Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Bandsaw Capacity

Posts

Bandsaw Capacity

#1

Bandsaw Capacity

Ron Solfest

I'm looking at replacing my Delta 14" bandsaw that cuts up to ~11" height with riser block and am curious what height capacity people have in their bandsaws, and what they'd recommend. Cost and size do matter so 24" resaw capacity is really out of the question but options exist between 12" and 16" height capabilities (with commensurate price increases). Is 12" enough? Would you recommend 14", 16"?

I'm looking for input on cutting logs for bowls, I've struggled this past summer cutting up blanks for my PM3520 but frankly most of the issue was my 3/4hp motor, but if I'm getting something new I don't want to be sorry in a couple years.

Thanks for you replies,

Ron

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

#2

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

Dennis in Southern Oregon

Ron, my 16-in bandsaw has about a 9-in throat capacity and I have often wished I could have just a bit more. However, as you point out prices rise very steeply with throat capacity. So far, in almost all cases I have found that judicious use of a chain saw solves most problems.

Dennis

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

#3

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

Hi Ron,

I have the Rikon 10-325 bandsaw. It have been a very good saw for me. I got a heck of a deal on it about 4 years ago... 600.00. I see it is closer to 950.00 now. But it has some nice features. Height of cut was what made up my mind for me. I believe it is 13". It sure comes in handy at times. But truth be told, I have a large heavy lathe and do most of my cutting of blanks with my Husqvarna chainsaw.

But there are times when I use this saw a lot. It has been a real workhorse for me. It has taken everything I have thrown at is with no complaints. Power is good and I would buy another if this one ever vanished.

Best wishes,

Dave


img

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

#4

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

John Scheideman

Do an online search of the Minimax 16". They are expensive but you get what you pay for. I bought one about 5 years ago and have never been sorry. It handles any bowl blank that I want to cut.

John

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

#5

JL

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

JL

I would also recommend the 14" Rikon. It has a 12-13" resaw capacity and a 1 1/2 hp motor.

I've got it's big brother, the 18" Rikon. That has a similar resaw capacity (and a larger motor).

That being said - how big of a bowl blank do you really need? I can understand cutting hollowform blanks that might be greater than 12" high, but I don't know about bowl blanks. They get heavy when they are that large.

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

#6

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

Jeff Willaford

Ron,

Maybe a motor upgrade and a blade change are what you need. Just a thought.

I've had a Delta 14" for 30+ years. When I started cutting bowl blanks I wasn't happy with the effort involved but solved that. A 1.5hp motor replaced the original 3/4, I added the riser and changed the type of blade. Most of my blanks are made round on the lathe but the bandsaw handles whatever I put on it now. Anything too tall (hollow forms) for the bandsaw gets the corners knocked off with the chainsaw and onto the lathe it goes.

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

#7

16" MiniMax MM16

Don Evans

I concur with John, there just isn't another machine to compare it with. There are 2 different one's though.

I got the MM16 which is heavier than the E16. This is so much better than anything coming out of Taiwan it is really a bargain at the price.

I really got feed up with cheaply made American brand saws with their crowned wheels and wheels that are so light weight. This machine will make u extremely happy. It's very nice to be able to lay something on the table's edge and it is still there after making a cut (doesn't fall off due to vibration). That makes it capable for you to make more prefect cuts with it also. My saw has now become more because of being able to do things with it that just could not be done with the others, I will not name them publicly, the "others" I mean.

One other thing I was thinking about, if I took all the money I spent on those other saws, buying them, modifications to make them better etc, I bet I bought a MM16 with all that. I could have saved tons of agrevation and tons of time that could have been better spent.

If I had known then what I know now I would have taken a loan and bought one way back then instead of waiting till I could do it with cash upfront.

Don: who doesn't work for nor has never even been to MiniMax in Texas. Tell Blasko I said hello though, he's also a woodworker but cannot remember his web site, look him up on company website.

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

#8

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

robo hippy

I have a Laguna 16HD and consider it to be one of the best buys I have made for my shop, next to the centralized dust collector, and my Robust. If you are turning bowls for sale, you need some thing like this. It has a 4.5 hp motor, while the LT version has 2 hp. You really need the extra horses. For selling bowls, I seldom go over 14 to 16 inch diameter. That is a more specialized market, and if some one wants a bowl bigger than that, the chainsaw can do fine. The advantages to having a bandsaw this big is that when you start turning the bowl blank, your surfaces are +/- 1/8 inch, not like the chainsaw job where you are lucky to get within an inch. Big time saver. I have a 1 1/4 inch Lennox Diemaster bimetal resaw blade. Perfect for cutting bowl blanks.

All you have to do with the chainsaw is to cut the log down the pith, the rest you can do in your shop.

robo hippy

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

#9

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

steve worcester

Going above 12" is where the money comes in. Sure, you can have 12" of resaw capability, but cutting 12" of wet wood with a 1.5" motor gets to be a lot of work.

At that point, look at Laguna, Mini-Max or Agazanni if you want to buy the last bandsaw ever. I am sure there are several others out there that will do just fine, but look for larger wheel size (16"+), larger motors, I would say, >2HP TEFC motor, 3HP+ preferred (over 18" of resaw, I would say 4HP+) , but the other item to consider is table size. As you start to cut larger and larger logs, you need help getting them onto the table, you can't get to the end of your cut and have to pick up the log to go back to the front of the blade, it may be too heavy. So if the table isn't large enough, on the out feed or the right side of the blade, you will need to make table extensions.

Granted, all of my observations are based on my own use with a large Laguna

http://turningwood.com/moab.htm

and I don't do any resaw in the traditional sense, I cut wet and large logs down for woodturning.

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

#10

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

Dale Bonertz

Robo,

Isn't a 1 1/4" resaw blade a bit wide for making the curve on a blank? Seems like it would drag as you cut the curve on a blank. Or are you just knocking off the corners? Inquiry minds want to learn. :)

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

#11

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

robo hippy

Yes, a 1 1/4 inch blade is for resawing only. You can do a very slight arc with it. I only nibble off the corners on blocks thicker than 6 inches. I have an industrial PM with a 1 hp motor, and 6 inch cutting height.

The point about the table is right, they are too small. It seems to me that most bandsaws are made more for cutting curves (deeper throat depth), and less for resawing (little table support) If you get a bigger saw, you will most likely need some outfeed tables and sleds, so things don't fall off after you cut them.

Harbor Freight makes a nifty electric hydrolic lift table on wheels for lifting heavy things.

The dust ports on all bandsaws are terrible. I keep thinking about a floor vent type in the bottom door. Another 'round-to-it' project. If you stand a log on end to cut, you get a lot of hairballs in the bottom of your saw. Maybe I need to design and make my own.

robo hippy

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

#12

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

Ron Solfest

Thanks for the replies and insights. I'm sure that many better turners and woodworkers do superior work with the equivalent of my current Delta (or less) but I've developed the 'itch' to upgrade my bandsaw (as I did 10yrs ago with my tablesaw from Craftsman to Unisaw, and my lathe a few years ago from Jet to PM3520, etc). While the Italian's would certainly provide me a high quality saw that should outlast me, I'm not sure if my true hobbyist needs justify the price, and my shop wouldn't really fit Steve's MOAB.

After sorting through comments, and lots of other internet searches, I'm pretty sure the Laguna 3000 LT16 with 12" resaw and 3hp would meet my needs and they're tossing in the Driftmaster fence with this right now. Still, I'm tempted by the LT18 with 15.5" resaw and 4hp just so I'm not tempted to 'upgrade' again in a few years :) I'll have to talk to Laguna and see how good of deal can be had...

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

#13

Re: Bandsaw Capacity

John Scheideman

Ron,

While I am still sold on my MiniMax MM16, I don't think you can go wrong with a Laguna or Agazzani either. One other thing that I really like about MiniMax is their customer service. They are just tremendous about making sure their customers are happy. Enjoy your upgrade. You will love it!

John