Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Box finial

Posts

Box finial

#1

Tony Reynolds

Box finial

Tony Reynolds

I've been making these "keepsake" boxes and am trying to come up with a knob/finial that works with them. This box is 4" in diameter and 2" tall and made from maple. The question: Is this finial to large or overpowering for the box?

Thanks for the feedback.

Tony


Re: Box finial

#2

Love it!


Re: Box finial

#3

Re: Box finial

Jim H

I think it looks great. Very well proportioned to my eye. Nice crisp detail. The finish on the box looks good as well.

Re: Box finial

#4

Re: Box finial

John Lucas

Tony I think the finial is great and the right size for the box. My only change would be the box it'self. I thinks it's too square or box. Give it some curves or taper it so it is equal to the great finial.

Re: Box finial

#5

Re: Box finial

wooden leg

I really like your box and the finial. I have a question, Has people get older some of us can't hold something that small to lift up the top, do you make the top "loose" enough that the user could lift the top off without using the finial? It really is a nice piece of work. Dave

Re: Box finial

#6

Tony Reynolds

Re: Box finial

Tony Reynolds

Thanks John. I have been doing other boxes with a rounded bottom etc. Just was working on this one and decided to try doing finials for them. Always glad to get your input!

Re: Box finial

#7

Tony Reynolds

Re: Box finial

Tony Reynolds

Hi Dave,

yes these have a loose lid. I'd rather people didn't use the finial to remove the lid, but I can't control that. Thanks for the compliment and input.

Re: Box finial

#9

comments...

GaryG in MD

Tony,

First, you've been posting some really quality work lately. I love seeing it. You're giving me all kinds of inspiration to "up" my game.

Second, I'm not a big fan of finials on boxes, but if you want one, I think you've done a very nice job of it. The form is good in all respects. I like it, and I like the fact that it's different from "just another Drozda finial" (nothing against Cindy!... and I really like them on your pedestaled HFs).

Third, given what I just said, let me be a Devil's Advocate for a moment. What you have done is great, and if it's what you like, then by all means keep it up, because a lot of other people do too, but if it were mine, I'd cut the finial off at the top of the bead. Pardon my presumption for messing with your work, but just in the vein of fun, see what you think about this: ...Gary


Re: Box finial

#10

Re: Box finial

David Walser

Tony,

I like the finial and I like the box; I'm not so sure I like the finial on the box. In the thread, you state you prefer that people don't use the finial as a handle to lift the lid. Fine. Just understand that that's what most people think a finial is for -- to serve as a fancy knob for lifting the lid. The finial appears to serve both as a decoration and as a knob. Since most finials are tall and slender, they actually makes a poor knobs. A shorter, squatter nob is easier to grab without engendering the fear that the user might inadvertently break the finial. The form is not following function.

So, for functional pieces like a box, I'd prefer any decoration not detract from the ease of using the box. So, yes to inlays, pyrography, chatter work, and other surface forms of decoration. No to finials.

Change the shape of the box so that it's more decorative and a finial becomes a more appropriate option.

Just my 2 cents.

Re: Box finial

#11

Don Leydens

Re: Box finial

Don Leydens

The finial is excellent. Love the whole box. Well done.

Re: Box finial

#12

Re: Box finial

Stuart Johnson

Tony, I like the taller finial. It has a nice crisp shape but isn't over powering and the main focal point of the box. I don't think I would worry about using it as a handle to remove the lid with a loose fit. My thinking is most boxes like this will be used by women (I know another sexist remark) so think about a perfume bottle. Many of the very fancy ones have tight fitting glass finial stoppers yet they manage to open them without slinging perfume all over. The normal reaction would be to "gently" lift the lid. If there is resistance the grip will automatically move away from the finial and to the lid. That isn't to say you won't find someone that can manage to snap it off.

Re: Box finial

#13

Re: comments...

John Lucas

What a change. Do you see how it pulls your eye down to the box? A larger finial becomes an attention getter and the both parts need to work together to keep the finial from becoming over powerful or as Cindy said in the Chat your eye should flow from one to the other.

With the smaller finial the box becomes more important so the shape and type of wood becomes more important.

thank for posting both images. Maybe we should put them side by side. I'll try that at work this morning if I have time.

Re: Box finial

#14

Re: comments...

Dale Miner

My first thought was parrallel to the pic Gary posted. The knob portion works as a handle for the lid. Also, if the finial only had the upper stem portion and not the knob portion, then the stem would work for as a handle. Both elements combined seemed to me to be one more than needed.

Here is my two cents on the fit of box lids; feel free to give change.

I am not a fan of snap fit or suction fit lids on boxes that are meant to be used. To me, a snap fit lid requires two hands to open, and for the most part, that is objectionable for routine use. A person approaches a box, lifts the lid with one hand, and retrieves or returns the contents with the other. A box that requires two hands to open adds a step to the process that does not need to be there.

A suction fit lid is perhaps even worse. The lid and box is lifted with one hand, the assembly gets over the edge of the dresser or counter, and the bottom falls off, spilling the contents and damaging the box.

Snap fit and suction fit lids do have a place however, and that is to impress other woodturners with the tool control needed to produce those fits.

Re: Box finial

#15

Tony Reynolds

Re: Box finial

Tony Reynolds

Great discussion. As expected, opinions are all over the map. I like what Gary has done, as does my wife. Here's the two side by side as John talked about. I agree on the thoughts of a snap fit box. They are of little use to a customer and provide only a source of frustration.

Thanks to all for taking the time to comment.


Re: Box finial

#16

Left one is more proportional

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

The box is really nice though.

Re: Box finial

#17

Re: Left one is more proportional

bob davis

great box..i like left better

Re: Box finial

#18

Re: Box finial

Bob Edwards

An observation on lidded boxes. If you offer a turned box to a woman she will not pick up the box but will remove the lid to look inside, leaving the free hand to remove the object in the box. A man on the other hand will pick up the entire box and remove the lid assuming he will have to unscrew or pry the lid off.

Re: Box finial

#19

Steven Antonucci

IMO left box better,but I wish the lid was thicker


Re: Box finial

#20

Tony,

GaryG in MD

I was a little reticent to alter your work, so I'm glad that you appreciate the effort and the resulting discussion. It's a great piece either way.

I believe that John is 'right on' when he says the finial takes the eye off the box. Nothing wrong with that, but it's a "different" object altogether. With the "knob", the box itself is the what the eye sees, with the knob being an adornment (as well as a practical way to remove the lid).

I normally agree with everything John says, but I'll throw in one minor difference here. In his first comment, John said that he would like a little more curve in the shape of the box. That would be fine too, but I kind of like your subtle form.

Keep 'em coming! ...Gary

Re: Box finial

#21

Steve,

GaryG in MD

Looks like about 1/3 to me -- what ratio do you like? ...Gary

Re: Box finial

#22

Steven Antonucci

more like 1/4 to my eye?

steven antonucci

35/40% is more natural.

I just think that it would be a better box if it was split differently. For this type of finial, I might even prefer it with an inset lid instead.

Steve