Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

Posts

Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

#1

Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

Now that I am plumbing the shop with a dust collection system, I would love some advice on 'dust collection' at the lathe. Clearly no system will capture all the shavings flying off the gouge in roughing bowls, unless you spend an inordinate amount of time arrange the collection system (and then I suspect it would get in the way). But what about sanding dust or the fine cut stuff? Can that be collected effectively with a dust collector?

I have experimented with my shop vac and it can capture some of the sanding dust - so that helps. But there I was using a very small hose that has to be positioned just right. Would a larger 4 or 6" hose with some sort of bell end capture much? Any good or bad experience trying this?

I suspect that the answer is no here - given the preponderance of dust helmets and respirators - but I wanted to ask in case I was missing something obvious.

Thanks.

Henry

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

#2

Alan Zenreich

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of t

Alan Zenreich

I am one of those folk who turn on the dust collector every time my lathe is running. It does a good job of sucking up a good portion of the dust. My respirator gets whatever is trying to find its way into my lungs, and a room air filter gets anything swirling around in the air.

So, is this overkill? I don't think so... Not in my basement shop that lives below my dining room and office.

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

#3

NOT a waste of time, IMHO.

Doc Green

My experience is that while a dust collector at the lathe will not capture All the dust, it will get most of it, and every little bit helps. I've also found that the end of a hose or pipe located close to where the dust is being produced is more effective that a bell or hood located farther away.

Where the dust collector is almost essential is in turning spalted wood or wood that has bug frass or powder post beetle damage. I'm sure you would never turn such wood, but if you do, you will appreciate the dust collector.

MDF is also a big dust producer, if you turn a piece for a jig or whatever.

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

#4

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of t

steve worcester

For chip, yep, for dust, no

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

#5

No!

Carole Valentine

I have one of those flexible "stay-put" 4 inch hoses at my lathe. It sucks in all of the sanding dust. When I forget to turn it on, I pay for it! I don't worry about shavings...they just fall to the floor and get swept up. It's the fine stuff I am after.

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

#6

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of t

robo hippy

This is my sanding hood. It is only used when I sand as I turn green to final thickness, let them dry and warp, then sand and finish. Some day, I will build more of a permanent one that stays up whenever I am turning. I will be able to partition it off into sections for when I do turn dry wood. The more you collect at the source, the less there is in your shop and your lungs.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AZsVc7qVx7A

robo hippy

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

#7

Dick Hines

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of t

dick hines

I am not sue you can collect ALL the dust made by wood turning. I have two dust systems and still can see dust in the air. Not a lot but it is there.

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

#8

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of t

Barry Irby

I agree with all of the above. For roughing I think it would be nearly impossible to set up any kind of effective hood that would not be in the way, but for sanding, I bring the four inch hose off my DC up and trap it in the tool rest and put it as close as I can. It looks like some sort of wind tunnel test. You can see the dust streaming into the hose. It gets most of it. I think a relatively small inlet works better than a large funnel or box. Anything that flares the end of the hose reduces the velocity of the air proportionately. What you want is a high velocity air stream to capture the particles.

And, Carol is right, while the big shavings are obvious and messy, they are not a health risk. Its the Nearly invisible stuff that gets into your lungs. Anything that falls out of the air is harmless or nearly so.

A small warning. If you are hand sanding with a small piece of sandpaper and you lose your grip on it the DC will snort that up too. Quickly.

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

#9

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of t

Bill Howatt

I wear a respirator for all turning, rough, finish, wet dry, bowls and spindles. I do use a DC when sanding as well.

No attempt to try and catch the heavy shavings, IMO, it is not worth the bother and they are relatively easy to shovel up. Try and make the turning area so it is easy to clean up shavings.

Bill

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

#10

No!!

Jorge

Specially at sanding time.

The big shavings are easy to gather with a dustpan or shovel, the fine dust is not, just floats around and we breath.

In my book dust collection at the lathe is a must.

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

#11

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of t

Ron Solfest

Agree with all that a dust collector is great to catch most of the sanding dust, I also have a JDS air filter that I run when sanding. Regarding big shavings, I originally installed a floor sweep vent thinking that would be a good idea...after an hour or two of ripping apart the ducting to clear all of the clogged shavings I've since removed the floor vent and am happy to use shovel :)

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

#12

Harry Robinette

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of t

Harry Robinette

I have two 4" hoses one behind the lathe the other in front and they collect allot of the dust. I use just the hose end NO bells or big mouths. The hoses are 4" flex and stay I got from Woodcraft and their connected to my 1200 CFM Delta.

I also use a Jet ambient air cleaner and a positive pressure face mask.

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

#13

Brian McKearney

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of t

Brian McKearney

I would say that dust collection is ABSOLUTELY WORTHWHILE.

Many years ago before I had dust collection at the lathe, I turned a shaker stool over Christmas vacation. By the end of the week, I had a very fine layer of dust over everything in the basement. I was pretty surprised because I didn't notice "that much" dust while I was making the parts for the stool.

That was my wake-up call and that's when I did some research to find options. I decided to go with a section of 2 1/2" diameter Loc-Line attached to a 4" diameter branch off my 6" diameter main pipe that runs to my dust collector (the 4" was more convenient that 6" and I just wanted to get something working - works OK, so I never changed it). I like the Loc-Line because it can be positioned anywhere you want and it will hold its position pretty well - even with the 42" long section that I have. When sanding bowls, I position it at about 2-3 o'clock facing the headstock - as I sand, the centrifugal motion of the bowl creates a bit of wind whipping around the bowl and I find that the majority of the sanding dust circles around right into the Loc-Line.

I've included a pic that I took quickly this morning to show what I'm taking about.

By the way, If you're wondering what the "shades" are that you see behind the lathe - these are my way to control shavings and water when I'm roughing bowls. I bought these at Home Depot pretty cheaply.

Brian


Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

#14

Steven Antonucci

My lathe has no issues collecting dust on its own!


Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

#15

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of t

Don Evans

Henry, I have not had time to read the other responders but I'm going to pick on your first wording, go back and read it to refresh yourself.

Now, I've said this so many time over the years but here goes one more time! It is NOT a Chip collector, it is a DUST collector....... :D

What you want is air moving around you and going away from you when you turn or cut wood. A collector therefore has to be good enough to do that and efficient enough to collect what it gets and keep it, not dump it back into the shop.

It seems to be obvious to most that sanding on the lathe is easy to see the need but that need is also there when using gauges and skew etc, there is still fine dust being made and you want that above mentioned air pulling it away from you and going somewhere else. A vacuum cleaner can not do this, it is made for another job, the only place I have that a vacuum helps is on my router table, which also has 5" dust collector connected to it also. This is because my router (Triton) has a special vacuum port. I also use a vacuum connected to my ROS DeWalt sander and a contour sander from Dremel (they don't make them anymore sad as it is good tool to have around).

I hope you are able to go with a cyclone not bag unit.

I am giving you with this email an invitation to visit me, just outside Clayton, and take a look at my setup, I've fine tuned it for 40 years of woodworking and 35 of turning.

Email me if you like to come by, I'm retired and available most anytime.

I use two "Big Gulps" in the shop (studio, atilier(sp)), just for the above mention air movement, one is the lathe and other is power carving station.

You belong to "Woodturners Guild of NC"?

Don

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

#16

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of t

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

Don: Generous offer on the visit and I may be able to make the trip down to Clayton - although that does require me crossing the county line!

I'll nit pick as well and ask you to re-read my post. I don't actually use the term chip collector at all - I specifically mention that I DON'T expect a system to collect all the shaving, but my question related to the collecting dust generated at the lathe during sanding and fine cuts.

I did get a cyclone and canister filtration system that I am in the process of installing. The lathe and drill press are the machines that i don't have a good plan for. The few pictures and many descriptions given above have been very helpful.

And your last question - no I am not (YET) a "Woodturners Guild of NC" member, but have picked up a membership application once or twice. That time will come - likely shortly.

Henry

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

#17

Another set of great answers - consensus emerges!

Henry (Raleigh, NC)

Many thanks for the great answers, with the exception of Steve's :D . By his standard my lathe has great 'dust collection' capabilities, and he should know because we have 'very similar' lathes.

It's quite clear that there is a clear consensus, at least among those who replied. Dust collection at the lathe is not a waste of time/effort. Your pics and descriptions have been great in prodding my thinking in how to implement this.

Brian's pic of his 'stay-put' hose looks like something I should pursue.

Henry

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

#18

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of t

Don Evans

True you didn't use that word, but I didn't say you DID. I mearly stated what I have said many times in the past when discussing this issue.....

That's one of the biggest problems with these forums, people getting miss understands of the true meaning of anothers message.

Anyway, lets forget that, come down and see what I have and take it for what it is worth and then do your own thing. Mine is adjustable, sits on a stand that raises up and down, also the angle is adjustable, it's not perfect there are things I don't like about it but it will always be a work in progress.

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

#20

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of t

Jim Breeden

To plug in a DC to the lathe is not a bother to me - every little bit helps.

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

#21

JL

Floor stand

JL


I also use it for templates.

I have a big gulp hood that I can use on it, but as I turn mostly spindles, I prefer the one that is on there currently.

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of time?

#23

Re: Is "dust collection" at the lathe a waste of t

Roger Chandler

This is how I handle dust collection at my lathe.......really effective!