Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Madrone 'ginger jar'

Posts

Madrone 'ginger jar'

#1

Madrone 'ginger jar'

mjonesrdg

I seldom see a turning from straight grain Madrone as this wood is so prone to splitting. It is highly desirable in my area for use as firewood. The slick bark, (clean) and high BTU rating, gets woodcutters a premium price for it over the best of all other local hardwoods. My 'ginger jar' shown below is particularly unique in that there is very visible natural blue-stain throughout. Something we regularly see in pine, but not Madrone. A better photographer could likely capture that color

for you. All comments, critiques, and suggestions appreciated.

Re: Madrone 'ginger jar'

#2

Re: Madrone 'ginger jar'

Ed Larson

Nice ginger jar. What are the dimensions??

Re: Madrone 'ginger jar'

#3

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Madrone 'ginger jar'

Dennis in Southern Oregon

A very nice piece. I like it. I also live in madrone country, and when I started turning seriously about 15 years ago, madrone was what was available for the cutting on my property, so much of my work makes use of it. It needs to be rough turned or finish turned while green to minimize the chance of splitting, but despite this, it is an easy wood to turn and very versatile in the things that you can do with it. Boiling rough turned pieces seems to increase the survival rate quite a bit.

Dennis

Re: Madrone 'ginger jar'

#4

Steven Antonucci

Help me understand the lid?

steven antonucci

In looking at the picture, I think it is a lid with a collar? There is a small gap between the vessel and the collar that looks like it is either a lid that is in crooked for the picture or the collar needed to be 1/32 smaller to sit flush?

What is the secondary wood? Same top and bottom? One looks darker than the other, but I am assuming that's just lighting.

Steve

Re: Madrone 'ginger jar'

#5

Mike,

GaryG in MD

First and foremost, that's a VERY nice vessel.

You did a great job with it.

If you want me to be picky, I have two comments:

First, like Steve, I see the gap. Hey, it's madrone! We understand why it's there. But depending on how you've done the lid, if you wanted to, you might be able to sand that irregularity flat so it seats with no gap. Or not... just a thought.

The second thing is design. No accounting for taste, so this is just my 2¢.

To my eye, in the photo, the finial dominates the piece. This may not be the case in the 3-D world. You have to be the judge of that. For my way of seeing in 2-D, I think it might blend into the overall form better if it were about 20% shorter. Stick your finger up to the screen and block out the top fifth of the finial and see if you agree or not. When I do that, my eye tends to drop automatically away from the finial and to the swell of the vessel.

That's what's fun about WC. We can play "what if" games like this.

...Gary

Re: Madrone 'ginger jar'

#6

Thanks, guys!

mjonesrdg

I honestly did not see the problem with the lid...and you are right, the collar is not flat and will be easily fixed. The missus has snagged this one so I won't change anything 'till it has been in the house for a year or so.

Re: Madrone 'ginger jar'

#7

Don Leydens

Re: Madrone 'ginger jar'

Don Leydens

Very nice piece, Mike. I like everything about it. Well done.

Re: Madrone 'ginger jar'

#8

Ellis Walentine

Re: Madrone 'ginger jar'

Ellis Walentine

Lovely piece, Mike. It does look like you took the photo with a fairly wide angle setting, with your lens about level with the middle of the finial. That would tend to distort the view a bit. I'd like to see a shot with a medium telephoto setting, from further back.

Anyhow, the madrone I've worked with in the past has been much deeper in color, almost like redwood. Is this another variety of madrone, or is the color quite variable from tree to tree?

Ellis

Re: Madrone 'ginger jar'

#9

Re: Madrone 'ginger jar'

mjonesrdg

Thanks Ellis,

I am known to be camera challenged, and suppose as I go along I'll learn and do better. Since this piece will stay home for a year or so, I'll have opportunity to try shooting with telephoto another day.

Arbutus is Arbutus as far as I know, and all that I have had experience with presents with a pale straw and with pink to red hues. The knots on the piece you see are quite red. I turned a piece a few years ago that was root burl and much darker throughout (like manzanita). I've seen some burl that when fresh cut was real pink-in-white. Our WC friend, Dennis in So, Oregon has more experience with it than I....he might pop in here again and answer your questions.

Mike in Redding, Ca