Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Headstock alignment

Posts

Headstock alignment

#1

Headstock alignment

John Lucas

I've been trying to figure out a way to check headstock alignment other than running the tailstock up so centers touch This only tells you if the points meet and not whether the headstock is parallel to the ways.

I just purchased a boresight to sight in rifle scopes and thought, why not, so I headed to the lathe. I selected the right adaptor and inserted it in the morse taper. As you can see in the top photo it is off a little. As I rotate the spindle the laser dot makes a circle around the center of the tailstock. The second photo sort of shows that but it reflected off the sides of the center point and looks like the whole thing is lit up like a car cigarette lighter.

So does that tell me anything? Is the boresight off center? Is the lathe spindle off center? Why would it rotate around the center? I thought maybe it wasn't aligning correctly with the Morse taper so I turned a wooden morse taper and center drilled it with a #5 drill and put the boresight in that. It had exactly the same circular rotation. So I'm back to the original question, is it the boresight?

Re: Headstock alignment

#2

Re: Headstock alignment

Bart Leetch

I just know you'll feel better about this when you can hit a 4 point buck at 300 yards; sorry I couldn't help my self.

Why don't you put piece of wood in that is as long as you can turn on your lathe turn it round the check the tail end of it to see how out of round it is as compared to the head end? That will indicate how far out of round you can possibly turn at the full length your lathe can turn.

Re: Headstock alignment

#3

Ted Calver

Re: Headstock alignment

Ted Calver

John, I've wondered why someone hasn't come up with a commercial laser alignment gizmo for lathes and thought about adapting a bore sight. When I looked, the specs all listed an effective 'range' with a minimum distance that was several feet longer than my lathe so I backed off from the idea. It seems to me that in order to be accurate the laser would have to be tuned to typical lathe bed lengths with a much smaller dot than what we see on a typical hollowing rig set up. My lathe has a little over an 8' bed and I sure could use such a device. I'm curious to hear what others think.

Re: Headstock alignment

#4

Re: Headstock alignment

Stuart Johnson

Can you change your setup so the light comes from the headstock? If so you can mark where it hits on a flat surface and then see if it rotates around a point. I think this would let you know if the spindle is the issue or the tailstock.

Re: Headstock alignment

#5

Re: Headstock alignment

John Lucas

Bart don't think that would work. Anything very long would chatter too much unless supported by the tailstock. Supporting it by the tailstock would mean it would be turned round

Re: Headstock alignment

#6

Re: Headstock alignment

John Lucas

Ted I would think a minimum distance would be due to parallax not accuracy of the laser. In theory the laser should align with the bore and all I'm trying to do is find out if the spindle is aligned parallel to the bed. It's obviously pretty close since it's about 3/16" off at 32", but it's either not dead on or the bore sight is off.

Re: Headstock alignment

#7

Re: Headstock alignment

John Lucas

Stuart The light is coming from the headstock.

Re: Headstock alignment

#8

Re: Headstock alignment

Stuart Johnson

Only in the pictures and your description. If I ever get together and start seeing, thinking, saying and doing at the same time the world is in trouble :\

Re: Headstock alignment

#9

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Headstock alignment

Dennis in Southern Oregon

John, in the first photo, if the circle swept out on the live center by the laser dot is exactly centered, then the axis of rotation of the headstock spindle is perfectly aligned with the tailstock. The fact that the circle is not of zero radius means that optical center of the laser is either not centered on and/or not parallel to the headstock axis of rotation. Try moving the tailstock inward and see if the diameter of the circle decreases. If it decreases, at least part of the error is caused by nonparallelism. If there is no change in diameter the problem is an offset error in your test fixture. Possible causes of nonparallelism are bent headstock shaft, dirty morse taper or machining error in the piece that is inserted into the morse taper.

Dennis

Re: Headstock alignment

#10

Dennis is on the right path, because...

JamieDonaldson

.. if there was any deviation from a center point of the laser spot when the headstock spindle is slowly rotated, then either the laser is not accurately centered in the spindle, or the spindle is not running true.

Re: Headstock alignment

#11

Re: Headstock alignment

Doc Green

John, when you rotate the headstock spindle, does the laser dot on the live center stay the same distance from the point? Or put differently, is the circle traced by the dot centered on the point?

If it does (or is), the misalignment is with the laser and/or the way it's mounted in the spindle.

If the circle traveled by the dot is displaced to one side, the cause could be that the ways of the lathe are twisted.

From the bottom photo, it appears that the circle is pretty well centered. However, if the circle were displaced by 1/8", the indication would be that the twist amounts to only about 0.7 degrees.

Also, if the spindle is not perfectly aligned with the ways, the circle traversed by the dot will be offset from the center point. So you have two causes for a displaced circle: twist of the ways and a misaligned spindle.

It may be interesting to adjust one of the leveling screws and see if it has any effect. It doesn't matter which end of the lathe you adjust. What this should do is shift the circle relative to the center point of the live center.

I might add that a displacement of the dot of 3/16" over 32" is not much at all. I don't think you could observe any effect from it in a practical turning situation.

~Doc

Re: Headstock alignment

#12

Oops ... Great minds, I guess ...


Re: Headstock alignment

#13

Re: Headstock alignment

clay foster

So, John, if you find out the headstock doesn't run true or that the bed is warped or bowed or twisted, what are you going to do about it?

Re: Headstock alignment

#14

Re: Headstock alignment

steve worcester

About the closest I have seen is this device I use for mill setup

http://lasercenteredgefinder.com/

You can test how centered the laser is by putting it in a drill press chuck (as close as we can get anyway) and site it, put a dot there and then rotate by hand.

I suppose you could always test runout of the chuck you are using to hold the laser and then runout of the laser also to see if it is centered in the holder.

Re: Headstock alignment

#15

Re: Oops ... Great minds, I guess ...

John Lucas

Doc Dennis and Jamie, yes the circle is pretty much centered which of course made me think the laser is off also. This wasn't a high dollar bore sight and I realize that it's just supposed to be a ball park thing and you sight in the rifle by firing anyway. Just wanted to speed up that process a little and thought I'd try it on the lathe.

I forgot to mention that my Delta 46-460 is dead on using the laser. Of course the tailstock is only 16" away on that lathe.

Re: Headstock alignment

#16

I'll throw away my lathe 


Re: Headstock alignment

#17

Many lathe owners have no clear.....

JamieDonaldson

...understanding about how much even a heavy cast iron machine like a lathe can suffer alignment distortions. Proper leveling can often true a warped bed to some degree, but until recent lathe evolution with individually adjustable legs, we often had to shim in very crude adjustments. If a lathe is moved, even slightly, there is potential for misalignments, because concrete slabs are seldom close to true flat level. We can rack a casting by attempting to rough an out of balance blank, overtightening between centers, and any number of other operations that stress the machine. Proper alignment priorities increase with the increase in precision expected in the work that the machine performs, such as a wood lathe compared to a metal lathe or mill. And many wood lathe owners attempt to anchor a lathe to the floor, to reduce walking the lathe around the shop with an unbalanced blank, and I've seen several cracked castings or mounting supports resulting from this abuse. The extreme alignment examples are the optical benches that I used in my past occupation, now aligned by laser assisted jigs.

Re: Headstock alignment

#18

Re: Headstock alignment

Dale Cook

Hi John, is it possible that with a lathe like the powermatic and the sliding headstock that there is a tiny amount of play when you reset the headstock after hollowing or whenever it's moved. I'm wondering if you can loosen the headstock lever and line up the light and tighten it . I don't know but it might be possible if there's any play in it.

Re: Headstock alignment

#19

Re: Headstock alignment

John Lucas

Dale I had planned to try that but had to get on to other projects. Now that I have those moving along I will probably have time to give it a try later in the week. I'll let everyone know how it goes.

This topic of lathe alignment peaked my interest ever since Vic from Bestwoodtools and I got to discussing how accurate wood lathes are compared to metal lathes. The topic of angular alignment of the head stock components came up and I've wanted to see how to measure this and more importantly, as some have stated, is this even a problem when building most turnings.

Re: Headstock alignment

#20

Good point Dale

Jorge

When I move the head, I use a double Morse aligner I got from Teknatool, there may be others, stick it on the head, bring the tail and snug both, then tighten. Maybe is not perfect in my Powermatic, but it is a lot better than it was on the Nova 3000.

Re: Headstock alignment

#21

Re: Headstock alignment

Don Evans

John:

The bore sights I'm familiar with have a rod attached to them that is sized based on the bore of the rifle. Is this the type you have?

One thing you should do to test the sight itself is to rotate it while the spindle is locked solid (some spindle locks still allow it to move slightly) you need to lock it some way it cannot move at all.

Next turn ONLY the bore sight itself and see what happens. If the light moves in the circle as when you move the spindle then you'll know the sight is off.

I gave thought to this same method several years ago when I have a Nova 3000. I came to the conclusion that the laser would have to be aligned thru the spindle to ensure accuracy of it's own set up. I designed a target insert for the left end of the spindle and another for the right end of the spindle. These would be used to align the light dead center of the spindle, then go from there with the alignment. I did this mentally only, I didn't think it practical to really proceed with making any of it. One reason is the tool accuracy in our own shops isn't good enough to make what is needed. It may be practical to make a device that sits on the ways with a target spot (which could simply be a small hole that the light shines through. But it would have to be alignable with the ways probably using the opening between the ways.

I like the Nova but the alignment problem with it's movable head drove me nuts sometimes with so of the precision I needed. I came to the conclusion that my only recourse was to sell it and get a Oneway 2436 and it would be less stressful and more successful and that has turned out to be true.

Second quesion is why a #5 drill, that doesn't fit any gun caliber that I know of?

Is it for a .22 if so doesn't the sight now have slop with the .204 hole of a #5?

Purhaps that machine accuracy mention earlier is reason for that size? A #2 bit would be .221.

Don

Re: Headstock alignment

#22

Re: Headstock alignment

john lucas

Don I used one of the caliber adaptors that came with it to properly fit the "bore" of my lathe. The front end of the bore sight is tapered so it set nicely against the morse taper.

Re: Headstock alignment

#23

Steven Antonucci

put it in my truck and i'll bring it to the dump:)


Re: Headstock alignment

#24

You sure you wanna go Mustard Yellow