A comparison test of tools
steven antonucci
Attached is a quick comparison test for your consideration.
There are 4 different areas in this end grain maple, cut with 4 different tools:
(in no particular order)
A home made hook tool in oil hardened steel that I made
A Doug Thomspon 10V spindle gouge
A Hunter #5
and a Sears skew
Your job is to order the cuts based upon this picture and what you know about the different materials and their ability to work end grain maple.

None of the tools were particularly sharp, that is to say that they had all been previously used and none were given the advantage of a fresh cutting edge. It is fair to say that this surface is somewhere in the 240-320 range, and would probably be a little bit better if all of the tools had been brought up to their maximum potential.
Let's hear what you think and I'll post the order and the edges/presentation later.
Steve




