Re: vibration (long)
Lyle Jamieson
Verbally, you seem to be doing everything right to turn without vibration. My guess is that it is not a lathe problem but a technique issue. Everything you said so far is correct but it might be, even a little, tune up of some methods would get you over the hump.
Sharp tools are a matter degree. They have to be REALLY sharp. This is a rare place that I might even hone my edges to get them razor sharp and sharpen them often. I always hone my skew.
The lathe speed might help. Try a few higher speeds and see if that makes any difference. In my opinion faster is better.
Being self taught might mean you are scraping which causes vibration. Being relatively new at turning and if you are using a slicing cut with bevel support it is easy to get vibration with too much pressure on the bevel. We do not ride the bevel, we follow it gently. It takes considerable experience, time at the lathe, to perfect the touch the bevel needs.
The size of the shaving you are taking might be too big. If the tool is ground with a broad radius of a grind, the stress of the shaving itself can start vibration. Use a smaller tool or grind the edge so that there is a tighter radius at the cutting surface to scoop out a smaller shaving. A smaller shaving can be done by angling the cutting edge on a severe angle. A cutting edge approaching the wood at 90 degrees will be a lot more stressful then a 45 degree slicing angle. A 30 degree angle would be even better. Take small, slow, light cuts, you can't force it. The wood is going fast the tool is moving slowly across the surface. It might help to get some hands-on help from someone in a turning club near you with production experience. Turners love to help turners.
There is no mention of the kind of wood you are using. Some woods will flex more then others. The length between centers and the diameter will both determine how much vibration problems you will have. Do the details on the largest diameter parts of the spindle first, and leave the thinnest sections for last, keeping as much support as possible for as long as possible. If all else fails then the last resort would be a steady rest. Depending on the spindle, the steady rest might have to be moved several times, to do one stage of the spindle at a time, with support up close to where you are cutting.
The good news is that doing multiple repetitive things will give you valuable experience and shorten the learning curve for tool control to do other projects. I remember my first production run of 58 stair railing spindles and how much I learned from the project. One thing I learned is I don’t like production work, but my tool skills were improved big time because of it.