Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

A comparison test of tools

Posts

A comparison test of tools

#1

Steven Antonucci

A comparison test of tools

steven antonucci

Attached is a quick comparison test for your consideration.

There are 4 different areas in this end grain maple, cut with 4 different tools:

(in no particular order)

A home made hook tool in oil hardened steel that I made

A Doug Thomspon 10V spindle gouge

A Hunter #5

and a Sears skew

Your job is to order the cuts based upon this picture and what you know about the different materials and their ability to work end grain maple.


None of the tools were particularly sharp, that is to say that they had all been previously used and none were given the advantage of a fresh cutting edge. It is fair to say that this surface is somewhere in the 240-320 range, and would probably be a little bit better if all of the tools had been brought up to their maximum potential.

Let's hear what you think and I'll post the order and the edges/presentation later.

Steve

Re: A comparison test of tools

#2

Steve,

GaryG in MD

On my monitor, the photo does not have sufficient resolution to answer your question. I can see obvious tear out in the outer ring at the "top" of the photo, and maybe (or maybe not) some in the second ring (out from the center -- the one that appears to be lower in height). The center circle and third ring appear to be clean. We really need a much higher resolution photo for any reasonable judgements. Given the severs limits of resolution of computer monitors (nowhere near as good as a paper print), it would help if your photo only encompassed one quarter of the entire circle (in the quadrant where tear out is evident in the outer ring). I'm interested in your answers, but I think we need better "evidence" to work with. Thanks, Gary

Re: A comparison test of tools

#3

Steven Antonucci

I think you need a new computer?

steven antonucci

Gary-

There is no tearout in any of the rings. The four surfaces are all identical to the human eye and touch. That was the point. The middle section has some small lines in it because the Hunter cutter has some small chips in it and cannot be sharpened.

The second ring from the middle was cut with my hook. I would describe it as "sharp enough", but someday, I may polish it to get it really sharp.

The third ring was cut with a spindle gouge with the handle down and the tool pointing up at 10 o'clock from the center to the outside. That ring is proud of the other surface.

The outer ring was cut with the skew, toe down.

Depending upon what you are making, each tool has it's advantages and disadvantages, but all of them can do the job- regardless of the steel composition.

Steve

Re: A comparison test of tools

#4

Re: A comparison test of tools

robo hippy

Well, you can't pass that one around for feel and tell. From what I can see, the center section looks fuzzy.

The biggest thing in finish cuts is how the tool is presented to the wood. Bevel rubbing/shear angle cuts leave a finer surface than scraping (flat on the tool rest) cuts. Of course, the tools need to be sharp.

robo hippy

Re: A comparison test of tools

#5

Steven Antonucci

Center is not fuzzy.

steven antonucci

The center has small "lines" in it that are clean cuts, but present because of the small variations in the carbide cutter (that cannot be resharpened out). think of them as "micro-ridges", but they are completely cleanly cut.

To be fair, I think it's probably the hardest thing to do (cutting the center flat and clean) Any one of the tools would have left some marks because the the center is moving so slowly in comparison to the outside. It's hard to move the tool consistently in that small space.

Steve

Re: A comparison test of tools

#6

Re: Center is not fuzzy.

robo hippy

That cut is where Doug Thompson's fluteless gouge excells. ) nose profile, 60 to 70 degree bevel, same shear angle. You end up removing a disc, or flower shaped piece of wood, not a long shaving. With the carbide disc, this is impossible to do.

robo hippy

Re: A comparison test of tools

#7

Re: Center is not fuzzy.

John Jordan

End grain maple is EASY to cut, and starting with edges that have been used makes no sense if you are doing a test. Anything made of metal and sharpened would make clean cuts on that. :)

John

Re: A comparison test of tools

#8

Steven Antonucci

I think that was my point

steven antonucci

any piece of metal with an edge will cut wood. The variables are how sharp, how long will it stay sharp, and how do you present it to the wood?

If I cut fast with any of them, the cut will degrade, so I cut fast until I get close to finished, resharpen and then make a final cut or two. as long as the edge is sharp and presented right, it works pretty flawlessly.

I don't think about what steel it is when I select a tool. I just think "is it sharp?" and "Can I put it on the wood the way it needs to be put?" If I can, I usually end up in a good place...

S

Re: A comparison test of tools

#9

Re: A comparison test of tools

john lucas

Steve I hate to tell you but you really can't tell finish quality in a photo. I've tried. Only with a really good light reflecting off of it at an incident angle can you see the difference and then it's difficult. I was able to show the difference between a polished finish and scraped finish using the hunter tool in Hunter Hercules video. Even then it's not anywhere near as good as in person.

Re: A comparison test of tools

#10

Steven Antonucci

The purpose was to show comparatively

steven antonucci

Without being able to see it firsthand, the goal was to see if anyone could distinguish between on surface or the other via what was posted. The image (on my laptop, at least) shows 4 surfaces that all look "about the same". In person, they may appear better, but they all feel "about the same" too.

A good edge and proper presentation matters more than which tool, which steel. or whose name is on it. Done correctly, it is impossible to tell them apart.

S