Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

First gouge

Posts

First gouge

#1

First gouge

Carole Valentine

Well, my very first gouge (Packard 3/8") is about to enter the turning tool retirement home. It just got too short to sharpen on my Wolverine but I am stubborn...I refuse to allow it to go the way of all good gouges....I will hand sharpen it until there is absolutely no flute left, then I will give what's left of a place of honor on my shop wall. I think when I bought that gouge, it was $16. It's been a good friend.

Re: First gouge

#2

Re: First gouge

RCH

My first gouge, also at Packard 3/8", also has about reached this point. I've flattened the top of the flute closest to the handle, including a bit of the unfluted shaft, to get it to fit into the Wolverine better. But retirement looms. I've tried a number of other 3/8" gouges, but I still go back to this one when I'm having a problem. I suspect I ought to just break down and buy another.

Re: First gouge

#3

Re: First gouge

john Veerkamp

Make a really short detail tool out of the un-fluted remainder. Shape the end however you like, scraper or pointed, maybe even a beading tool.

Re: First gouge

#4

Joe Fleming

Re: First gouge

Joe Fleming

Carole,

Two thoughts. First, the hardening of gouges does not go all the way to the bottom of the flute. Therefore, the very bottom of the flute is not really suitable for turning. Second, I just retired my first gouge. I ground it to the exact "perfect" profile for my gouge and now I use it to show and tell for sharpening demos and to se up my jig, when needed. I pulled the handle off and keep the tip covered in a rubber tip when not in use.

Joe

Re: First gouge

#5

Re: First gouge

Carole Valentine

Thanks, Joe. I wondered if the entire thing was hardened. I think I will just just put her on the wall with a plaque that reads "Teacher" 2005 -2012. ;) She led a good life - taught me many things and suffered much abuse while I learned to sharpen and and tried various grinds. I take so little steel from my other gouges when grinding that I suspect they will all outlive me.

Re: First gouge

#6

Lyle Jamieson

Re: First gouge

Lyle Jamieson

Take the handle off and get many more years as a sheer scraper. Without the handle in the way, you can maneuver where the handle hits the bed or headstock.

Re: First gouge

#7

Re: First gouge

Jorge

It was my second gouge, also a Packard 5/8" it is getting too short too.

Once I saw Beth Ireland sharpening free hand and told myself: "have to learn to do that", have not done it yet, maybe now is when... Is the fate of the favorite tools, they go first.

Re: First gouge

#8

Re: First gouge

Cyril Griesbach

Carole, when my first gouge, a 3/8 Sorby, got too short it went with my first lathe to a new club member.

Re: First gouge

#9

Re: First gouge

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

My first gouge was retired many years ago after I discovered that the last couple of inches wasn't tempered to hold an edge.

Until way back in 1982 or 83 I had never heard of a bowl gouge. Neither had almost any other turner. I think that they first came on the market in the US in around 1980. All made in the UK. Mine was a Sorby 1/2 inch. I'm sure it was my first HSS tool. The handle is only 12 inches long. They came ground square across like a roughing gouge. That was the way just about everyone used them. I can still remember an article and photo in Fine Woodwroking mag, The heading was...why not a fingernail grind?...A light came on. I headed for the shop, reground my gouge and it went from there. That was in about 1985.

Re: First gouge

#10

Retire it mounted on a nice plaque Carole,...

JamieDonaldson

..and include the purchase date to serve as a reminder of the good ol' days of learning, where we all started. I often remind turners to save their first bowl, rather than later toss it on the burn pile, to serve as an example of how far we've progressed. I have always considered our tools as old friends, counting the number of hours we spent together. ;)

Re: First gouge

#11

Mike Stafford

Re: First gouge

Mike Stafford

Carole, old gouges never die they just get ground away......

A friend of mine, Don Riggs, has a favorite 1/2" bowl gouge that he has ground until the flute is only about 1" long.

You should see him turn a sphere with it.....Amazing!

Re: First gouge

#12

Re: First gouge

jim 9 miles

Another idea: Get a piece of round 1" diam metal stock, drill hole to fit gouge, tap set screws

I use it to work extended over the rest the bottom of a bowl or HF

Does a lot that you just can't do with regular gouge

Re: First gouge

#13

Steven Antonucci

Haven't gotten there yet?

steven antonucci

I turn a lot, and I use a couple of tools frequently. Between my Tormek and my diamond hones, I guess I just consume them much more slowly?

I bought a bunch of Sorby stuff on eBay in 2003. Not even close to used up...wore out my bearing before I wore out the gouges...

Someday.

Steve

Re: First gouge

#14

Re: First gouge

Mike Foster

I have yet to retire a gouge. I guess it is because I keep adding more and I just don't turn as much as you. Give it a place of honor.

Re: First gouge

#15

I have a whole box full of tool stubs,........

JamieDonaldson

...and have always wished there was some good way to melt them all back into new tools! My Scottish ancestry prevents me from just tossing them! :D

Re: First gouge

#16

Re: First gouge

steve worcester

I thought it was all done in ovens , so why wouldn't it go all the way to the ends?

Re: First gouge

#17

Tool hardening is not uniform.......

JamieDonaldson

Steve- most tools are only inserted part way into the furnaces while being held in some type of holder, there are several methods employed by different makers. Tools with a small tang would be particularly dangerous if fully hardened, because the tang would be more brittle and subject to fracture when stressed, rather than bending. I had a gouge (a top brand from CA!) several years ago that was only hardened about the first 2" and the color change was as visible as the difference in sharpening.

Re: First gouge

#18

Re: Tool hardening is not uniform.......

steve worcester

For a forged tool, yes. I figured nowadays, it would be in an over with tool wrap or a salt bath immersion.