Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

I didn't know that

Posts

I didn't know that

#1

I didn't know that

TomCollins

In the thread below about coring the discussion turned to having a tennon size that is 40% of the bowl diameter. I don't recall seeing or reading this rule-of-thumb before. I think this may be why I get so much vibration when I try to hollow a bowl as I have only been using around a 2 1/4" tennon on everything.

Thanks to all of you who are so willing to share your knowledge and experiences. There are many times I have picked up "drive by" tidbits of information that have helped improve my turning from this forum. A lot of times those of us who are less experienced don't even know what questions to ask but will inadvertantly find answers here.

TomC

Re: I didn't know that

#2

I'm not so sure

Jeff Willaford

I'm not so sure that is a rule of thumb but maybe just one opinion of tenon size.

When you say "I think this may be why I get so much vibration when I try to hollow a bowl" are you talking about coring with one of the center-saver types of systems or are you getting vibration when hollowing a bowl with a gouge or scraper? There might be items to address other than tenon size. Just a thought.

Re: I didn't know that

#3

BarbS

I have a question on this...

BarbS

when I took a weekend class with Russ Fairfield, he taught me to judge tenon size more by the size of the chuck and where the jaws close to make a perfect circle, saying that gave the most grip to a well-formed tenon. If I have a heavy bowl blank, is it better to cut that tenon 2" in diameter so the chuck jaws will fully grip it in a circle? Or go bigger with the tenon and have the dovetailed jaws only contacting on the outside corners for bite? I'm confused, too, by this 40% rule.

Re: I didn't know that

#4

Re: I have a question on this...

Carole Valentine

I think all jaws have an optimal holding diameter. The extreme on either end of the jaw range is not really good when there are significant forces such as in coring. There is usually an optimal holding diameter...a sweet spot so to speak. In my humble opinion, jaws stretched to their max offer a greater opportunity for the tenon to break or split because of the pressure and angle of the sharp jaw edges in the wood. And personally, I think that 40% "rule of thumb" is off base. That means that every time I wanted to core a 15" piece I should use 6" jaws and I don't think that is realistic (of course I wouldn't use 2 1/4" jaws either!) There are too many variables, not the least of which is a properly formed tenon and shoulder, the type, form, weight and balance of the wood; the lathe, the tools and the operator. But then I have never thought much of "rules of thumb" either. ;)

Re: I didn't know that

#5

Re: I have a question on this...

Barbara Gill

Barb, I never even heard of the "40% rule of thumb before". When I turn a green bowl to be dried and turned later I make the tenon large enough so that when I have to turn it down later it will fit into my chuck(s).

When I finish turn a bowl I try to have the tenon small enough to fit into the jaws I want to use (usually# 2 Oneway). I hane never had a tenon break in all the years I have been turning. That includes bowls over 16".

Russ knew what he was doing and was a great source of good information.

Re: I didn't know that

#6

There are two forces ...

Doc Green

involved in the process. One is the force (torque, actually) that spins, turns, or rotates the blank. The other is a force that can lever the blank out of the jaws.

For both of these, the larger the tenon the better. If you double the size of the tenon, you also double the amount of force (or torque) the chuck can apply to the blank for the same amount of tightness of the jaws.

I have Oneway chucks with the serrated jaws. These make contact with the tenon at two points or regions per jaw, whether the tenon is large or small. Therefore, for the serrated jaws, a bigger tenon is better, without question.

I have no real experience with dovetail jaws so I can't make any comments about opening the jaws more than the diameter that gives the greatest contact. However, my uneducated guess is that the best "holding power" will be obtained with a tenon slightly larger than the one that gives a uniform circular contact. That is, make the tenon as large as you can without causing the ends of the jaws to dig in enough to damage the wood.

Re: I didn't know that

#7

Re: I didn't know that

robo hippy

I figure tenon size should be in the 1/4 to 1/3 the diameter range. That is pretty close. I could turn and core a 12 inch bowl with a 2 inch tenon, but would have to be VERY careful with the whole process. One tiny catch, and there will be a failure at the point of most stress, which is the attachment point.

I prefer a recess. My big Vicmark is 2 5/8 inch diameter, and works fine on bowls up to 16 inches or so. Important thing is to have ample shoulder outside the recess to take the turning and coring forces. At least 1 inch for larger bowls.

robo hippy

Re: I didn't know that

#8

BarbS

Re: I have a question on this...

BarbS

Thanks, all. That helps straighten it out for me. I'd better buy a set of bigger jaws for larger work before I mount anything like that 14" blank for the walnut salad bowl I just did. That two inch tenon cracked half-way through and I tried repairing it with CA but it cracked again and I fought that thing all the way. Only a steady rest and tail center support allowed me to complete the bowl. Too ignorant to know how much trouble I'd caused, I guess. Glad you're all here to help.

Re: I didn't know that

#9

Re: I didn't know that

Barry L Elder

Seems more like a rumor than a "rule". :D

Re: I didn't know that

#10

Re: I didn't know that

Lloyd in Mississauga

I wonder if it is a hold over from when face plates were the holding method of choice. You would want a larger face plate for a larger piece to get a few more screws in.

Then when chucks came along the rule of thumb came along with them, and over time with the advent of the scroll chucks and variety of jaw forms and sizes, it really is not such a relevant bit of info.

As was pointed out, the larger the tenon your chuck will hold, the better the bowl will be held, but you can work with a smaller tenon easier than you would with a smaller face plate.

Lloyd

Re: I didn't know that

#11

Re: There are two forces ...

Don Evans

Hey Doc:

Just a clarification on your third paragraph:

You state "serrated" Oneway jaws and 2 points of contact. That sounds like to me that you have "Profile" jaws, which also have the straight threads inside them.

I'm really asking more than stating, as just yesterday I decided I needed another set of jaws for my Stronghold and on looking at the multiple choices I discovered there are 3 types "smooth" dovetails, "serated" and "Profile" if I got it figured out right the profiles will contact more in compression at 2 points but the serated ones will contact evenly when at that magic sweet spot where the inside of the jaws form a perfect circle.

All of this is stated for compression mode ONLY.

Do you think I got if figured right or backwards for the serrated verse profile?

I'm going to go look at them sometime this week instead of relying on a sales book.

Don

Re: I didn't know that

#12

Re: I didn't know that

Don Evans

Another factor that needs consideration is using the tailstock. You can safely get by with using smaller tendon if you leave a tenon inside the bowl for the tailstock to help keep the thing captured. All this needs to be kept in mind when making rules. I would have no reservations with a 2" tenon in a 4 jaw with a 1 inch tenon inside with the tailstock on it as long as the wood is solid, not punky (which I would not turn anyway) it's like most things like this. You cannot make one rule to cover all the possibilities out there.

I also consider myself brain over brawn and don't try to turn the insides of a 16" bowl in 15 seconds.

Don

Re: I didn't know that

#13

Profile, serrated, smooth ???

Doc Green

Hey Don, (in reference to Oneway chuck jaws)

I used the term "serrated" to distinguish between the serrated and dovetail jaws. The dovetail jaws are "smooth" and are circular.

As best I can tell, the term "profile" is used in reference to the jaws whose inner surface is contoured instead of being exactly circular. These are the jaws whose grip is about the same for tenons of different diameters.

There is at least one set of jaws that are serrated but which are not "profile." This is the OW/Talon #2 Serrated Tower Jaws.

On the other hand, the OW/Talon #2 Profile Tower Jaws are serrated And have the contour on the inside.

You can see photos of these at www.packardwoodworks.com

There is no substitute for seeing them up close and holding them in your hand. Have fun! ~Doc

Re: I didn't know that

#14

Brad Vietje

Re: There are two forces ...

Brad Vietje

Whoa, there, Doc...

I agree with your physics, and I will agree that a bigger tenon is better with certain jaws, but can be much worse with others, and only in compression. For expanding into a recess, bigger is also better, but it would be best to switch to bigger jaws so the rebate is just a little bigger than the closed jaws.

For the Oneway profile jaws (a.k.a. serrated), this is true because they are not round on their inner profiles (which is why they're called that). They are shaped to be able to hold round or square stock, so they can grip larger diameters pretty well. If you 2" circular jaws (like the standard 50mm set that comes with the SN-2), and made the tenon the maximum diameter that the jaws would grab, you would have greatly reduced the surface area where wood meets the jaws, and there would be only 8 small points of contact. You might very well have the most torque under this scenario, but not much grip (I think the official term is "gripsion" ;) ) to keep the bowl from sprinting across the room.

I would say that for coring, use the larger sized jaws, or even better -- a faceplate.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: I didn't know that

#15

Re: There are two forces ...

Doc Green

OK, Brad, I'm in a state of Whoa! I've read your post several times, and I cannot find any significant points where we disagree. Perhaps your point of concern is my statement made in regard to dovetail jaws ...

"However, my uneducated guess is that the best "holding power" will be obtained with a tenon slightly larger than the one that gives a uniform circular contact. That is, make the tenon as large as you can without causing the ends of the jaws to dig in enough to damage the wood."

First of all, the assumption that the holding power is in direct proportion to the area of contact is not necessarily valid. For discussion, assume that we tighten the jaws the same amount in all cases. Then, if the contact area is reduced by making the tenon larger, the pressure exerted on the smaller area of contact increases, and the points may dig into the wood.

Having the points "dug in" will increase the ability of the jaws to exert a torque on the piece, to spin the wood, as you suggested.

However, the part of the dovetailed tenon that doesn't make contact with the jaws will not help to keep the piece from being levered out of the jaws. That is, the gripsion will be reduced because it IS directly proportional to the amount of the dovetail that contacts the jaws.

So, as I see it, the ideal situation for dovetailed jaws would be to make the tenon slightly larger than the diameter that gives the best fit. Then tighten the jaws so that the points dig in, to increase the torque capability. If, at the same time, the wood is compressed at the points enough to let the remainder of the dovetail make contact with the jaws, the gripsion will be increased, which will help to prevent the piece from being pulled out of the jaws.

How much larger than "best fit" the tenon should be made will depend on the wood. My guess is that an increase of 1/4" on a 4" tenon might be in the ballpark.

I've adopted another approach to coring. If I have a big bowl blank that deserves to be cored, which I don't like to do, I'll take my trusty ol' chainsaw and slice it into disks and make a bunch of plates rather than one big bowl.

That way, not much wood is lost, no coring is required, and the plates are easier to display. :)

Take care, ~Doc

Re: I didn't know that

#16

Re: I didn't know that

Mike Kratky

Not sure what direction this tread is going but at the recent Utah Symposium on 5/19/12 durning Mike Mahoney's demo on coring bowl blanks with the McNaughton System he said that you want a tenon 50% the diameter of the bowl blank. Mike will also be demoing at Totally Turning 2013 in Saratoga Springs NY.

Re: I didn't know that

#17

Re: I didn't know that

dbonertz

I agree with what Robo has stated. One thing worth mentioning is the drying after coring. If your blank has to large of a tenon say 50% then the outside bottom of the bowl will be pretty flat due to the tenon or recess. By doing this can create stresses when drying thus a crack may form often times right through the tenon/recess. Just adding to the confusion.:)

Re: I didn't know that

#18

Brad Vietje

Gee, That's Enormous!