery fluid, the searing pain of forcing the tailstock assembly to and fro (rotator cuff tears and multiple re-injuries) was gone! The tailstock ram seemed as smooth and slippery as brand new. Then the gunk dried to a gooey substance that did far more harm than good (at least as far as lubrication goes).
So, I use 4-0 steel wool, Scotch Bright pads and paper towels to remove it, and start again -- this time applying with a piece of grey Scotch Bright pad, followed by wiping "dry" with paper towels. No real improvement. After a few turning sessions, the residue created sticky patches, and had to be mechanically removed with steel wool all over again.
Conclusion: this product has no place in a woodworking shop. It may prevent rust and pitting, and may work OK for in-feed and out-feed tables for saws, etc..., but this stuff becomes a gooey, sticky mess, and is not for use on lathes. I did spray it on a dry and noisy car door hinge with good results, so maybe that's how it should be used. My late is not in a heated room, so maybe that's the problem, but buyer beware -- this stuff is not a replacement for Top Coat.
Since the closest Woodcraft is a 2-1/2 hour drive away, and the store where I bought this is 3 hours away, I will call the store where I bought it and request they swap this can for the product I wanted: Bostic Top Coat. Why a woodworking store like Woodcraft would allow their stock of a great product like Top Coat to run out is beyond me. Telling me that this new product from Boeing Aerospace will do the same thing just ain't so. At $18.95 for a can, this was an expensive little mistake!
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
(or 0 for 2...
)
, I'll clean the whole thing off with mineral spirits and wax everything. I've done this for years now, the machine's almost 41 years old, looks like new. Haven't tried it on my lathe yet...maybe I should take such good care of my lathe.



