Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Is this workable?

Posts

Is this workable?

#1

Is this workable?

Terry in Ottawa

A friend gave me a cherry bowl blank but it has some cracks that concern me. This picture shows a crack on the face grain that descends into end grain and then seems to follow a growth ring. Could be ring shake as I understand it.

What do you think, could this be turned?


Re: Is this workable?

#2

Re: Is this workable?

GaryG in MD

That looks pretty bad to me. I try hard to save nice blanks, and I'll work around or with some minor cracks, but with this one, I'd be concerned about safety, as well as the attractiveness of the end product. If it were mine, I'd be tempted to chainsaw away the cracked part and turn the rest into something smaller -- if it's not also cracked on the other side too. Per John Jordan, "Life is too short to turn crappy wood." ...Gary

Re: Is this workable?

#3

Not as that size....

Dick Coers

but split it open on the crack on the pith and use the other side for a smaller vessel. Maybe cut around the bad half and make some boxes or ornaments. There are lots of smaller projects that could be made, but to use that blank for the bowl intended is inviting disaster.

Re: Is this workable?

#4

Re: Is this workable?

Brian McInturff

I sure wouldn't attempt a bowl from that. Accident waiting to happen.

Re: Is this workable?

#5

Small pieces or firewood!


Re: Is this workable?

#6

Re: Is this workable?

robo hippy

It could be done, but is not worth the extra work to get a finished product or the extra risk, which is considerable. I would have cut it for box or small hollow form blanks. Maybe tops.

robo hippy

Re: Is this workable?

#7

Re: Is this workable?

Lewis Dodd

Welcomke to the world of CHERRY!

Re: Is this workable?

#8

Rob Wallace

"Life's too short to turn crappy wood".....

Rob Wallace

.......right John?

;)

Rob

Re: Is this workable?

#9

Re: NO, it isn't turnable ALSO

Don Evans

Isn't this a great photo to give us the opportunity to clarify the "pith" statements that are made?

So here it is for debate and prediction is we will not agree on all of it but:

Ignoring the large crack for a moment, look at the pith area. It appears that the cut was made right down the very side of the pith. This is incorrect IMO but we are all guilty of saying "cut down the pith" when we should be saying, find the pith, move over 1/2" or slightly more and make a cut. Note where the crack ends (small one in middle) at the prominent growth ring. That ring is where it should have been split and I believe none of the cracks would be there, not even the big one. There is a lot of stress in those small rings in the middle. When the larger rings began to dry faster the little one's resisted and cause the large crack also.

Point is, by not removing more center rings it caused all the problems.

I'll also bet that this piece was too green before it was brough into a heated area. Green wood I air dry in unheated, no sun, area (garage) for several months before bringing into the shop which is heated all the time, I then try to put it in my home made kiln which I start out at 85 deg for month then go up to 95 deg for 3 months. I've had excellent success with this method.

Don

Re: Is this workable?

#10

NOT worth it.

Don Orr

As others have already said this is just not worth the trouble. Cut it down into smaller blanks maybe.

The other Don is correct about cutting a section out on either side of the pith when ripping logs into halves. Since I started doing it I have had much more success getting blanks that stayed solid.

Re: Is this workable?

#11

Brad Vietje

NO -- Not as a Bowl (Dangerous).

Brad Vietje

I'd split it into spindle and/or box blanks.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Is this workable?

#12

Re: Is this workable?

jim 9 miles

Try driving wedges- or screwdrivers along crack and go ahead and split it apart. Glue it back together.

might be able to use band clamps to clamp it back. If you get a good glue joint turn it , if not you haven't lost anything.

Re: Is this workable?

#13

Re: Is this workable?

Terry Scott

I have burnt beter than that

Make smaller craft items