Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

What tool do I need to use?

Posts

What tool do I need to use?

#1

What tool do I need to use?

Dustmaker Mike

alright I have three orders for the Circuit Boards pens and I know I will get more when I deliver these. So now my question is very simple. What is the best tool to use to cut these without them chipping out just before I finish them. I have a few practice ones that did just that to me when I was using a sharp gouge. The folks at Woodcraft said a Carbide chisel would be better but before I spend the money on one what does the collective knowledge think? More practice with the gouge or?

TIA

Re: What tool do I need to use?

#2

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: What tool do I need to use?

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Mike,

Can you give us a few more details on what you are turning?

Dennis

Re: What tool do I need to use?

#3

Re: What tool do I need to use?

John Lucas

Don't believe a carbide scraper will cut cleaner than a properly sharpened gouge. On rare occasions a scraper is better but usually it's on very hard very brittle materials. Use the gouge. Let the tool do the cutting, don't force it. speed up the lathe and take light passes. That helps you keep from forcing the cut.

The Hunter tools are the exception to the carbide tools but only if you rub the bevel and use them like you would gouge. That is an advanced technique and hard to do unless you have a fair amount of experience with gouges.

Even then I don't think the Hunter tools will leave a finish any better than a sharp gouge.

Re: What tool do I need to use?

#4

for those not familiar...

GaryG in MD

...with the material, it can be seen on page 118 of the new PSI catalog.

It's a new pen blank supposedly made from "genuine circuit board components". It says it's "laminated with UV resistant polyester resin. I haven't seen them in person, but it almost sounds to me like maybe you're not supposed to turn down into the actual metal bits -- just shape by removing some of the lamination resin.

If you're actually supposed to turn the metal bits, then I can see that they might be prone to pulling out of the base material if your tools aren't super sharp and presented at the proper cutting angle.

I certainly wouldn't go to carbide (except maybe the micro-grain stuff) because you can't get carbide as sharp as HSS. That's off the grinder, of course. If you don't resharpen frequently, then your carbide, in practice, may be sharper than your HSS. But that's bad practice. I would recommend using a freshly sharpened and honed HSS skew.

Give us some more details. What's actually happening? ...Gary

Re: What tool do I need to use?

#5

Harry Robinette

Re: What tool do I need to use?

Harry Robinette

Mike

Yes the EWT's work very well on the circuit board pens. I've done maybe 6 or 7 of them and I use the round EWT finisher. The acrylic they use is very hard and brittle so they work much better then gouges.

I have the Hunter tools and they don't work well on these you need the flat type.

Just my $.02

Re: What tool do I need to use?

#6

Re: What tool do I need to use? *LINK*

Jeff Willaford

I use a skew for any acrylics I turn but many people seem to like the carbide cutters. You might want to check out the International Association of Penturners (IAP) website for more suggestions/input.


http://www.penturners.org/forum/index.php

Re: What tool do I need to use?

#7

Re: What tool do I need to use? *LINK*

Dick Coers

Here's an excellent video from Ed Brown. He's a regular on the IAP site.


polyester resin turning

Re: What tool do I need to use?

#8

Re: What tool do I need to use?

David Walser

Mike,

I've made a handful of the circuit board pens and have had good success using a roughing gouge to turn the blank down to about 1/16" proud of the bushings. I then use a negative rake scraper to smooth the surface -- leaving it about 1/32" above the bushing. (A skew laid on its side works well for this.) Sanding and polishing will take you down the rest of the way. You want to leave the blank slightly proud of the bushings, or you'll risk hitting the circuit board.

Hope this helps, and good luck!

Re: What tool do I need to use?

#9

Re: What tool do I need to use?

Terry Scott

Razer sharp 55 degree bowl gouge

Then sand with wet and dry with oil to 4000 grit

Re: What tool do I need to use?

#10

Re: What tool do I need to use?

John Lucas

I have to respectfully dissagree. I turn a lot of acrylic and other very hard materials. If your getting chip out your pushing the tool faster than it wants to cut. It takes a steady hand and slow feed rate. When you do it right your get curls coming off and a very clean surface.

I will say that I've never turned the circuit board material but have turned acrylics with metal inlayed in and I can turn it quite successfully using my Thompson detail gouge or my #4 or #5 Hunter tool.

Re: What tool do I need to use?

#11

What is happening

Dustmaker Mike

You are correct in saying you do not turn it down to the metal inside. I turn it down to just about the size of the bushings and bang 1 out of three chip the resin.

Thanks

Re: What tool do I need to use?

#12

Thanks I will

Dustmaker Mike

Try slowing down I have turned a few of these with mixed results. I keep the gouge sharp and the speed up on the lathe. I will try one an slow down my cutting speed and see what happens. The chip out is normally by one of the bushings and it is a little nick. I keep these and the ones that come out all right I sell.

Thanks

Re: What tool do I need to use?

#13

That is the tool

Dustmaker Mike

the person form Woodcraft is recommending. Thanks

Re: What tool do I need to use?

#14

Thanks For the links

Dustmaker Mike

I have not tried a Skew but maybe this weekend.

Thanks

Re: What tool do I need to use?

#15

Re: Thanks I will

john lucas

Mike You can of course use a carbide scraper type tool and many do with success. I just know from experience that I can get a cleaner finish off a sharp tool which of course saves me from sanding as much.

Re: What tool do I need to use?

#16

another thought...

GaryG in MD

Mike,

What John said is very true. Don't rush the cut.

Another possibility: from which direction are you cutting the ends at the bushings? I have found that it's best to work from the outside into the blank. That provides support for the cut. If you work from the inside out, there's nothing there for support, and it's very easy to get chipping off the ends of the blank.

Just a thought... ...Gary

Re: What tool do I need to use?

#17

Thanks

Dustmaker Mike

I will have to pay attention to this. I am pretty sure I always cut toward the bushing.

Re: What tool do I need to use?

#18

I think that's the problem!

GaryG in MD

It's never good to push a tool through an unsupported edge.

I always leave a small amount and come back at it from the other direction.

Give it a try, and I'll bet you don't get chips. ...Gary

Re: What tool do I need to use?

#19

Re: I think that's the problem!

Lloyd in Mississauga

Coming onto the end is what I needed to do to keep zebra wood blank cut on a diagonal for a pen from knocking the end out.

I found in that case to work onto the end gave a better chance of success than working off of the end.

small light cuts, it is not a race.

Lloyd