Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

newbie tool ? (carbide or hss)

Posts

newbie tool ? (carbide or hss)

#1

newbie tool ? (carbide or hss)

Earl

As stated I am new to turning. I apologize if this has already been discussed to death but I missed it if it was. I am having a hard time learning to sharpen my gouges. I could spend a lot more money on equipment for sharpening and that may make a difference. I have the Wolverine Vari-grind jig and home made jig to slide in and out under the wheel. With the price of the carbide tools coming down should I even worry about learning to sharpen? Is there some reason to learn to sharpen the traditional gouges or can I just use with the carbides? Thanks for any help with this

Earl

Re: newbie tool ? (carbide or hss)

#2

In the long run you will benefit more.....

JamieDonaldson

...by learning to sharpen HSS tools, and for the high cost of many of the current carbide scrapers you could better use the money to seek some sharpening lessons from a skilled turner.

Re: newbie tool ? (carbide or hss)

#3

Steven Antonucci

The mistake that many new turners make ...

steven antonucci

with respect to sharpening is that buying a jig means that they will get the right shape automatically. A jig only holds your tool at a constant position to the wheel, it does not create the shape.

I had two guys at the club on Wednesday night ask me to sharpen tools for them. One was sharp, but the wrong shape. The other was the right shape, but not sharp. Sharpening with a jig requires developing a "recipe" to make it easy to get to that same shape in one or two quick LIGHT passes.

One of the things that I teach is to hold the jig up by where it is grinding. If it's too hot and you cannot touch it with a bare hand, you are grinding too hard. Once you get the right shape and a recipe, sharpening should take 10 seconds.

Steve

...and no, carbide is not the answer to sharpening. I agree with JD...find someone to show you how...

Re: newbie tool ? (carbide or hss)

#4

Re: In the long run you will benefit more..... *LINK*

john lucas

I agree with the others. Since you already have the equipment you are much better off just improving your technique. Here is my video on sharpening problems. Hopefully it will help. I also have one on trueing the grinding wheel and one on sharpening tips. If you subscribe to my videos you will find all of those and more. It will also give you a notice when I produce another one which hopefully won't be too long.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M9G16ylEZHQ

Re: newbie tool ? (carbide or hss)

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: newbie tool ? (carbide or hss)

Keith Tompkins

HI Earl,

By purchasing, and learning on carbide tools, you are missing out on learning TWO basic skills....Sharpening, and tool handling skills. Also, you seem to be implying you are mainly interested in bowl turning, but the whole field of spindle turning really relies on learning proper tool technique...something you will miss out on by using only carbide tools. I feel learning to sharpen is a fundamental skill, that if overlooked, will come back to haunt you time and time again.

In the general field of woodworking, sharpening tools is a must. Carving chisels, bench chisels, plane irons, etc. all need periodic sharpening...why should turning tools be exempt from that?

I think you will be much happier down the road if you take the time to learn to sharpen...you will be a much better turner (craftsman) for it. I may have a bit of an elitist attitude, too many people get into turning because it's quick and fairly easy...a project can be completed in a short time. But to become GOOD at turning will take an investment of your time...turning is the one segment of woodworking that relies on SKILL to produce a finished product; the shape you produce comes from inside yourself, and from the skills you develop...not the profile of a router bit or shaper head.

Re: newbie tool ? (carbide or hss)

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: newbie tool ? (carbide or hss)

Keith Tompkins

I forgot to mention...you can learn a TON just by hanging out on Wood Central! :)

Re: newbie tool ? (carbide or hss)

#7

Mike Stafford

Re: newbie tool ? (carbide or hss)

Mike Stafford

One of the most important skills any turner (or woodworker for that matter) is to learn how to sharpen tools. In wood turning a sharp tool makes every aspect of the craft more enjoyable. The ability to easily remove large amounts of wood with a large bowl gouge or wispy shavings with a small detail gouge can only be accomplished with sharp well shaped tools. Effortless cutting and good tool control is facilitated by the sharpness of your edge. The ability to make the cuts you want to make are enhanced with a sharp edge.

Sharpening takes practice and skill even with a Wolverine jig. I ground away a lot of steel before someone finally explained how to best use the jig.

I understand the allure of using some of the carbide scrapers which allow a novice to quickly begin removing wood and turning objects. In my class I always have a set or two of those carbide scrapers just in case I have someone who shows up with absolutely no turning experience and demonstrates no ability to follow directions. I would rather they learn to use the gouges but in a week in a class with other students it is hard to devote enough time to one student who will not follow directions. Better to arm them with a carbide scraper and let them enjoy the week. Very few of the students like I am describing will go home to a lathe so it is important for them to leave with the enjoyment of turning.

If you have access to a turning club join it and find a friend who can help you along the way. It is cheaper to learn how to things correctly than to pay with expensive high speed steel grinding dust on the floor, dull tools and frustration over how hard the enjoyable craft of wood turning has become.

Re: newbie tool ? (carbide or hss)

#8

Re: newbie tool ? (carbide or hss)

steve worcester

Since you mention you have the jigs, I assume you have the grinder, you are half way home. Under proper tutelage, you can learn to sharpen most gouges in an afternoon. The issue here is that you can't replace the cut of all gouges with the cut of all carbides. There is a place for both, but not a place for no gouges.

Either set up an afternoon on Youtube with John Lucas or dutifully look through the manuals and websites, or get some help from a local club. With just a bit of understanding on how the jigs work and proper angles, you won't have the fear.

Personally, I don't think you can do everything with gouges that you can do with carbide. And this coming from someone who wants to sell you more sandpaper.

Heck, setup a camera and a skype account, and I can help (I have neither , but would go that far to help)

Re: newbie tool ? (carbide or hss)

#9

Re: In the long run you will benefit more.....

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

John, I just watched your linked sharpening video (a new one to me) and I noticed that you are using the rounded side of a grinding wheel for sharpening some tools.

Do you also advocate using the side of a grinding wheel to sharpen skews?

There seems to be considerable controversy relative to sharpening on the side of a grinding wheel, as a number of people say NEVER because of the danger of shattering a wheel.

Please comment on this issue.

Re: newbie tool ? (carbide or hss)

#10

Bill Blasic

Re: In the long run you will benefit more.....

Bill Blasic

Earl,

A starting place that might help is to go to Doug Thompson's site and download the pdf that shows the Vari-grind Jig and set yours up like the picture. Just set your jig on the picture and set your jig the same way. This will give you a good starting point for a decent profile.

Bill

http://www.thompsonlathetools.com/sharpening.asp

Re: newbie tool ? (carbide or hss)

#11

Re: newbie tool ? (carbide or hss)

Earl

Thanks to all for taking the time to help me. I guess I'll have to take the time to learn to sharpen. I do belong to a turning club and a couple guys do give turning classes I'll have to ask about sharpening. I bought a lathe because sometime I had to skip a project because it required a lathe. So far I have not been pulled into the vortex but if I learn to sharpen that may happen. I do like the turning part its the sharpening that I don't like. Once again thanks to all Earl

Re: newbie tool ? (carbide or hss)

#12

Re: In the long run you will benefit more.....

John Lucas

No I don't sharpen on the side of the wheel. I have occasionally for special tools but you can't apply any pressure at all or you risk fracturing the stone which is quite dangerous.

The grinding I'm doing for sharpening on the edge of the stone is extremelylight. It doesn't take much pressure to do that grind.

Re: newbie tool ? (carbide or hss)

#13

Re: newbie tool ? (carbide or hss)

Bob Edwards

Along with all the great advice you have gotten so far you may want to have a look at the Oneway video on sharpening with the Wolverine jig. There are nuances to every technique and sometime you have to tweak them a little but this will give you a good start to one phase of tool sharpening.

http://www.oneway.ca/multi-media/index.htm