Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

vibration

Posts

vibration

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

vibration

Jack Guzman from Maine

I own a basic Grizzly lathe. I've used it off and on for ten years. I got it for turning handles and other minor chores. I'm still learning and all my tools are salvaged from flea markets and yard sales. I do mostly flat work so I haven't spent much time learning. I am making windsor chairs so I have to get better at the lathe if I want to make my own legs. I've been watching Curtis Buchanan's videos and reading Mike Dunbars book on turning legs . I picked up some pointers and my tools are sharp and I'm getting the hang of a skew. My main problem now is vibration. I turn at my lowest speed and use my hand to steady the piece.I've tried all different approaches with the tools and even when I seem to have everything right(real sharp tool,clean continuous shaving peeling off)I still get vibration. It scallops the surface. Would loading a bunch of sand bags onto my lathe base make a difference? Anything else I should look for?---Jack

Re: vibration

#2

Re: vibration

robo hippy

You may be getting what some refer to as 'whipping'. This is where the spindle is long, and there is not enough wood to keep it from moving from tool pressure. Ratio is 10 to 1, so a 10 inch long spindle that is 1 inch diameter will not flex at all.

You want just enough tailstock pressure to hold the piece on the lathe. If you over tighten, that can make the whipping increase.

You want gentle tool pressure. There is an art to just barely feeling the bevel on the wood compared to really rubbing the bevel. The more you fight it, the worse it gets.

Work from the tailstock end back to the headstock, and pretty much finish cut it as you go. This way, you have a bit more mass to help keep the wood stable.

A steady rest helps. If you don't have one, or want to learn without, which is possible, this is where you use your hand as a steady rest. Hand pressure = tool pressure for balance.

When you get the ripples, you have to go back to where there aren't any, and slowly come in, taking out the high spots till you are round again. Some times this is easier to do with 80 grit.

robo hippy

Re: vibration

#3

Re: vibration

Bill Howatt

I hadn't heard the 10:1 rule before but it makes me feel a lot better having fought the scallop battle many times.

I can't add anything to the post but to say that one of the things that impressed me when using a lathe in Grade 8 woodshop was that sanding straight spindles was fun.

Remember sandpaper is also a cutting tool.

Bill

Re: vibration

#4

Leo Cuellar

Re: vibration

Leo Cuellar

If it sits for long periods of time between use, the belts may be a little hard or cracked and contributing to some of the vibration. Check to be sure the head & tail stocks line up. Dust & dirt buildup in the morse tapers for the drive spurs could also be responsible. A bent drive spur a possibility as well.

Re: vibration

#5

Re: vibration

Dick Wilson

Robo covered most of the points I would make. It doesn't sound from what you discribe that weighing the lathe down will cure lyour specific problem, althoughl lots of weight on the lathe sure doesn't hurt anything and sure help in a lot of turnings. If I am doing long spindles and have your chatter problems I set up my spindle steady that I got from Oneway. That really gets rid of the problem.

Re: vibration

#6

Jack- you mention that you are turning.....

JamieDonaldson

...at a low speed, and spindle turning benefits from higher speeds than a bowl turner would use. I don't believe your lathe has a speed readout, but RPM's well above 1K for spindles are better than lower RPM's, and facilitate turning smoothly.

Re: vibration

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

Friendly place

Jack Guzman from Maine

I heard that this turning forum was a helpful place. You people gave me alot to work with. I bet my problem is a combination. There are some burrs on the shaft of the drive bit. My spindles are 20" long and less than an inch thick in places.I need to back up the tension. Probably a few more things too. I'm gonna print this stuff up and get back in the shop and do some adjustments.---Thanks all.---Jack

Re: vibration

#8

Re: vibration *LINK*

Fred Holder

Hello Jack,

There has been some excellent advice given here, but I would like to add a bit more. If possible, i.e., if you have enough length in your blank, mount a chuck in the headstock and grip the wood with a chuck. This eliminated one of the problems from drive centers. A second thing that helps, if you have a lot of spindles to turn, is a Jacobs chuck mounted to a live center in the tailstock. Now, with a chuck on each end, you can apply a pulling pressure, which almost eliminates the vibration caused by pressure between the tailstock and the headstock drive. Using this technique I've turned 1/8" spindles 12 inches long with no great problem.

The attached link will show you the device that I have to apply pulling pressure on the tailstock end. Unfortunately, the fellow who made mine has retired and is no longer making them.


http://www.morewoodturning.net/reviews/spindle_tensioning.php

Re: vibration

#9

Lyle Jamieson

Re: vibration (long)

Lyle Jamieson

Verbally, you seem to be doing everything right to turn without vibration. My guess is that it is not a lathe problem but a technique issue. Everything you said so far is correct but it might be, even a little, tune up of some methods would get you over the hump.

Sharp tools are a matter degree. They have to be REALLY sharp. This is a rare place that I might even hone my edges to get them razor sharp and sharpen them often. I always hone my skew.

The lathe speed might help. Try a few higher speeds and see if that makes any difference. In my opinion faster is better.

Being self taught might mean you are scraping which causes vibration. Being relatively new at turning and if you are using a slicing cut with bevel support it is easy to get vibration with too much pressure on the bevel. We do not ride the bevel, we follow it gently. It takes considerable experience, time at the lathe, to perfect the touch the bevel needs.

The size of the shaving you are taking might be too big. If the tool is ground with a broad radius of a grind, the stress of the shaving itself can start vibration. Use a smaller tool or grind the edge so that there is a tighter radius at the cutting surface to scoop out a smaller shaving. A smaller shaving can be done by angling the cutting edge on a severe angle. A cutting edge approaching the wood at 90 degrees will be a lot more stressful then a 45 degree slicing angle. A 30 degree angle would be even better. Take small, slow, light cuts, you can't force it. The wood is going fast the tool is moving slowly across the surface. It might help to get some hands-on help from someone in a turning club near you with production experience. Turners love to help turners.

There is no mention of the kind of wood you are using. Some woods will flex more then others. The length between centers and the diameter will both determine how much vibration problems you will have. Do the details on the largest diameter parts of the spindle first, and leave the thinnest sections for last, keeping as much support as possible for as long as possible. If all else fails then the last resort would be a steady rest. Depending on the spindle, the steady rest might have to be moved several times, to do one stage of the spindle at a time, with support up close to where you are cutting.

The good news is that doing multiple repetitive things will give you valuable experience and shorten the learning curve for tool control to do other projects. I remember my first production run of 58 stair railing spindles and how much I learned from the project. One thing I learned is I don’t like production work, but my tool skills were improved big time because of it.

Re: vibration

#10

Re: vibration

John Lucas

I think your problem is too much pressure on the bevel as mentioned above. Learn to be as light as possible. Really really sharp tools help with this. You learn to apply the same amount of light pressure with your hand on the backside of the spindle to counter the pressure from the bevel.

If you push on the bevel too hard then you have to push harder with your fingers on the backside and it burns your fingers. That's a good sign that you need to lighten up on the cut.

One think not mentioned that helps in the beginning is to start turning the spindle in the middle. Leave the ends thick at this stage. You will have less whipping of the spindle near the ends so leaving them thick reduces the chatter when cutting in the middle. As your skills improve you will get less chatter over all.

Re: vibration

#11

Tony Reynolds

Re: vibration (long)

Tony Reynolds

Great info Lyle. Funny thing, I learned to like production work because of the improved tool control and skill it taught me. Don't get me wrong, I'd rather turn a nice HF but with every production job I take on I look at it as only making me a better all round turner.

Tony

Re: vibration

#12

great thread...

GaryG in MD

Lyle, Between you and Robo, and the other respondents, you have given everyone a primer, and a virtual check list for taking a look at our techniques. Great job, Gary

Re: vibration

#13

Don Leydens

Re: vibration

Don Leydens

If this thread doesn't prove the worthiness of sites like Wood Central than nothing does. A new guy (Gary) has a problem and Robo, John, Lyle, Fred, Tony, Bill and Leo step up to the plate with some terrific advice. I wish I could add more, but to tell you the truth, I was too busy LEARNING. Makes me proud to be a turner when you see how much we love to help each other. GREAT job guys! And Gary, come back any time! I think you got a good feel for what we're all about. Please let us know how this works out for you.

Re: vibration

#14

correction...

GaryG in MD

Don, Jack is the new guy. I've been here for a while. ;-) ...Gary

Re: vibration

#15

Re: vibration

Rich

Jack don't know what model Grizzly Lathe your working from. But I've found on my Grizzly Lathe that the tool rest transfers vibration through tool to work piece. Removed swing arm portion of original tool rest set-up and are using single bed portion only connecting to rest. This seems to lesson the sanding by giving me a finer cutting and less bounce. I myself am always learning from data submitted by more experienced turners then myself. WHAT A GREAT SITE "Wood Central"

Re: vibration

#16

Those extended tool rests suck

John Lucas

I've been forced to use those a couple of time on different lathes and you just can't get a really clean cut. They do vibrate as you say. My Dad has a shopsmith and it has the cantilever tool rest as well. I get chatter no matter what when I use that but then theirs is aluminum which is even worse.

Re: vibration

#17

Don Leydens

Re: correction...

Don Leydens

I just switched the names Gary, sorry about that.

Re: vibration

#18

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Those extended tool rests suck

Jack Guzman from Maine

Curtis Buchanan has a homemade wooden tool rest. I'm thinking of trying something like it. It's the full length of the chair leg blanks.It even has holes drilled in the board that mounts to the lathe bed to hold turning tools.---Jack

Re: vibration

#19

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: correction...

Jack Guzman from Maine

I got that you were addressing me. I'm not new to Woodcentral. I hang out in the hand tool area mostly. However,I am new here and I appreciate the hospitality and all the help.----Jack

Re: vibration

#20

Re: Those extended tool rests suck

John Lucas

Jack I have done that. I had to turn a 58" spindle for a client. I fastened 2 lathes together and made a full length tool rest out of oak.

I took Curtiss Buchannan class on Windsor chairs many years ago. We used a spring pole lathe to turn the tapered tenons on the legs. The rest of the leg we carved with spokeshaves and Drawknives.

Re: vibration

#21

Re: vibration

Don Evans

Jack, I just sent you an email

Don