Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

pen finish question...

Posts

pen finish question...

#1

pen finish question...

GaryG in MD

I've started making a few pens, and I'm trying to make them look different from each other. I finished the first couple with Hut Crystal Coat, which yellows the wood. I don't want them all looking yellowish. So I figured I'd try one with water-based poly. I read the back of the can carefully, and amidst all the directions and warnings, it says to sand the first coat back at 220 to make sure the second coat sticks. They don't say anything about the sanding level of the wood before the first coat. I have already sanded the wood to 4k, and I don't like the idea of going back to rough it up again.

So, finally, my questions is: will water-based poly stick to wood sanded to 4k, or will it decide to peel or flake or wear off sometime later? Pens obviously get a lot of rough use, so this would be a kind of acid test for a finish.

I'm sure some of you must have experience with this kind of thing.

Thanks, Gary

Re: pen finish question...

#2

Re: pen finish question...

Vincent Welch

HI Gary,

The folks at Stick Fast just created a nice system for pen finsihing using there CA glue. The product is listed on my site and you can also see a you tube video wo to use the product.

Vince

http://vinceswoodnwonders.com/the-best-cyanoacrylate-glue/

Re: pen finish question...

#3

Re: pen finish question...

Bernie Weishapl

I started using the General Finishes Woodturners Finish because I could not stand the fumes from CA especially during the winter. I sand my pens to 600 for the wood pens. I have a hair dryer I use on low heat so I can get 6 coats on in about 30 minutes. You must remember the first coat or two you will need to sand with 800 grit as the WB finish will raise the grain. I am finding it is a pretty tough finish as I did a cereal/salad bowl that I have used at least 4 days a week for 2 or 3 months. It still looks good.

Re: pen finish question...

#4

Vince,

GaryG in MD

Thanks for the reminder about CA.

I'll check out that article.

I know it does a very nice job.

I'm a little concerned about the sensitizer aspects.

Terry Scott used it too much and now doesn't dare get near it.

I might want to save my remaining tolerance for filling cracks.

We'll see... ...Gary

Re: pen finish question...

#5

Bernie,

GaryG in MD

I appreciate your input (and that's a great story about the durability -- good to know), but that's the kind of thing I'm trying to avoid. The specs read:

"WTF is a non-toxic water/oil urethane hybrid for use on wood turnings, salad bowls, and other lathe turned projects. It produces a rich amber tone and dries to recoat in minutes." It's the ambering that I specifically don't want.

I've already made several "amber" pens, so, for this one, I want to retain the light color component in this piece of "marblewood" as it is. That means using either a water-based poly or an acrylic spray. I have both, but my fear is that they might not stay stuck to a 4k surface! ...Gary

Re: pen finish question...

#6

Alan Zenreich

Re: Bernie,

Alan Zenreich

Gary,

Why not resand the blanks to 400 or 600 grit?

That would only take a few seconds if you put the blank between centers on the lathe. Then sand by hand in the long direction and your done.

Total time... a minute to prepare for just about any finish.

Re: pen finish question...

#7

Re: pen finish question...

Barry L Elder

Each layer is separate so each needs some"bite" to stay in place. So the need for 220 sanding or something like that.

Lacquer is the only finish I have used where the top coat blends in with the coat underneath, but some people can't handle the odor thus the need for a booth or very good ventilation. :b

Re: pen finish question...

#8

Re: Bernie,

Bernie Weishapl

Gary it doesn't impart a really amber to the wood. The bowl I did just has a slight hint of it. I was concerned to but bought a small bottle (8 oz I think) and was pleased enough to order a quart.

Re: pen finish question...

#9

Re: pen finish question...

Scott Greaves

Hi Gary!

I would think the first coat of WB poly would stick to your pen just fine. Then for each successive coat sand lightly before applying. Tell us how it goes, and I'd love to see a picture when you're done.

That being said, it seems like a complicated finish when simpler ones exist. I use a CA finish, and I recommend them. If you are sensitive to the odor, there are odorless varieties around. Or you could use a fan to blow the fumes away from you. CA is a good hard finish that is relatively easy and quick to apply, and it generally doesn't impart any yellow color. I quite often use CA along with BLO, and the BLO can change the color. Just know that and plan accordingly. There are massive discussions on pen finishes over on IAP that you might want to check.

Good luck!

Scott.

Re: pen finish question...

#10

Alan,

GaryG in MD

I understand what you're saying. But it goes "against the grain".

My typical method of finishing does not involve surface finishes.

I normally sand to 800, put on a few coats of oil, and take it to 4k.

That gives the kind of mild, not-plastic shine that I like.

But oils yellow.

So I have to find another way if I want to maintain color.

I've never left wood so roughly sanded before finishing.

I've been taught that scratches under a top coat are still scratches.

At this point, I'm still not sure what I'm going to do. ...Gary

Re: pen finish question...

#11

thanks Bernie,

GaryG in MD

That's good to know. ...Gary

Re: pen finish question...

#12

Barry,

GaryG in MD

Yeah, I've got some rattle-can lacquer too.

That's another alternative. Thanks, Gary

Re: pen finish question...

#13

Scott,

GaryG in MD

I think you may be right about the water-based poly.

As you say, there's one way to find out.

It's a cheap pen, so it won't be a big deal if it fails.

Better to find out now before the price goes up.

Re CA -- I know it makes a great finish, but it also causes permanent brain damage, regardless of whether it's "odorless" or not. I need all I've got left!

Thanks for the push, Gary

Re: pen finish question...

#14

Steve Kubien

220 grit

Steve Kubien

I think the thing you need to remember about MOST water-based poly's is that they are not made for woodturners. Unless it's a spindle project destined to be painted, does anyone stop at 220 grit? However, 220 is a perfectly suited place to stop for a lot of flat work, especially when using a random orbital sander.

Unless I TOTALLY botched a CA finish on a pen, I would never go back to 220. As others have said, all you need to do is scuff the surface for the next coat to adhere.

Just my 2 cents.

Re: pen finish question...

#15

Steve,

GaryG in MD

Thanks for your thoughts. I decided to give the WBPoly a shot.

I applied a very thin coat directly to my 4k sanded surface.

I'm letting it dry and cure overnight.

Then I'm going to go at it with my finger nails and see if I can get it to detach.

I'll report back... ...Gary

Re: pen finish question...

#16

Re: Scott,

Scott Greaves

Hi Gary!

I don't think the poly finish will fail, it's just a complex finish that will take some time to apply. I was thinking that scuffing the coats with 400 would probably be sufficient. I'm just thinking it would take six or eight thin coats to build up a sufficient finish. I'm a little impatient when it comes to pens. I spend five or ten minutes turning a pen, then fifteen or twenty sanding through to 12000 micro-mesh. At this point the idea of a multi-day finishing process is not appealing. So I go for a quicker option.

What a lot of turners do to help offset the CA fumes is to blow them away. Set up a fan to blow the fumes away from you, or maybe a dust collection system to suck them away. Yeah it's not perfect, but it will help a lot. But really, there are a lot of ways to finish pens. Try out a couple of different ones and pick one you like.

I know this is called "Woodturning", but another option is to turn pens from acrylics. No finish is really needed, just a good sanding and polishing process.

I'm just trying to be helpful. I happen to really like pen turning, and I think it is an important branch of Woodturning. If you'd like an example, find a current copy of Pen World magazine. We have pens by five of our IAP penturners in there, and they stand up well with the expensive commercial pens showcased throughout the rest of the magazine.

So keep up the good work, and please show us how things go with whatever finish you use.

Scott.

Re: pen finish question...

#17

Thank you, Scott...

GaryG in MD

I'm with you. I appreciate your comments and your obvious passion for pens.

I wasn't interested in them originally, but now that I've started, I can see the fun. I just got a new batch in today. One good thing for me is that I can do them inside during the winter because they don't make a big mess -- I usually have to turn most things outside, which limits me seasonally.

I agree completely (!) about the time spent and not wanting a lengthy process on top of the sanding. No way! With some woods I don't mind yellowing and just use the Crystal Coat (which is a simple shellac/French polish type of thing). What got me into this problem is the desire to keep some things not ambered. I can't do CA or lacquer or acrylic sprays in the house, but I'll probably try them when I can get outside again. There's a big difference between what I'd like to do and what I can do right now, but the weather is getting warm enough frequently now, so I'm about ready to make my move.

Thanks for the info on the IAP and magazine. I'll check it out.

I plan to stick with wood for now, but I do like the looks of some of those acrylics, so who knows...

Thanks for your support, Gary

Re: pen finish question...

#18

Alan Zenreich

Re: Alan,

Alan Zenreich

Gary,

The issue is that pens are handled over and over and over again, and in my opinion deserve a very durable finish.

An oil finish is fine for most of my work, but I generally would not consider it for pens.

Friction finish (a shellac base) is ok for low end pens. CA for higher end wood pens.

I know that there is much to be said about the look of an oil finish, but look again at that pen after a month of use. Some folk might like the "patina" that's developing where the fingers meet the pen... many others will just see it as an artifact of a less durable finish.

Some pen makers, years ago, actually touted their pen's ability to take on a patina... as a selling point. Others recognized it as a coverup for less than stellar workmanship.

Re: pen finish question...

#19

Re: pen finish question...

John Lucas

Gary I would suggest practicing on scrap. Take a 3/4" square piece about 2" long and just turn it round and play with finishes. Pine would work great since your worrying about yellowing.

How glossy a piece gets when finishing is simply how fine you sand the wood or the finish. You could sand with 80 grit and apply enough coats of finish to build it up and get a glossy finish. It will definitely look different than if you sand the wood to a finer grit before applying that many coats of finish and or course it will take more finish coats to get to the glossy stage.

That being said there is probably a point of sanding the wood that is unnecessary depending on the finish you use. I did a test on flat wood one day using 4 different finishes. I sanded the wood in sections up to 1200 grit. Beyond 400 grit no one in the club could see the difference when the finishes were applied and the finish was properly finished (sanded, finer and buffed with the Beal system). I took a lot of flak over it online because I didn't use turned wood and do intend to do that test some day it will just be a lot more work.

My point is based on my experience it isn't necessary to sand the wood to super fine grits before applying the finish. It is necessary to sand the finish to the super fine grits if you want that super gloss look. There may be some difference in how the wood looks or other materials. I know the pen turners practice finished much more than I do because my projects simply take a lot longer to make. It should not take very long to do a series of tests on scrap using your sandpaper and your finish. Then you will know.

Re: pen finish question...

#20

Alan Zenreich

Re: Alan,

Alan Zenreich

I forgot to mention that there are some oil base finishes that I find suitable for wood pens... but the finishing time increases quite a bit.

I'm quite fond of Tru-Oil. It's often used to put a durable finish on gunstocks.

It applies quite easily, and you can do a coat every few hours.

However, as with most polymerized oil finishes, it really should dry/cure for a week or so before buffing.

Re: pen finish question...

#21

Good to know...

GaryG in MD

I wasn't planning to use oil on pens -- just making a point about what I'm used to doing on other turnings...

Your point about shellac vs. CA is of definite interest.

I'm only making low-end pens now, because I'm learning and making mistakes, but I suppose I'll be moving up the food chain in the future, so your comments are of definite interest. ...Gary

Re: pen finish question...

#22

John,

GaryG in MD

Lots of good, practical info in your post; thanks!

I agree that experimentation is a good thing. But that's what WC is for. I let you do the experiment, and I get the benefits. ;-)

It's very interesting to me to hear you say that sanding to finer than 400 under a finish isn't necessary. I seem to recall asking a question about that some years ago and getting a wide variety of answers. As with most things, I'm sure the "truth" lies somewhere in between and is also a strong function of the end observer.

So experiment I will! ...Gary

Re: pen finish question...

#23

Re: John,

John Lucas

Gary There are advantages to sanding to higher grits. Some woods simply will show it more, some woods don't. Sanding to higher grits seems to require less finish to do the same job. As always experimenting is necessary because there are simply too many circumstances that vary between the wood, the turner, and the finish.