Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Coring system

Posts

Coring system

#1

Coring system

Starry Chan

My favorite bowl range is from 8" to 14.5". I am trying to figure out whether I should buy an Oneway easy-core system with 9" and 11.5" knifes set or just buy a Woodcut Bowlsaver. The cost difference is about $200.

Both of these systems core out hemispherical centers. The Oneway system's pivoting point is adjustable but it has to be at or around the center of the lathe bed way in order to complete the cut at the center of the blank. The Woodcut pivoting point is restricted to be at the center of of lathe bed way.

The Oneway system has a separate support blade under the cutting blade to provide more support and to minimize vibration. This requires readjustment of its position as the coring progresses. Woodcut does not have this so the coring is a continuous process except the occasional withdraw of the blade to clear chip.

The Oneway cutter can be resharpened but it may require frequent sharpening. On the other hand, the Woodcut Bowlsaver cannot be sharpened but Woodcut claims that it can last for a few hundred bowls.

For those of you have used both system, what are your experience with these two systems?

Starry

Re: Coring system

#2

Re: Coring system

Doc Green

Starry, in my opinion, the Woodcut is a "light-duty" system, good only for producing cores in the 6" range, or smaller. With anything larger, the unsupported blade vibrates badly.

On the other hand, the Oneway system is massive. While it takes an extra step to move the blade support, it can be done quickly, and you will appreciate the ability to support the blade in the cut. By moving the pivot to the side, you can produce a core that is not a hemisphere.

I bought the Oneway system (not all the knives at one time) after learning the limitations of the Woodcut. My impression is that you need all the mass, strength, and support you can get because coring often degenerates to a brute-force operation in comparison to other turning operations.

My $0.02. ~Doc

Re: Coring system

#3

Re: Coring system

Mark Strang

Don't even bother agonizing over it. Spend the extra $200 and get the One Way system. It's sturdy like all of their products. The cutters do need to be sharpened but not too frequently depending on the type of wood being cut. The support bar under the knife is great and makes the coring a snap. The support arm gives a lot of confidence when doing the larger blanks. I can core at least a dozen green blanks of the 9" size before I need to resharpen. Sharpening should not be an issue regarding the purchase. It's a minor thing compared to the ease of using their product. I've tried other types of equipment and their unit is, in my opinion, the best. I can pop out a core in no time flat with virtually no worry.

Re: Coring system

#4

Re: Coring system

Dale Bonertz

Starry,

I have used the oneway, Mcnaughton and have seen the woodcut. I settled on the McNaughton but if you are choosing between the other two then I would have to agree with the other responses that the oneway, long term, is a better purchase.

Re: Coring system

#5

Dick Hines

Re: Coring system

dick hines

The McNaughton will give you greater range of bowls. The Oneway and the Wood cut give you same shape bowls.

Saying that the Oneway and the Woodcut are easier to use than the McNaughton with it's stright up learning curve. But once you have it down this system will give you more choices in your bowls.

I have the jumbo and the standard set and use them all the time.

It you can get a chance to use all three sets it would help you to deside.

Re: Coring system

#6

Steve Kubien

Re: Coring system

Steve Kubien

I'll take the contrarian view. Get the WoodCut and I have zero reservations in offering this viewpoint. I have used both systems extensively and I REALLY wish I had not sold my WoodCut in order to help pay for the Oneway.

I recently posted my views on the different coring systems over on my blog, www.greenleafwoodstudio.blogspot.com. Feel free to have a gander. Everything I wrote is 100% my opinion based on my experience. I do not claim this is any sort of definitive text but until someone can prove me wrong, on my lathe, I stand by it.

YMMV

Re: Coring system

#7

Alan Zenreich

Re: Coring system

Alan Zenreich

I'm glad Steve K sold his WoodCut Bowlsaver.

Mostly because he sold it to me

So far, I've only cored a few bowls, but it was very straightforward.

Re: Coring system

#8

I agree with Steve....

Dick Coers

I have the Woodcut and like how it works. Now if I was coring lots of burls, lots of dry wood, I might think differently. But I turn a lot of soft maple and and elm burl, and it works well for that. It does vibrate, and may sound a bit like a train wreck from time to time, but I'm not after surface finish with the tool.

Re: Coring system

#9

Re: Coring system

Josh Bowman

I've got the McNaughton and feel the learning curve is a long path. Seems I'm a slow learner, since I've had it since Nov. 2010 and am just now starting to feel confident with using it. It's flexibility is the challenge. It's kind of hard to guess at the starting point. But if you visualize where the tip is going by stopping and studying the blades curve, you can make some good cores. I've had a laser on mine and find you still have to stop and look at the position of the remaining blade to the outside curve of the bowl. Having said that, it's fairly fast. I've only done 12" blanks and less and find the two smallest blades do the job fine.

Re: Coring system

#10

Re: Coring system

Bernie Weishapl

I have used the Woodcut and the Oneway systems. I went with the oneway and only bought the 3 smaller knives as my lathe is 16" so didn't need the big one. I really love the system as it cores so easily with not much effort at all.

Re: Coring system

#11

Re: Coring system

robo hippy

I don't know where you heard that the Woodcut can not be sharpened. A quick brush on the grinder or with a hone on the nose and it is ready to go again. They are working on a bigger blade for the system. The 'large' blade is a 5 inch radius, so you can remove a 10 to maybe 12 inch core if you break the core off. Pretty simple to use, and you do need to hook the tailstock up.

The Oneway is the most stable no matter how deep you go. Most expensive. The down side is when coring, you have to turn off the lathe to advance and adjust the support finger for each 2 inches of cutter you stick into the bowl. Some what time consuming. You also have to remove the cutter from the tip to sharpen it. This system mounts on a separate plate that you bolt to the ways of the lathe.

The McNaughton is the fastest to set up and use. It has a learning curve. The biggest difference in the shapes you can remove/core is the small/flattest curved blade which can be used to core deeper vessels, and/or plate forms.

robo hippy

Re: Coring system

#12

Phil Stivers

Re: Coring system

Phil Stivers

I have the one way easy core and am very happy with it. I find the need to sharpen frequently.

Re: Coring system

#13

Steve Kubien

Just curious

Steve Kubien

Phil, can I ask what lathe you're using?

Re: Coring system

#14

Phil Stivers

Re: Just curious

Phil Stivers

Powermatic 3520B.

Re: Coring system

#15

Steve Kubien

Re: Just curious

Steve Kubien

So you have more ponies than my DVRXP and you can't brute force your way either? I figured as much.

Thanks.

Re: Coring system

#16

Phil Stivers

Re: Just curious

Phil Stivers

I've never found it to be under powered for coring. I don't think you should muscle you way through anyway. If you have to you're doing something wrong. I sharpen the cutters about every other session (one session is a days coring). I rotate the cutters as the directions suggest. The smaller cutters get more use.

Re: Coring system

#17

Steve Kubien

Re: Just curious

Steve Kubien

Ok, that changes things a little. I read your earlier comment as you were sharpening after every core or two, which is my experience or else I get vibration issues.

Hmmm, wonder what I'm doing wrong... Do I really need to get #4 jaws (Oneway) for my SN2 chuck? Seems a bit extreme for a bowl around 14".

Re: Coring system

#18

Phil Stivers

Re: Just curious

Phil Stivers

Your vibration might be in the chuck (jaws). I'm not sure what size you're using but is sounds smaller than 4". I use Vicmarc 4 or 5" jaws when I core. My learning' taught me to have jaws somewhere around 40% of the dimeter of the bowl. The other option would be to use a faceplate. That might be a good trouble shooting step before you invest in jaws.

Re: Coring system

#19

Steve Kubien

Re: Just curious

Steve Kubien

Will look into it. Thanks!

Re: Coring system

#20

Re: Just curious

Steve Mushinski

Steve,

Doesn't hurt to add lube to the process. A spray bottle of water at hand helps the cutting action also. Spray a steady stream into the slot the knife creates as you go along. Even with high horse power constant clearing of chip is required.

When I am doing metal turning a spay bottle is my friend. At work all the machines have auto lubbers. We use a water soluble oil mix.

Re: Coring system

#21

Re: Just curious

Ralph Lindberg

I core with a DVR-XP wired for 120V

I found that if I used the 2-inch (#2) jaws, I had tenons snap off. I find that if I follow the 40% rule I tend not to.

I aiso use lub, in the form of WD-40

I also use the "pulse" method of coring that Steve Russell advocates.

Re: Coring system

#22

So You Are Saying...

Barbara Gill

If I am coring a 20" bowl my jaws need to fit a tenon that is 40% of the diameter of the bowl??? That just does not compute.

Plus, if I am coring a bowl of the same diameter and have a faceplate holding the piece and have a catch in tough, knarley wood those screws are going to hold that sucker? If you dislodge the screws you really will have a problem.

Re: Coring system

#23

Phil Stivers

Re: So You Are Saying...

Phil Stivers

You're right the 40% doesn't compute. If I have a 20" bowl to core, I am going to use the 7" or 8" Vicmarc jaws (mainly because they don't come larger). The bowl turning "rule of thumb" is jaws and foot 30% - 40% of the diameter for stability. If I am coring, I want more strength. On a smaller core 14" - 18", I'll use a larger jaw (if I have one.)

If I am using a face plate in "dry knurly" I would consider gluing to the faceplate as well. That would definitely fall into the category of "bad wood". It had better be real pretty. Life's too show for bad wood. I would use at least a 6" face plate with at probably 12 screws, #12 x 1 1/4". I don't use faceplates often, that would be my approach. I have never knocked a core out of the chuck, but have sheared off a tenon (and knocked it off the lathe). The tenon was still in the chuck. And that was a problem.

I am not stating "laws" according to Phil. This is my approach and my opinion on how I would address the issue. Feel free to disagree. I'm happy to learn from your opinion and approach.

Re: Coring system

#24

Harry Robinette

Re: So You Are Saying...

Harry Robinette

I use a McNaughton coring system and I use a Nova Titan 5" with 100 MM jaws on my Vega 2600 to do large bowls. My smaller bowls say under 12" I use my General 160-18" with a 1hp DC Drive with a Super Nova 2 with 75MM bowl Jaws. Have no trouble with either.