Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Boshield... No, Top Coat!

Posts

Boshield... No, Top Coat!

#1

Brad Vietje

Boshield... No, Top Coat!

Brad Vietje

Went to Woodcraft about a month ago on a trip to Boston, looking for Top Coat. They didn't have any, but did have a can of Boshield, which was represented as a similar product; and good for lubricating bed ways, rust and corrosion protection, etc...

So, I tried it on my pretty sticky PM3520B tailstock, ways, tool rest banjo, and even lubricated the tailstock ram, and the sliding headstock. The instructions tell us to spray on and allow to dry for a heavy coating, or wipe on/wipe off for a lighter coating. So, I spray it on there, spread it around with a paper towel, and start working all the moving parts back & forth.

At first, it was like magic -- the tail stock just floated on a sheet of slippery fluid, the searing pain of forcing the tailstock assembly to and fro (rotator cuff tears and multiple re-injuries) was gone! The tailstock ram seemed as smooth and slippery as brand new. Then the gunk dried to a gooey substance that did far more harm than good (at least as far as lubrication goes).

So, I use 4-0 steel wool, Scotch Bright pads and paper towels to remove it, and start again -- this time applying with a piece of grey Scotch Bright pad, followed by wiping "dry" with paper towels. No real improvement. After a few turning sessions, the residue created sticky patches, and had to be mechanically removed with steel wool all over again.

Conclusion: this product has no place in a woodworking shop. It may prevent rust and pitting, and may work OK for in-feed and out-feed tables for saws, etc..., but this stuff becomes a gooey, sticky mess, and is not for use on lathes. I did spray it on a dry and noisy car door hinge with good results, so maybe that's how it should be used. My late is not in a heated room, so maybe that's the problem, but buyer beware -- this stuff is not a replacement for Top Coat.

Since the closest Woodcraft is a 2-1/2 hour drive away, and the store where I bought this is 3 hours away, I will call the store where I bought it and request they swap this can for the product I wanted: Bostic Top Coat. Why a woodworking store like Woodcraft would allow their stock of a great product like Top Coat to run out is beyond me. Telling me that this new product from Boeing Aerospace will do the same thing just ain't so. At $18.95 for a can, this was an expensive little mistake!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

#2

Re: Boshield...(slick tape report)

mjonesrdg

Last month I posted here about my application of UHMW "Slick Tape) to the bottom of my banjo (PM3520A) and to the top surface of a couple of tool rests. The banjo application was a bust...for the same reasons Brad reports, that just a bit of fine dust between the banjo bottom and the ways, and I'm right back where I started. I DO very much like the tape on my tool rests, however. Having a very smooth, slick, surface really helps when doing small work, like finials and such.

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

#3

Rob Wallace

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

Rob Wallace

Brad:

I am also sold on Bostik Top Cote for the surfaces of the ways, and bottoms of tool rest banjoes, and tailstock slides. I treat all of my lathes at least 3-4 times/year with Top Cote (removing the previous coatings first with mineral spirits, and then polishing the surfaces with a rubberized fine abrasive block, followed by another mineral spirit wipe-down with a clean rag, and re-coating the solvent cleaned surface with Top Cote). I will also spray a heavy coat on the ways (and not buff it out) just before turning wet blanks of acidic/corrosive species like cherry, oak, or walnut. Really cuts down or eliminates discoloration and corrosion under these situations.

I have read that Boeshield is an excellent preserver of metal/machined parts (for which it was developed by the Boeing Corp.) and reviews published (either in Fine Woodworking or in Wood magazine??) regard it highly as a cast iron rust preservative - it "won" with the top ranking in that regard, if memory serves. However, I don't believe it was developed for and meant to be a metal surface protectant AND friction reducing compound like Top Cote is.

Others use various paste waxes, WD-40, and silicone/teflon sprays, etc, on their lathe ways, however I have been very happy with using Top Cote for the past 10-12 years at least. I think it is worth the cost of this product for upkeep of my lathes, table saw, band saws, jointer, etc. - my lathe beds and sliding tool parts look and perform great!

Good luck getting back on track - I do know that Klingspor's sells Top Cote: http://www.woodworkingshop.com/product/bos1075/ among other on-line 'mail-order' vendors....

Cheers,

Rob

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

#4

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

Brian McInturff

Never had a problem with it. I squirt a little on, wait until I see the white film, and then buff it with a paper towel. Works great!

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

#5

Brad Vietje

Re: Boeshield... No, Top Cote!

Brad Vietje

Hey Brian,

Are you saying the Boeshield works well for you? Could be my problem is that my lathe is currently in an unheated barn, and during the colder months maybe the liquid gels or doesn't cure or dry out properly (?) This has been a very warm winter, but these results were from temp's in the 20's - 40's on about 4 different sessions.

Obviously the cold has affected my spelling -- got an error in both product names, so I was 2 for 2 !! 8) (or 0 for 2... :\ )

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

#6

Harry Robinette

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

Harry Robinette

I have had Top coat let my tailstock and banjo creep on the ways. Bioshield is not meant for sliding but great for medal preservative.

For the ways on all my Lathe I use PG2000 light spray and wipe with a paper towel let dry everything slides beautifully and NO creep. Been checking it out now for about 6 months works really great. Spray on paper towel and wipe the ways about once a week before closing the shop for the night ,it drys over night and ready to go in the morning.

My shop stays at 67 to 69 degrees year around with humidity around 50 to 58 % if thats any help or reason for this to work for me.

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

#7

Re: Boeshield... No, Top Cote!

Brian McInturff

Brad,

Yeah, I've never had a problem. I use the T-9 on all my tools and my lathe. I use a light coat and rub it off. You shouldn't have any buildup when you use it. If you put it on thicK and don't buff it off with a paper towel then that could be your problem. I probably put 3 or 4 drops on each way, wipe it on so I see I've covered the ways, then buff it off.

My shop is unheated and not air conditioned in the summer with high humidity(I'm in Myrtle Beach, SC).

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

Keith Tompkins

Hi Brad...sorry to hear your troubles with Boeshield. I use it when I put my classic Honda CB750 up for the winter. I spray heavily all exposed metal parts, then also use a chemically treated sponge product that deters rust as well.then seal the bike in a plastic strorage bag with bags of silica gel. In the spring...about a MONTH :) , I'll clean the whole thing off with mineral spirits and wax everything. I've done this for years now, the machine's almost 41 years old, looks like new. Haven't tried it on my lathe yet...maybe I should take such good care of my lathe.

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

#9

Reinassance Wax

Jorge

Brad, it is for "mothballing" equipment for an extended period of non use.

For our everyday maintenance of our lathes, I found Renaissance Wax to be my choice. A light coating, chase it with paper towels after a while and you are done., I also use air to clean the underside banjo, tailstock and headstock. I have an unheated space and things do rust, the salt air in this island, and this wax prevents rust far better than Johnson's that I used in the past. It seems expensive, something like $25.00 a can. I got the can in 2008 when I got my lathe and have used about 1/3rd of the can, so lets say that it will last 10 years, so is really not expensive at all.

Blowing air is good at all times, but specially after sanding, when abrasive grit is on the ways and things get scratched if we leave it there.

my $0,02

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

#10

Keith-move south

John Lucas

I've ridden my bike at least one day a week all winter. Keeps the battery charged, the tires inflated, and the gas doesn't go bad. :)

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

#11

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

bill Crommett

Keith: Where can one get silica gel in small, but not tiny, quantities ? I have tried the local hardware stores and Home Depot, but hey don't know what I'm talking about.

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

#12

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat! *LINK*

john lucas

Bill I have no idea where I bought it. I found a site online to get small bags of silica jell. It was shortly after that that I found the Bullfrog tool protectors. It's hard to say if they work or not. I have considerable less rust than before on my planes blades and other things stored in the cabinet. Whether it's my new shop location or the Bullfrog discs I don't really know. I mean they don't make any noise, don't smell, and near as I tell the coating they apply is invisible. So it could all be my imagination and a big scam, BUT, I'm going to buy some more. I also don't know now you tell when they are used up.


http://www.bull-frog.com/products/

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

Keith Tompkins

Yes, John, the bullfrog sheets are what I use.

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

#14

Keith Tompkins

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

Keith Tompkins

HI Bill, try theruststore.com They have all you want!

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

#15

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

bill Crommett

Keith: I found silica gel at Walmart. It comes in a tightly sealed bag as kitty litter. Thanks for the reply.

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

#16

Rob Wallace

Re: Boshield... No, Top Coat!

Rob Wallace

Bill:

You can probably get silica gel in hobby shops in reasonable quantities which is sold for use in drying live flowers and making dried flower arrangements from fresh flowers. Places like Michael's, Hobby Lobby, or even Walmart's "crafts" section probably sells silica gel for this purpose.

This material is often found as a white pelletized material (that can have different particle sizes) which sometimes has a blue indicator added that turns pink when it has picked up too much moisture (a cobalt chloride humidity indicator).

Silica gel can be "re-activated' as a dessicant by spreading out the moist material on a baking sheet or similar pan, and placing it into a low (150 degree) oven for several hours to drive-off bound water in the pellets. If it has an indicator, the drying process will be complete when the pellets turn blue from their colorless or pink 'moist' condition. If not, 150 degrees for 2-5 hours should be a good starting point for reactivation of water-saturated silica gel, depending on particle size. You won't hurt it by keeping it warm longer.

Alternatively, you could make yourself a hero with your female friends, and buy them all dozens of pairs of shoes or leather handbags, and then save all of the little silica gel dessicant packets that come in the boxes. ;)

Good luck!

Rob