Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

hollowing with the pith left in

Posts

hollowing with the pith left in

#1

hollowing with the pith left in

eliotandmax

I don't do it, but, frankly, I don't see why not. I can see several advantages with the only disadvantage being the problem of plugging the hole at the bottom. I would say that the aesthetics of a good-looking vessel trump the problem of the plug. Is there some deeper( no pun intended) reason to avoid it?

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

#2

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

john lucas

I've done it both ways. I prefer not to leave the pith in because the chance of checking is just too great on most woods. I have also turned hollow vessels with the pith in the bottom and cut it out and plugged it after the vessel has dried and warped. I just go back and clean up the hole and put a plug in with matching wood.

Just for interest sake one time I cut the plug out with the pith in it. I dried the pith plug (say that 3 times real fast) using the plastic bag method. put it in a plastic bag and turn the bag inside out every day. that really really slows down the drying time. I've done it several times and been able to save limb sections and such with the pith in it. These were fairly thin, probably 3/8".

Dave Barriger showed me that if you make the pith area cone shaped it is less likely to check. When the wood dryies it warps. A flat pith area will simply check because it can't warp. If it's cone shaped the wood tends to shrink and elongate. think of an ice cream cone getting smaller at the top and taller and you'll get the idea. I've tried it once and it seemed to work but once of course could have been pure luck.

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

#3

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

clay foster

One consideration is the grain pattern. Pith included has an entirely different look from no pith. There's not a right or wrong, just very different.

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

#4

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

Joe Meirhaeghe

I've hollowed 100 plus vessels leaving the pith in them. I always center the piece on the pith so when there hollowed the pith is all removed except for 3/8" to 1/2" in the very bottom of the piece. I turn the tenon at the bottom of the piece to 3/4" to 1" diameter depending on the size of the vessel which also relieves a lot of stress. I've had very good success with this method. That said some pieces will crack no matter what you do, it just happens.

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

#5

You have many options once you ......

JamieDonaldson

...decide to take a chance by leaving the pith in your vessels. This is a piece of Elm turned green many years ago, and with the pith running horizontally and turned quite thin, it puckered out the sides like a football!

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

#6

Re: You have many options once you ......

R Henrickson

Or leave the pith elsewhere. Some cracking may result, but thinning (and sometimes a bit of CA) usually lessens the problem. This was turned from a pin oak branch with very offcenter pith, cut earlier that day. Just off the lathe, with no finish other than a single coat of thinned sanding sealer. The pith in the shoulder was slightly cracked when I started turning, but the grain pattern tempted me to continue.

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

#7

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

George Van Beynen

Eliot, I do not remove the pith. I will at times stabilize the pith with CA glue if I feel necessary. As John said it is helpful to cone the pith in rather than flat and also a thin base to allow some flex. I try to keep the pith on center as I have had unpleasant warping (sometimes grotesque) and instability when placing the pith to the side. I like the effect of the concentric rings in some woods when hollowed end grain with the pith included. The problem if any is that the opening at times has to be larger than I wanted due to the existing checking or rot at the pith that has to be removed to create a pleasing entry into the vessel.

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

#8

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

Phil Powell

Hi George,

Great pott! The grain and balance of the grain is perfect. Great piece.

Good to seeyouon here.

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

#9

Gorgeous!

mjonesrdg

...and I like the informal setting for the photo.

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

#10

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

eliotandmax

George, it's your PIC that I more or less have in mind. I mean right down the center of the pith. I can't see any reason, if you do it this way, why there should be any significant warping, especially if turned thin right away. Your piece is especially good looking! It is certainly the case that one can get a bigger vessel this way from a relatively smaller section of the log. I don't see why more hollow turners don't do it this way.

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

#11

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

George Van Beynen

Hi Phil,

I should be getting to that piece of walnut you gave me a few years ago. I am recovering from surgery on both of my feet so it will still be a month or so. The roughed out pot should be dry by now! :D

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

#12

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

Phil Powell

George, I do hope everything is healing up well and you're feeling well to.

remember George "You may grow another inch but you'll never grow

another foot". So take care!

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

#13

Brad Vietje

Beauty!  How Old is it?

Brad Vietje

--or --

Has it had time to fully dry, or was the photo taken just after it was finished? I'd expect a bump to develop there, and wonder if that's what happened (or is currently happening).

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

#14

Brad Vietje

Lovely Piece, George!

Brad Vietje

Looks like Butternut. I've had good success doing this with B'nut, Walnut, and White Ash, but it's trickier with Sugar Maple, Black Cherry, Apple, and other fruit woods.

Very nice H.F. with a beautiful form!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

Keith Tompkins

Nice one George...looks like butternut!

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

#16

Re: Beauty!  How Old is it?

RCH

I had made the last cut about 10 minutes earlier. Now, after about 10 days, there is still very little distortion at either pith. It was fresh-cut -- still part of the tree about 6 hours before I turned it.

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

#17

Re: hollowing with the pith left in

George Van Beynen

Thanks Keith, Butternut it is. :)