Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

can anyone compare...

Posts

can anyone compare...

#1

can anyone compare...

GaryG in MD

I'm planning to buy a can of General Finishes Arm-R-Seal, per Chris Groves, but I found a little unopened can of Minwax Polycrylic -- some sort of water-based poly. Can anybody compare these two finishes for me? Has anyone had good or bad luck with the Polycrylic? Thanks, Gary

Re: can anyone compare...

#2

Harry Robinette

Re: can anyone compare...

Harry Robinette

I use Arm-r-Seal all the time it's a Urethane and oil mix not a poly.It leaves a extremely nice oil look but will take a shine like a top coat. I really can't compare it to Minwax cause I don't use any Minwax at all.

Just remember to use VERY thin coats of Arm-R-Seal or it will take it awhile to dry.I think you'll find that you'll love the finish it gives you.

Re: can anyone compare...

#3

Armor-R-Seal is much like the old.....

JamieDonaldson

...mix that many use as a "home brew" Danish oil formula. I would use it only on darker woods, as the BLO content yellows lighter colored woods.

Re: can anyone compare...

#4

Re: can anyone compare...

Dick Coers

Polycrylic is water based. No color added to the wood, cold blue tint, but will never yellow.

Seal-a-cell is the direct opposite of all the above.

Re: can anyone compare...

#5

now I'm confused.....

GaryG in MD

Jamie, I learned about GF Arm-R-Seal from Chris Grove's recent post of a couple maple bowls.

www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/turning.pl/page/1/md/read/id/448585/sbj/couple-new-maple-bowls-from-crotchwood/

They didn't appear to me to be significantly yellowed, as I get from Watco Danish -- which is why I asked what finish he used. Is it just my eye? Or are you saying they'll get yellower with time? ...Gary