Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

gotta keep these photos coming... box

Posts

gotta keep these photos coming... box

#1

gotta keep these photos coming...  box

GaryG in MD

I turn for fun. I don't have any "signature" work.

I turn what I like. If I see something I like, I may try to turn it.

I do have fun coming up with new ideas and new shapes of my own, and I change things as I'm turning them when a new form pops out of roughing. But sometimes my stuff fits into the "copy" category. I don't sell it, so no harm, no foul.

My daughter asked me for a "Tooth Fairy" box for my grandson's first ejected teeth. Now who do you think of when you think of boxes? Well, there's Raffan and Stott, and, of course, our good friend Mike Stafford. It's not a hard choice. I happen to like Mike's "coved" form that I call a "yo-yo box". So here's my shot at it. It's not his most well-known form, but it soon will be. I notice that Joe Herrmann is going to feature this form in an upcoming issue of Woodturning Design, so I had to get this in first just to show that I wasn't copying that too!

The lid fit is neither "pop" nor French (per Hans Weissflog, "too loose"). My goal, which I met, was to have it tight enough so you can pick it up by the top and the bottom won't fall off and spill the teeth out, but neither is it so tight that when you take the top off the teeth go flying across the room!

Looking at the photo, I get the impression that black walnut may be a little too open-pored for this kind of thing. Happily, it's more obvious in the photo than it is in person. Photos are so unforgiving. This is aged walnut sapwood, 2.5" x 1.5". Finished with Bush Oil, rubbed out to Abralon 4k, and waxed with carnauba and Ren. wax.

C&C welcome, Gary


Re: gotta keep these photos coming... box

#2

Re: gotta keep these photos coming...  box

matt overton

Nice execution! Keep the pics coming.

Re: gotta keep these photos coming... box

#3

Very nice Gary. good clean lines


Re: gotta keep these photos coming... box

#4

Don Leydens

Re: gotta keep these photos coming...  box

Don Leydens

Nicely done, Gary. I'm sure Mike would approve.

Re: gotta keep these photos coming... box

#5

Re: gotta keep these photos coming...  box

Stuart Johnson

Begs to be picked up and held. It appears the have the same curve so when you pick it up you don't really have a top and bottom. Is that true or is there a small flat on the bottom?

Re: gotta keep these photos coming... box

#6

Re: gotta keep these photos coming...  box

Chuck Engstrom

Nice piece of work, Gary! --chuck

Re: gotta keep these photos coming... box

#7

Mike Stafford

Re: gotta keep these photos coming...  box

Mike Stafford

Very nicely done Gary! The only suggestion I can make is to choose wood with more figure in the end grain to provide more visual interest. Since the lid/bottom overwhelmingly dominate the view I like to use a piece of wood with interesting end grain. As far as tightness the lid should not fit too tightly because the user might break off the thin edges trying to pry apart the two halves of the box.

I have not turned this form in walnut and I have to admit it looks great. I have some beautiful curly claro walnut that I might just try to duplicate your effort. I have been hesitant to use woods like walnut in this form because they can be "chippy" on the thin edges of the top and the bottom if the box is handled roughly.

The article I have in the upcoming Woodturning Design issue is entitled "Which End is Up?" and plays on the fact that this design lends itself to a 50/50 split at the join. The crowned top and bottom which I try to make identical confuses the viewer as to "Which End is Up?" This has been a very popular box for me because it is fun for people to play with as it will rock and spin when sitting with just the slightest nudge. Sized appropriately and fitted with a soft ring holder covered with fuzzy fabric it is a nice box for that "special" ring.

Gary, you flatter me by putting my name in the same context as Raffan and Stott. Thank you very much. I don't know who originated this design but it certainly was not me. I just make a variant. I hope to see more boxes from you. In case you don't know I love boxes!

Re: gotta keep these photos coming... box

#8

Re: gotta keep these photos coming...  box

Jim Breeden

Gary.....Picture perfect turning! 8) Personally, I like the open pores of the wood. To me it is real, not the "plasticized" look by all kinds of filler.

Re: gotta keep these photos coming... box

#9

Steven Antonucci

It's a good looking box...nuff said!


Re: gotta keep these photos coming... box

#10

it's completely symmetric on the outside...

GaryG in MD

It has a "round" bottom, so it can rock, but with the low profile, the curvature is not so great as to make it unstable. It does have a nice feel to it. Thanks, Stuart. ...Gary

Re: gotta keep these photos coming... box

#11

I agree, Jim...

GaryG in MD

I rarely fill. I, too, want it to look like the wood that it is.

Having said that, I also appreciate the efforts and results of our friends who are able to make things smooth and satiny, or even glossy, while keeping away from a plastic appearance. That's a real skill that I fear I have yet to master. ...Gary

Re: gotta keep these photos coming... box

#12

Thanks for the comments, Mike...

GaryG in MD

You're certainly right about the desire to have a fantastic end grain pattern because that's pretty much all you see in this form. Some tropicals are a natural for this kind of thing, but I'm thinking that it might be nice to try some figured myrtle, figured big-leaf maple, and, as you say, claro walnut. Something with birds eyes sounds like fun.

Without looking at some of your pix to see if I can figure it out, please tell me this: do you also turn boxes side grain? That would certainly open up a lot of possibilities, grain-wise, but even starting with dry wood, the small variations in shape with changes in humidity could cause a 'perfect' fit to become too loose or too tight. How do you feel about that situation?

I definitely like the idea of turning one of these into a ring holder with a small internal pillar, maybe topped by a 5-mm cabochon. I'll put that on "the list".

We'll look forward to the article!

When it comes to boxes, your name is up there in lights.

Cheers, Gary

Re: gotta keep these photos coming... box

#13

Thanks to all for your kind comments.

GaryG in MD

Boxes can become addictive. (Just ask Mike!)

I can't wait to do another one in a different wood. ...Gary

Re: gotta keep these photos coming... box

#14

Mike Stafford

Re: Thanks for the comments, Mike...

Mike Stafford

Yes, I do turn boxes in side grain but not with a snug fitting lid. All of my side grain boxes even when turned from kiln dried wood will have a loose/not sloppy lift off lid because any degree of snugness will result in twist lock fits certain seasons of the year. Turning a box from side grain affords a lot of design possibilities because of the grain patterns that can be easily displayed, cabochons, inlays, etc. I start my box turning class with side grain boxes and halfway through the week we move to end grain.

Birdseye and curly figures which can be lost in an end grain box come to life when used side grain.

I'm glad you are enjoying boxes as much as I do.

Re: gotta keep these photos coming... box

#15

thanks for the good advice! 


Re: gotta keep these photos coming... box

#16

Re: Thanks to all for your kind comments.

Jim Breeden

GaryG...I too am a beginner. To achieve perfection in this hobby (?) is a daily process, as I am still trying to find the "perfect" finish. But, to infer that many finishes I've seen are plastisized is an incorrect trerm. I think jealousy that I am not able to achieve the finish that others have, would be more the correct term here....and to all those whose feathers I ruffled......apologies. :\