Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Inlace problems

Posts

Inlace problems

#1

Inlace problems

John Lucas

Many years ago when I was using a lot of Inlace I became concerned about 2 things. How well it bonded to the wood, and how wood movement would affect the bond. I did a test. I cut 2 grooves in a platter, one out near the edge and one closer in. I filled the grooves with Inlace.

On the inside ring I simply turned a detail into it after turning away most of the wood. On the outside ring I turned away all the wood so only the ring was left bonded to the outside edge of the platter. It held up well for about a year or more. Then I noticed the outer ring has separated a little. After about 2 more years the outer ring was held on by only a few inches. In the photo below I flexed the ring to make it more clear how little is attached. In normal position there is only a small gap but that's all it takes to be free.

The inner ring is still good but it is sitting in a tiny groove. I need to run a test with the wood turned flush with the bottom edge of the Inlace to see if only the bond will hold it. I don't think it will.

Bottom line, make sure any Inlace or epoxy is captured in a groove of some kind if you don't want it falling off later. I think I could have cut a groove in the side wall of the outer ring so that the Inlace would have filled that space. Then that inner groove would have acted kind of like a floating panel in frame and panel doors. It might still have come loose but would not be able to fall out. It would take a special tool to do that but naturally I never pass up a chance to build another tool.


Re: Inlace problems

#2

Re: Inlace problems

Randy Gleckler

Would be interesting to know what Larry Fox's experience with this is as he does a Lot of Rim Treatments with Turquoises and I didn't think he had many problems. Course you may have just tested longer than he has... but he likely has had feedback on pieces if this happened to them.

Re: Inlace problems

#3

Re: Inlace problems

Steve Criscenzo

Interesting result John

I have never used Inlace unconfined on a rim but I have used it in many groves on platters. A few times I have had it crack and only once did I have it come loose in a grove (the piece was not fully dry).

I have found that if I undercut the grove a bit, kind of a dovetail shape, I get much better results. I also found that the addition of fillers helps keep it together versus just the resin.

Steve

Re: Inlace problems

#4

This reflects my concerns over the years......

JamieDonaldson

...that many of the bonded inclusions filled with turquoise, Inlace, and a variety of other materials will eventually fail. Wood as an elastic material will always be subject to movement due to species characteristics, weather changes, etc. and the differences in movement will lead to joint failure.

Re: Inlace problems

#5

Re: Inlace problems

Ed Davidson

John,

Larry Fox uses 2 part epoxy with crushed stone on the outer edge of large bowls and platters (me too), and we've never had a problem with his "outlay" technique separating from non-oily woods like maple, osage or aspen.


img

Re: Inlace problems

#6

Re: Inlace problems

Barry L Elder

I agree with Ed and with Jamie. Without a high quality two-part epoxy, you are more or less hanging in the wind. I have never used InLace and I am sure that it is a good product for its' intended use. But I have filled many grooves, cracks, etc. with crushed stone of various grades and have not yet (knock wood) heard of a failure.