Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Another teaching video (not mine)

Posts

Another teaching video (not mine)

#1

Steven Antonucci

Another teaching video (not mine)

steven antonucci


I do not know this guy, but I have watched a few of his videos and he is definitely a beginner. I tripped across his video this AM over coffee, and it is a GREAT video of a common beginner mistake. I posted a comment on it, and I have copied it here:

If you look at the video closely (1:12-1:22), you are cutting just barely at centerline and slowly raising the handle, which drops you below centerline. You are also not cutting, but scraping with the gouge (as illustrated by the visible gap between the wood and the bevel) You need to raise the toolrest to cut above centerline. Scraping like this usually puts a bowl into orbit...

Not meant to be a shot at him, but I thought that it was the easiest video explanation of that type of beginner mistake I have ever seen. If you've ever gotten that type of catch, you probably did what he did.

Steve

Re: Another teaching video (not mine)

#2

Leo Cuellar

Re: Another teaching video (not mine)

Leo Cuellar

So, Steve,

did you invite him to check out WC? He seems to have the right sense of humor for this place :D

Leo

Re: Another teaching video (not mine)

#3

Rob Wallace

Re: Another teaching video (not mine)

Rob Wallace

Steve -

You're very generous by calling this a "teaching" video......

....I'm not so sure I could be as kind. There are so many things, in succession, that he does wrong, that I could never suggest any beginner ever watch and learn from the "information" has been made available in this video.

I don't understand what compels beginners to put these things on youtube just because they can..... ... I suppose there is some value in it, since it shows novice woodturners what NOT to do. The problem is that the beginners have no idea what turning methods and tools should or should not be used, even after watching it, or having any explanation why the methods they are watching should be used. This contributes little to improving the learning situation for anyone. In my opinion, this video is not "teaching" at all, in any sense.

I think you did the guy a service by posting the critique.

Caveat emptor.

Rob

Re: Another teaching video (not mine)

#4

Steven Antonucci

Both sides of the coin

steven antonucci

The internet has many untapped possibilities. Distance learning is one of the early success stories. What if the guy was in the middle of nowhere and didn't know about the opportunities to learn (clubs, other turners, forums...)?

So, on the positive side of things, by posting this video, warts and all, he opens up the possibility to improving his situation if he is willing to learn. He also opens up the possibility for others to learn from his mistakes, even if he isn't. My reason for posting the comment was to explain why he got the catch to ANYONE that views it. I know it cannot possibily reach everyone, but if it helps a few, that's a good thing.

I am also agreeing with you that some people should probably not be posting videos of some of the things they do without gross warnings about being for entertainment value or non-instructional. There are lots of people posting videos with little or no value other than documenting their desire for a Darwin Award. It is critical that anyone seeking INSTRUCTION understands that not everything posted on Youtube is safe, smart, or optimal.

I posted the link to this video knowing that his intent is not to instruct, and that he's doing lots of things wrong, but the nugget in those 15 seconds is a very good illustration of how a catch occurs. It's all there. I could spend a few hours picking the rest of the video apart, but I decided to go out to the shop and finish my model rocket launch controller instead...

Steve

Re: Another teaching video (not mine)

#5

Re: Another teaching video (not mine)

Jim Breeden

Unbelievable! Even I, as a beginner, would not have tried what he did. My instructor would have used a 2x4 to get my attention. To turn what looks to me like in excess of the recommended 600rpm on the cole jaws, without the live center back-up, is nuts. I know! When I turn with the cole jaws I always use the live center up to the very end, then turn the lathe down and complete the turning. My instructor didb't teach me this, I learned it on my own, the hard way. Someone will probably say this is not the correct way, but it works for me.

Time for one of them critique sessions? Ok with me.

Re: Another teaching video (not mine)

#6

Re: Another teaching video (not mine)

johh lucas

What a great workout. Upper back, biceps, probably lats and traps. Definitely better than crunches for the abs, and a really good cardiovascular workout. I'd take my turn. :)

Re: Another teaching video (not mine)

#7

Brad Vietje

Re: Both sides of the coin

Brad Vietje

Steve, I see your point.

I've seen a few of his videos, too, and I must say, they are quite refreshing. This fellow just loves woodworking, and he's having fun at it, too. He also turns despite a tremor in his hands, so he's not letting that stop him, either. He doesn't present himself as a master of anything, he's aware of his mistake, and he even points it out in the video. I think his enthusiasm, patience, humility, and great sense of humor will make him a good turner with a little practice and guidance. I hope he joins us here on the forum.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT