Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Holdfast vacuum chuck

Posts

Holdfast vacuum chuck

#1

Steve Kubien

Holdfast vacuum chuck

Steve Kubien

Does anyone here have any experience with the Holdfast vacuum chucking system? I'm looking for simple, easy and affordable and this looks like it will fit the bill.

My compressor is a Porter Cable pancake, 6 gallon and 2.6cfm @ 90psi. The Holdfast requires 2.5cfm @ 50-60psi so I am thinking I'm ok. I should note, that I won't be trying to run it for hours at a time, more like 1/2 hour bursts as need requires.

Thoughts?

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#2

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck *LINK*

Doc Green

Steve, I don't have any hands-on experience with the Holdfast system, but based on what I've read, I'm skeptical.

First, the system requires a Big air compressor. The PC pancake will be marginal, and it will be LOUD, as you well know. The compressor will have to run continuously.

In my opinion, a better way to go by far is to use a vacuum pump. The Gast pumps are best, but expensive unless you can find one on the surplus market. Another option is the diaphragm pump marketed by Stubby Lathe USA which is much less expensive than a new Gast pump and which costs only a bit more than the Holdfast vacuum generator.

I have one of the pumps sold by Stubby Lathe USA. It does the job, but it is not without issues. It tends to run hot, which they say is normal, but which concerns me. Also, a bit of a nuisance is the vibration of the pump. You will have to tie it down or it will try to walk away.

As you may be aware, you can build your own vacuum couplers and chucks, and it is not hard to do. Detailed instructions are given in my book, Fixtures and Chucks, but you can find information on line without having to buy the book.

Here is a link to the vacuum pump:

Good Luck, ~Doc


Stubby Lathe USA Vac Pump

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#3

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

John Lucas

Steve I don't own one but asked a lot of questions one time from the dealer. I had looked at Venturi style vacuum systems and ruled them out because they need too much air. That is until I saw the holdfast system. It requires much less volume and will work on small compressors. How small I don't remember but you probably looked up the specs.

It is much smaller and less expensive than going the vacuum motor pump system. Other than not needing a compressor I'm not sure if one system has an advantage over the other.

You will certainly love a vacuum system once you get one. It kind of like buying your first chuck. After you own one you don't know how you got along without it. I just used mine this morning to finish off the bottom of a platter a was doing.

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#4

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

John Lucas

I see Doc answered the same time I did. It does make a loud whining noise but I not nearly as bad as the older style venturi systems and as I mentioned doesn't take as large of a compressor.

I think maybe Bill Grumbine was selling them for awhile. You might contact him and get his opinions.

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#5

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

tevans9129

My first vacuum system was the Holdfast, which I still have. It worked flawlessly for me using a 5hp commercial duty compressor with a 60-gallon tank. I use the vac a lot, for not only cleaning up the bottoms but also for sanding and finishing and found the compressor was running a lot.

I did not like running a 5hp motor when the same could be done with a 1/4hp one. What proved to be a nuisance to me with the Holdfast was the installing and removal of the adapter through the spindle so frequently. I modified the hand wheel on a 1642 and built an adapter with O rings so that it can be pushed in and pulled out easily and quickly. A slightly used Gast was found on EBay which is quieter and less costly to operate. My guess is that you will use it a lot once you start, good luck.

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#6

Dick Hines

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

dick hines

Once you use a vacuum chuck you will not want to do with out. I have no relation with this companmy but have had good service from them

www.jtturningtools.com

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#7

Brian McKearney

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

Brian McKearney

I don't mean to bash anyone, but be careful doing business with JT Turning Tools. I purchased the "Precision Vacuum Chuck Hub" almost one year ago. I still use it and I like it. BUT...

The problem that I had was this: when I received the chuck hub, the threads didn't go far enough to allow the hub to snug up to the spindle shoulder. My concern was that if the chuck bottoms out on the threads rather than snugging up to the spindle shoulder, then this is a good place to lose vacuum pressure and just doesn't fit correctly.

I contacted the company and someone (I forget his name, but I think that he was the owner) contacted me promptly. We exchanged messages and talked in person several times and he said that he would make right by my purchase. Then I asked to return the chuck hub and get one with the threads cut slightly deeper so that it would snug up to the spindle shoulder on my Oneway 1640 - I even sent detailed pictures to show the issue as it was about a eighth of an inch off.

After asking to get a new chuck (or repair the one that I had) that fit properly, all contact ended and I never heard from him again! Not a single word or message! Not exactly "doing right by the purchase" if you ask me. I ended up fixing the problem myself by grinding away at the chuck with a dremel tool. Just didn't seem like I should have to do that after paying $70!

Beware!

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#8

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

tevans9129

I had an order ready to send until it showed $18 for shipping. When I sent an email asking about a more reasonable method of shipping, he pretty much responded that he thought the shipping was fair. For about the cost of his shipping charge, I purchased some 6061 aluminum and made my own and it fits like it is suppose to. Had he quoted shipping less than $10, I would have ordered from him. Exorbitant shipping charges is a pet peeve with me and I try not to do business with those that try to pad their profit with unreasonable shipping.

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#9

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

J Dahn

I have a holdfast working with a 27gal 5.6cfm compressor. It is good for short efforts under 60 min. The compressor just runs too much otherwise. I picked mine up at a significant discount otherwise I would go the vac pump route. Like others have said, once you start using a vac pump you'll love it. Don't forget to pick up a tailstock adapter that fits your headstock thread. That way you can unscrew you chuck mount it to your tailstock and easily center your workpiece in the vac chuck.

Good luck

Jake

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#10

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

Chip in Plano

I own one and use a pancake compressor. I have not have any problems with the Holdfast except it won't hold burls or banksia pods (duh). It was a gift to me but I am a satisfied customer. I only have 2 cups both of which are the standard Holdfast ones: the small one (3"?) and the 6" one. I need an something in-between but as long as I keep the tailstock in position the 3" one does fine.

I looked at several DIY vac setups and frankly building one bored me to death. I'm a business person not an engineer. I will at some point replace my setup. I'll likely replace my compressor for a big one before I will buy a good quality Gast pump....the compressor has far more uses for the $$.

The drawback with the pancake processor is that that it will cycle on/off. When it cycles on...it usually scares the heck out of me. I generally only use it for finishing the bottom of pieces so my time on vacuum is anywhere from 5min-20min. I did buy a spindle extension from Best Tools (has to have a hole thru it) which was a great investment since I can do deep bowls without hitting the headstock. I'm not crazy about the nylon washers that are used but I swear you will do it once without them and figure out why they exist....and I don't experience any suction lose with them so long as they are clean going on.

It's been said already...once you go vacuum, you will wonder why you waited so long. I still use my donut chuck on my other lathe when I don't want to setup the vac on the PM; otherwise, I will complete 5-6 pieces then setup the vac to finish them en masse.

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#11

Bill Blasic

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

Bill Blasic

You could try going to a appliance dealer and see if you can get a pump from a dehumidifier. I'm using one and it is quiet and draws 25. Cost was free.

Bill

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#12

Steve Kubien

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

Steve Kubien

Loads of great comments here and for that, I thank you all. I will certainly look at the Stubby vac but as one of you mentioned, I have almost zero interest/patience for building a system. Just not my idea of fun.

Cheers.

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#13

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

Chuck Bjorgen

Steve -- I was reluctant to comment on your question because although I bought the Holdfast system last year, I had not yet set it up because I moved my turning operation to my garage and it is unheated and turning for me has become more of a fair weather activity here in Minnesota. Having said that I did a lot of research on the Holdfast unit, reading both skeptical comments from those who never used it, and comments from those who bought and liked it. There were also a few who bought it and moved over to the vacuum pump systems. I have a fairly big compressor in my garage as well as the pancake style and was pretty convinced either would work for me. Wish I could back this up with proven experience though.

Like you, I did not want to go through building my own system. I should be back into turning in a few weeks and probably will use vacuum chucking mainly for finishing bowl bottoms or other similar projects. Your reasons for considering the Holdfast seem very much like mine.

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#14

Steve Kubien

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

Steve Kubien

An unheated shop in Minnesota? Dude, that's inhumane!!!

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#15

Re: Vacuum pump and JT Turning Tools

Jerry

One of the posts in this thread refers to service from J T Turning Tools as being unsatisfactory. I wanted everyone to know that I have received great service from their representative, Tom Steyer. I purchased JT's vacuum chuck system for my Delta mini lathe, as well as a few other tools. The vacuum chuck system was easy to install and works wonderfully with my Gast pump. He even provided a brass fitting I needed to connect his air hose to my pump, at no charge.

I sent the post with the negative comments to Tom because I knew he would be concerned. Tom checked his records to locate that person's order. Tom was not able to identify the person or the issue. Tom encouraged that person to recontact him to resolve the issue because he wants to maintain his reputation as always providing responsive and excellent service.

I just thought everyone should know about Tom's excellent products and service.

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#16

Brian McKearney

Re: Vacuum pump and JT Turning Tools

Brian McKearney

Jerry,

Thanks for following up - I'm surprised that he doesn't remember me since we talked on the phone several times about this issue and I sent him direct mail with pics, etc.

As I said before, he was very attentive to me until I asked for a fix and that's when all communication ended - kinda like he dropped off the face of the earth. I finally gave up and fixed the problem myself, but as I stated in my original post, I was disappointed that I had to "fix" a product that cost me nearly $100.

After my fix, the vacuum hub that I bought is working fine for me. It just wasn't the kind of experience that I'd like to repeat and didn't seem at all satisfactory.

Brian

Re: Holdfast vacuum chuck

#17

Re: Vacuum pump and JT Turning Tools

Bernie Weishapl

I have been doing business with Tom for several years now. I have his complete vacuum system that he sold me about 4 yrs ago along with other tools. I have had nothing but excellent service from him. He has made good on any problems I have had.