Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

Posts

Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#1

Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

ronnyeelen

Hi,

A friend of mine is planning on buying hollowing tools for hand held hollowing. He has been testing my Kelton hollowers and likes them. But he also has seen the Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro tools video on youtube.

My personal preference would still be the Keltons. I would be interested in what you think about the M. Jackofsky tools.

thanks

Ronny


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=du0ifM_sfAo&feature=related

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#2

Bill Blasic

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro

Bill Blasic

Ronny,

I have never used the Hollow-Pro Tools and I have most of the Keltons. Just on a cost basis in the Craft Supply Catalog I'm looking at getting the three 5/8 Keltons for less than one 5/8 Hollow-Pro without a cutter (the catalog says that you get 10% off of the Keltons if you buy two so I imagine you would get 10% off of three). I also know that you can take the same cuts in the video with the Keltons with the same results. So knowing what I know I would go with the Keltons but your friend will have to make his own decision.

Bill

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#3

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro

Jeff Willaford

I'm with Bill on this one. Your friend will have to decide what's best for him.

For me... I use my Keltons handheld and also use the larger ones in my Monster Hollowing Rig for deeper vessels. Kelton Hollowers can take a big bite or finesse the cut...my choice. The range in size and shape allows me to hollow small globes or hollow forms up to about 14" deep. Did I mention I like them?

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#4

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro

Stuart Johnson

I haven't used the Hollow-Pros and like my Keltons. Are those Hunter cutters on the Hollow-Pro which would be a big plus? Price would also come into play if I was purchasing. The Hollow-Pro looks to be about $350 for the bent and straight tool with on cutter assembly unless I'm misreading and each tool includes the cutter. The three Keltons would run around $135 total with the 10% discount.

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#5

What Jeff said ...

Doc Green

Whatever steel is used in the Keltons is head and shoulders above anything else I've ever used for taking a keen edge and then holding it forever.

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#6

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro

ronnyeelen

This is going kind of like I expected it.

Thanks for confirming.

Yes, they have the Hunter like carbide cutters. And I am sure they will do a very good job. But I like the simplicity and the sturdyness of the Keltons.

But others might have a different opinion yet...

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#7

Phil Stivers

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro

Phil Stivers

I own both the Keltons and the large and small Hollow Pro tools. The 1/2" and 5/8" Keltons are forgiving tools and inexpensive. The do have a finite life if you sharpen as much as you should. The Hollow Pro tools are my tools of choice for anything I can fit the tool into. The rotating adjustment always ensures that the cutter is aligned with where you want to cut. The number 1 hunter cutter will remove wood quickly and efficiently on either bent or straight bar. The number 2 is very aggressive, but the 15 degree negative #2 is a wonderful cutter for a little slower stock removal with smooth cuts. For fine cleaning cuts the M4 scraper tips leaves a smooth surface in little need of sanding (for those that sand the inside you can start at 180 or 220.). Mikes's DVD does a great job of teaching hollow forms regardless of the tools used. There is a special section on his tools that may be skipped if desired.

Some have said the the Hollow Pro tools don't cut, only scrape. I have found that hey cut so well I must stop quite often to clear the curls of wood. On dry or very hard woods the Hollow Pros with the carbide cutter has no equal for hand hollowing.

I use the Jamieson for deep hollowing when the opening allows.

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#8

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro

Ronnyeelen

Thanks Phil, for sharing your experience.

Ronny

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#9

Harry Robinette

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro

harry robinette

I have the large and small Keltons and love them. They work very fast and are very controllable.

I have not tried the Jackofskys so i can't say anything about them.

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#10

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro

Carole Valentine

Ronny, I will add my voice. Have not tried the Hollow Pro, but I have accumulated all of the Keltons over the years and love them. They last just about forever if they are sharpened properly, and that means just refreshing the burr with a hard Arkansas stone, a ceramic stone or even a diamond hone if you don't have the others. Mine rarely, if ever, see a grinder, and if they do it is with the very lightest of touches on the bevel.

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#11

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro

Karen F.

I can add my experience with Mike's Hollow Pro tools to this thread. I agree with Phil they are the first tools I pick up for hollowing medium to large size hollow forms. I am a complete tool-aholic and have Keltons, Stewart System (I've sold them since getting Mike's tools) and Jamison's captive system.

Mike's will cut the inside quickly and precisely with little need for sanding. The keltons only get used for small globe ornaments or small (6 inches or less) hollow forms with small openings. I see a lot of others have Keltons and so are comfortable with them but when you want to get it done quick (Jamison's take a while to set up) try Mikes.

I'm not saying any one is the ONLY way to hollow a vessel (hand held vs captured) but try them and go with the one you are most comfortable. (Or be like me and buy one of each- they sell fast once you decide what you like)

I've always said when I train someone, there are hundred ways to do something and you should use the one that works best for you. I don't think anyone should every say "My way is the only way" or the "right way" to get the job done.

Just my 6 cents.

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#12

Joe Fleming

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro

Joe Fleming

I have many hollowing systems. I have never bought one without trying it first. They are too expensive to buy on just a recommendation. So, please try both before you spend.

Having said that, I own Keltons, Hollow Pro, Sorby, Derry, Exocet, Hosaluk hook tools, Jordan, Packard, home made, Pencil Scorpion and Stinger, Stewart, and probably a few others I can't recall without going to look. All have a place in my tool kit depending on the size, shape, opening, grain orientation, wood condition, wood hardness, etc. The last two vessels I made were around 8" to 9" D and about the same height. They were both rather globe-shaped. I used the following tools for these:

Derry, Kelton, Hollow Pro, Packard and Stewart/Scorpion for these. Maybe Jordan too, but I don't recall. I use what works for me for different vessels and even different portions of the same vessel.

The only hollowing tool I ever did not have a use for was the Jerry Glaser boring bar. Borrowed it for a month and hated it.

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#13

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro

ronnyeelen

Thanks all.

It is good it is not me who has to choose. :D

Ronny

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#14

Dick Hines

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro

dick hines

Well, no one has said anything about Trent Bosch's hollowing tools. I have a set of those and really like them. The cutters are 3/16 rould rods that are glued into the shafts. They can make very fine cuts but you have to make sure the curved part is infront of the tool rest.

I also have the Kelton tools in the 5/16,1/2,. and 3/8 size. Also the Woodcut hollowers and the Jamieson rig.

I tried to find a turner close to me that had the tools I was thinking about buying and beg them to use their tools before I dropped the money.

You have some hard choises. Good luck.

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#15

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro

Dave Crawford

I am very interested in purchasing the MJ Hollow Pro tools. Question, for free hand hollowing how deep can you hollow with the 5/8 tool? I want to turn vases from 12 to 18 inches. Should I also be looking at the Jamieson Captive Hollowing Boring System for the really deep stuff?

Thanks.

Dave

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#16

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro

john lucas

If you want to turn 12 to 18" you need a bar bigger than 3/4". Look at Lyle's big one. It should do the trick for you.

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#17

Phil Stivers

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro

Phil Stivers

I have the Hollow Pro tools and they are excellent up to about 12". I suggest you contact Mike Jackofsky and ask his opinion. He is more concerned in your success than to sell his tools; expect an honest answer. In my opinion over 12" deep you will need a more stout bar and longer bar. The Kelton's don't have the reach you desire. In a captive bar system the large boring bar of the Jamieson system is ok up to maybe 18". I don't know of any available systems for Hand Held hollowing that deep. I know that Mike Jackofsky has larger bars for deeper hollowing but doesn't produce them for sale. Brian McEvoy produces very large boring bar systems for deep hollowing up to 20+". See www.onegoodturn.ca for information from Brian. At the depth you're discussing you'll also likely need a steady rest.

I find it interesting that people compare Kelton's and Hollow Pro tools. It's like comparing apples to oranges. Their geometry is different and the cutters aren't even close to equals. They both work but in different ways with very different hollowing experiences. Try them both, then judge.

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#18

Dave,

GaryG in MD

IMO, a 5/8" bar is only good to about 6" depth.

I use a rule of thumb for myself that my maximum depth is ten times the bar diameter. This relationship is probably a bit conservative. It seems to work pretty well for diameters up to about 5/8". I imagine it might break down at larger sizes, but I've never tried anything greater. ...Gary

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#19

Rob Wallace

Have a look at Advanced Lathe Tools Boring Bars *LINK*

Rob Wallace

Dave:

If you want to do really deep vessels, I suggest you check-out the Advanced Lathe Tools deep boring bar systems designed by Steve Sinner and sold by The Sanding Glove (link below).

I have Lyle Jamieson's captured bar system, and it works great, but has its limits. I will be getting an Advanced Lathe Tools boring bar later this year to add more depth to my system. I have seen some of Steve's pieces that are 30" tall, and I have seen this system in operation - it is pretty impressive.

BTW - I bought the ALT center steady for my Jet 1642, and it is built like a tank.

Rob Wallace


Advanced Lathe Tools Deep Hollowing System

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#20

I agree with Phil

Greg Haugen

At those depths, you've got three options. Lyle's large system, Steve Sinner's system, and Brian McEvoy's system. Each of them has pro's and con's. Shop them out and talk to the designers' of them.

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#21

Re: Have a look at Advanced Lathe Tools Boring Bar

Joe Meirhaeghe

12" is pretty deep to try & keep a good even wall thickness with by hand tools, in my opinion.

I work with Steve Sinner in his studio & use his Boring system there & also at home. I've hollowed 100 plus pieces it. It's very heavily built and depending on the size of the system you get ( he makes several different size bars) will allow you hollow up to 30" deep.

I personally have hollowed pieces that range from about 6" deep all the way up to 32" deep, using his different sized boring bars.

It's a much heavier built & better system than the Jamison if you want to go deep.

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#22

barry rockwell

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro

Barry Rockwell

I too want to do some larger and deeper hollow forms and need some larger tools. I just got back from the Utah Symposium where I saw Brian McEvoy demonstrate his deep hollowing system and was completely blown away. Very simple to use, extremely easy to set up, and amazingly inexpensive. Like Phil Stivers, I like the Hollow-Pros and other hollowing tools, but I have never seen anything like McEvoy's system. I'm pretty sure that one of them will appear in my shop before the summer is over.

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#23

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Have a look at Advanced Lathe Tools Boring Bar

Lyle Jamieson

I also have a larger system that will hollow more then 18-24 inches deep. And get into any shape you desire. My focus is on hollowing safely without vibration. When you get that deep you need to beef up everything including the back rest. The forces get so severe you need a lot more strength. When you get that deep the wood gets so heavy the inertia will keep going. If something bad happens its not going to stop in a heart beat. Some folks force their tools, hand held or captive, past the vibration point. I highly discourage that. You can get lucky for a while but somone is going to get hurt doing that. There is a huge difference between a 5/8 bar and a 3/4 bar. The deeper you go the larger diameter the bar needs to be to hollow without vibration.

What about the laser?? I certainly would not want to rely on caliper measuring in the bottom of a 16 inch tall vessel. Working hand held means hollowing blind in there. You want to keep the wall thickness uniform to prevent cracking. Once you put that much work into a piece, you want it to survive. If I were this 20 something year old stud that did not care about beating up my body with hand held hollowing Id still have a captured system just because of the laser speed, control, and fun .

I can drive my car just fine, I do not need to learn how to ride a horse. They can both get me down the road.

I will have a new video out soon for advanced hollowing techniques. For those of you that think there are limitations or obsticles with captured systems, I will show how to get into any conceivable shape you can think of.

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#24

Rob Wallace

Re: Have a look at Advanced Lathe Tools Boring Bar *LINK*

Rob Wallace

Lyle:

I don't know if you're asking about an Advanced Lathe Tool laser system, but Steve offers a fairly beefy and easily adjustable laser system that goes with the ALT boring bars of any size. It can be mounted in several positions to accommodate different shaped vessels.

The usual ALT boring bars recommended are doubled 1-1/4" solid steel rod (welded). In addition to having "normal" 3/16" or 1/4" HSS scraping cutters, he also has adapted the use of the Rolly Munro articulated arm cutter head in his boring bar systems. This is really a sweet deep-hollowing system.

I use your D-arm captive system and laser guide with the Hunter carbide cutter, and it does really well. Steve's is just a different scale system altogether.

See you in San Jose in about a week-and-a-half!

Rob Wallace


Advanced Lathe Tools Laser System

Re: Kelton Hollowers vs Mike Jackofsky Hollow-Pro *LINK*

#25

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Have a look at Advanced Lathe Tools Boring Bar

Lyle Jamieson

Yes, Look me up in San Jose, I will have the new Giant system as well as my basic system to see and USE in my booth. And I will be doing 4 demos. I can build it to go as deep as you want. Ive done some custom orders. Steve and I do things much differently. That is no implication of right or wrong. Our chucking methods, laser use, cutting tips and vibration tolerances are all on opposite ends of the scale.