Re: comments...
Dale Miner
My first thought was parrallel to the pic Gary posted. The knob portion works as a handle for the lid. Also, if the finial only had the upper stem portion and not the knob portion, then the stem would work for as a handle. Both elements combined seemed to me to be one more than needed.
Here is my two cents on the fit of box lids; feel free to give change.
I am not a fan of snap fit or suction fit lids on boxes that are meant to be used. To me, a snap fit lid requires two hands to open, and for the most part, that is objectionable for routine use. A person approaches a box, lifts the lid with one hand, and retrieves or returns the contents with the other. A box that requires two hands to open adds a step to the process that does not need to be there.
A suction fit lid is perhaps even worse. The lid and box is lifted with one hand, the assembly gets over the edge of the dresser or counter, and the bottom falls off, spilling the contents and damaging the box.
Snap fit and suction fit lids do have a place however, and that is to impress other woodturners with the tool control needed to produce those fits.