Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

Posts

Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

#1

Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

Steve Criscenzo

There have been a couple of articles in recent publications and several posts here about the benefits of using tool systems that allow one handle to be used on several tools. With the exception of someone that has to travel with their tools, I do not see any benefits to having a tool system that shares handles. I think that if I was faced with having to stop and change handles, that I would be tempted to “make do” with the tool in my hand and possibly not use the correct tool for the task at hand. Plus I have handles with different lengths and weights depending on the tool and intended use, adjustments you cannot get with a single handle system.

I do not see what all the fuss over handles is about. I personally like Doug Thompson’s handles because I can adjust the length of the tool sticking out and the weight and balance but I also have many tools with wooden handles, either they came that way or I made them, that I am quite happy with.

Seems like the focus should be on the tool. Am I missing something?

Just Wondering

Steve

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

#2

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

Stuart Johnson

I am quite happy

I think the above is the answer. Personally I like my Kelton ER1625 set. I like the feel and weight of the handles plus the ability to remove the tool for sharpening. Yes it is a pain sometimes to change from tool to tool if they use a different size collet but no more than the need to stop and sharpen. If you are happy with the tools and handles you currently use there is no need to change and probably no good argument to switch.

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

#3

Sharpening with no handle!

Jorge

Steve, to me the great advantage of the interchangeable handles is to go to the grinder without the handles. A great convenience.

I have handles in 3 different lengths that my most used tools share and a couple double enders (two different diameters) that the rest of the tools share, and yes, have some with permanent handles, but use those less and less. It takes a few seconds to loosen the grub screw and have a shelve with many gouges, skews, scrapers and a drawer with toll handles, beats my old tool rack.

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

#4

Steven Antonucci

speed vs. neatness

steven antonucci

I think a lot of the benefit is in how you layout your workspace and your work pace. I used to have a rack of tools that had everything I owned in it. I took a bunch of the tools I do not use every day and put them in an empty drawer. Cut the clutter by half.

I layed the large bars I use for hollowing down. Visually, it is a lot easier to process. I may get to a day where I make one handle for all of the large bars I use, and put them away somwhere too.

Most of the time I turn, I only use 3-4 tools maximum on any project. I keep saying I will eventually get a rolling cart to put everything away. Having multiple handles more than doubles the storage requirements for things that may only be used sparingly.

I completely agree that the main advantage is being able to make a tool longer or shorter. I helped my buddy Bob drill his shop made aluminum handle 3" deeper yesterday to shorten it. Instant upgrade to the spindle gouge in it.

Steve

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

#5

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

Barbara Gill

Steve I used to feel the same until I bought the Kelton ER collet handles. I liked them so much I cut the wood handles off almost every tool that had a round shank. I have a PVC pipe holder for all my unhandled tools which also is an improvement.

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

#6

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

Bill Howatt

I'll admit I'm a rather lazy amateur turner and I don't travel with my tools.

I have a Kelton handle that will take 2 sizes of tool shank diameter and I have made wooden handles with a Hosaluk ferrule which allows switching tools and I've made my own copy of the Hosaluk ferrule out of brass.

I prefer to have my tools handled and I would be among those who would be seriously tempted to use the lesser tool if I had change the tool in the handle.

I have wooden handles made from fairly dense wood so they aren't real light and I have loaded shot into the back of the handle. I don't really see the fuss over handles!

Just use whatever makes you happy whether that means a common handle or dedicated handles.

Bill

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

#7

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

steve worcester

Here's what I do.

I have probably 5 each of the more common gouges I use, say 3/8", 1/2" and 5/8" bowl gouges.

While turning, if I need to sharpen, I just change out the steel.

For this example, I only need three handles, but I have 15 gouges available.

Also, I use the Trent Bosch handles because I like them real lightweight.

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

#8

Phil Stivers

Re: speed vs. neatness

Phil Stivers

The rolling car may not be the answer as mine is full already. I need to move stuff I don't use often to other storage or get rid of it.

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

#9

Phil Stivers

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

Phil Stivers

As the discussion goes there are many personal preferences for handles. I recently made one of aluminum, mostly to see if I could. My preferences go both ways; some wood, some metal. I've found I don't like the "factory" shape on wood handles.

The big advantage I see to handles with removable tools (whether metal or wood with ferrule) is in sharpening. It's much easier to sharpen without the handle in the way.

The main thing is find what works for you. You preferences over time may change so keeping an open mind is equally important.

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

#10

Mike Stafford

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

Mike Stafford

I have wooden handles into which I have fitted inserts made from aluminum with set screws that will hold tools with 1/4", 3/8", 1/2" and 5/8" shafts. I like the feel of wooden handles and I like the shape that I turned as it fits my hand.

I have chosen different woods for different tool functions. My spindle gouge handles are turned from birdseye or curly maple. My detail gouges are turned from bloodwood and chakte kok. Larger tools are turned from heavier and more dense woods such as cocobolo and verawood. This allows me to quickly recognize the tool that I need as I just grab the correct handle.

When I travel most of the tools can be reversed and inserted into the handle to protect the cutting edge and also protect me from the cutting edge. Of course my spindle roughing gouge cannot be reversed nor can many of my Hunter tools but I still like for them to have handles that allow for me to vary the length that the tool projects out of the handle. I drill a hole slightly larger in diameter than the tool shaft into the wood much deeper than is needed to accommodate the aluminum insert as this allows me to vary how far I project the tool out of the handle. Since I turn mostly small objects I don't need long and strong handles and I seldom reach more than a couple of inches over the tool rest.

When a favorite tool wears out I can replace it and continue to use a favorite handle.

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

#11

Exactly!

Jorge

I was trying to convey that.

I do have multiple of each size, scared of fire, I do grind in another building, so like you when a gouge needs touch up, just take another one.

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

#12

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

Carol Reed, Pahrump, NV

And anyone who knows Mike, knows it is important that Mike protect himself from the cutters. :D :D

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

#13

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

Carole Valentine

I like the interchangeable handles for several reasons. I have the Kelton ER handles, the Kelton KH handles and one Hausaluk. I find sharpening is much easier to control without a long handle in the way.

My favorites are the Kelton ERs because:

The colleted handle does not chew up your tool shafts with set screws.

No tools are needed to swap.

Great storage for travel.

Ability to add weight to my preference.

Can combine handles in the system for many configurations.

Easy on my hands.

Universally available collets.

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

#14

i agree


Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

#15

Re: Benefits of Interchangeable Handles?

eliotandmax

No, I don't think you're missing anything. I do have one metal handle that accepts different gauges. I hardly ever use it. I mean , it's a darn nice handle, but I prefer a bunch of different gauges with their own handles in a rack. Just pick up what you need and go. (Come to think of , though, where interchangeable tools for a single handle do come in handy is for hollowing.)