Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

be gentle... ;-)

Posts

be gentle... ;-)

#1

be gentle...  ;-)

GaryG in MD

OK, here's a two parter, each with a story:

I love Hans Weissflog's Saturn boxes and decided to play around with the concept when I got this nice piece of green black locust with nice rings (as it all does). I wasn't up to making the box, but I wanted to do a prototype to see how the wood would do as far as the ring is concerned. (The ring is free and spins.) Black locust cracks if you even look at it wrong (no quantum mechanics here!), so I didn't expect it to last, being turned on the pith, as it is. But I did my best by spritzing with with water as I turned it, and sealed it with spray shellac at every opportunity. Well, very surprisingly, it hasn't cracked. The only thing caused by drying (so far anyway, and that was many months ago) is a slight cupping of the ring. OK, successful experiment.

So now I need a pedestal for it. I drew up the simplest possible form -- just a clean teardrop shape with a foot and platform. I started with a cylinder of dry black walnut sapwood. Most of the wood used in pedestals is turned away and basically wasted. So when I rough, I don't just blast the wood out of the way. I practice whatever tool or shape comes to mind. Well, when I made the first cut under the upper platform, I decided to make some christmas tree type cuts and left them there momentarily. Then I practiced a couple captured rings. Then it was getting fun, so I threw in a little mini Saturn and some rings on the lower teardrop to balance it. Wow, this is turning into German art deco! What the heck. I kept it all except for the top section of the platform. A little ebonizing to match the color of the black locust better, and it's ready to display.

The Saturn is 4" x 2", and the pedestal is 6" x 1.5".

I took it to my monthly Show & Tell and got some serious flak for the overblown pedestal. That's OK, I still kind of like it. So what if it's over the top? I submit it for your disapproval.

C&C welcome. I can take it.

...Gary


Re: be gentle... ;-)

#2

here's the Saturn alone...

GaryG in MD


Re: be gentle... ;-)

#3

Re: be gentle...  ;-)

Stuart Johnson

Every globe needs a nice stand. I like the combination, well done.

Re: be gentle... ;-)

#4

Re: be gentle...  ;-)

John Lucas

Gary the stand is georgous and I like the Saturn, especially the ring concept. You did a wonderful job . If I have any thoughts it all it is on the planet itself. It doesn't look round. Sort of like a 2 bowls put together. I think it if the planet were round you would have pulled off a fantastic piece.

Re: be gentle... ;-)

#5

Don Leydens

Re: be gentle...  ;-)

Don Leydens

I was thinking the same thing as John.

Well done.

Re: be gentle... ;-)

#6

Re: be gentle...  ;-)

Hal Taylor

Gary, I'm undecided about the stand. I guess I tend toward "too much". I like the small Saturn in the stand, but the rest of it may be too much. Unfortunately, you may have to make a couple more to get your answer.

Re: be gentle... ;-)

#7

Re: be gentle...  ;-)

Randy Gleckler

Gary I think you did a cool job on it. I'd agree with John's comments if I was to critique it and say the two sides of the sphere look a little elongated such that instead of being round, they look more like bowls than 2 half's of a sphere. As for the stand, there may be too much going on, none of it wrong, just too much. Until I went back and read, I had missed the captured ring and the bottom. All that said, in my mind I was thinking - what if he had turned the ring off center on the stand Saturn as well.... so I probably would have messed with things on the stand as well. Good job on it, looks like fun

Re: be gentle... ;-)

#8

Gary, only 1 thing matters, and that......

JamieDonaldson

...is "did you have fun making them?!" ;)

Re: be gentle... ;-)

#9

Ditto what Jamie said


Re: be gentle... ;-)

#10

Keith Tompkins

Re: be gentle...  ;-)

Keith Tompkins

Hi Gary,

I agree with John on the sphere, but love the stand.... :)

Re: be gentle... ;-)

#11

Brad Vietje

Looks Great!  BTW:  Saturn is NOT a Shpere! *LINK*

Brad Vietje

Fine work Gary -- looks great, and if they don't like the fancy stand, then they obviously don't know how fancy Saturn is...

OK, please indulge me here -- I teach Astronomy (No "L"!!!), and telescope making, so this is a slow-pitch softball coming right over the plate to me :b

First: Saturn is not spherical (nor is Jupiter, or the Sun, BTW). The "gas giants" are not solid objects, but mostly a very dense gas, which is flattened from the rotation of the planet. You can visualize this by imagining (or playing with...) a water balloon spinning on a counter-top, which becomes wider than it is tall. Both Saturn and Jupiter rotate rather fast -- Saturn is ~10h14min, and Jupiter is 9h50 min. When you figure how large these fella's are, the velocity of the "surface" (actually the visible tops of the clouds, which depends on the wavelength of the detector...) is really, really fast!

Then: it starts getting weird.... The rotation (of all three) is faster at the equator than at the poles, too! This means the dense clouds of gas are constantly being churned and twisted, so there are very interesting eddied and currents and semi-permanent features visible in telescopes (like the great Red Spot and Equatorial Belts on Jupiter)

So: Nice turning Gary. Now go for the hollow box! I have not had much trouble with Black Locust cracking, but if you're using the entire stem of a 4" - 5" sapling, you might have a lot more moisture to dissipate than I usually do. And if you want to get it just right, make the globe a little wider through the equator than through the poles, and you'll have the real deal... no telescope required!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

PS: Link shows Saturn through a telescope 2 years ago when the rings appeared edge-on. Shows a typical, medium-power view in a good quality telescope, including the turbulence of the atmosphere.


Saturn Edge-On

Re: be gentle... ;-)

#12

Steven Antonucci

Short list of "little offs"

steven antonucci

1.) The round vs. not round jumped out at me first

2.) The proportion of the top element to the base is too similar. I would have liked to see a bigger base, smaller top.

3.) The weight of the lower element seems a little bit low. I would have moved it up a bit (the double ring)

Other than that, I think it's a neat concept. Love the Saturn detail in the finial.

Steve

Re: be gentle... ;-)

#13

THANKS!

GaryG in MD

I'll try to respond to each reply directly, but let me say in general that:

1) I appreciate the show of support and thoughtful comments on my Saturn and pedestal;

2) The comments are all positive, whether they offer a simple 'like' or a list of things that could be changed;

3) It shows that we can do this here on WC -- more pix of our work and observant, helpful, and courteous critiques, whether offered for possible change or not.

4) Let's keep it rolling. ...Gary

Re: be gentle... ;-)

#14

thank you, Stuart!


Re: be gentle... ;-)

#15

re shape...

GaryG in MD

Thank you, John. I'm glad you like it.

Your eye (and that of the other respondents) is very good, indeed.

The tangent of the would-be hemisphere is not quite vertical at the ring plane. My bad. Very good point. I'll have to watch that more closely "next time" (if I do a box -- I try not to make two of the same forms unless they're for gifts). I'd like to blame some of that on shrinkage, but I'm not sure I'm justified in doing so. BUT, it did, of course, shrink -- see below. ...Gary

Re: be gentle... ;-)

#16

good eye, Don...

GaryG in MD

See other comments... ...Gary

Re: be gentle... ;-)

#17

Hal,

GaryG in MD

Our Critique panel certainly agreed with you.

I know it's over the top, but once I got started, I couldn't stop! ...Gary

Re: be gentle... ;-)

#18

Thanks, Randy...

GaryG in MD

It was definitely fun.

With Barbara Dill's multi-axis influence running rampant through our community right now, I have to admit that it came to my mind that I should do one with the pedestal's saturn ring canted at an angle as an exercise. Will it work? Only one way to find out. I'll probably give it a try just to see... But, frankly, I'm not sure that would be as good from a design point of view. Maybe that would be "too much". Hard to say... ...Gary

Re: be gentle... ;-)

#19

Jamie,  We don't like nails in our turnings...

GaryG in MD

... but you hit that one on the head. I certainly had a lot of fun.

And that's the only reason I turn. ...Gary

Re: be gentle... ;-)

#20

Thank you, Keith...

GaryG in MD

Coming from someone with your design and sculpture creds, that means a lot to me. I believe I did some of the work on the pedestal with my Tompkins V-Skew. Hope to see some new work from you soon! ;-) ...Gary

Re: be gentle... ;-)

#21

very thoughtful comments, Steve...

GaryG in MD

1) It doesn't look as obvious in person as it does in the photo, but the photo doesn't lie. I used a cardboard semicircle cutout to try to get the shape right, but it failed me at the boundary. I missed the fact that the tangent is not quite vertical at the ring plane. (That's not an easy cut to make.) Actually, the angle on the "bottom" hemisphere, that you can't see, is a tad better, but I wanted the ring cupping concave down for display purposes.

2) I really like this comment. And it's all my fault! I originally had it bigger and than made it smaller for some reason I can't remember. You're absolutely right! Is everyone listening? This is a very good design comment. I'll certainly keep it in mind for the future.

3) I'll have to disagree with you on this one. I turned it by eye, and, as I noted, according to the original simple, plain design, this element was not going to be in the finished piece. Having said that, I just measured it, and here are the ratios:

The saturn ring is 1-1/8" = 18/4% down from the top, and the center of the lower double ring is at 1-1/4" = 20/4 up from the bottom. So the bottom "element" is actually slightly higher above the base than the upper element is down from the top. These proportions are basically "fifths", and that seems to work for me.

Thanks for your thoughts and "likes". ...Gary

Re: be gentle... ;-)

#22

Brad, I really love your comments...

GaryG in MD

When I was a kid in a little town in SD, with crystal clear skies and very little light pollution to worry about, I was enamored with astronomy and stared endlessly at the sky. And we had some SERIOUS Northern Lights in the winter! I can still remember the green curtains in the northern sky. I checked out every book in our Carnegie Library in the 629.13 (Dewey Decimal) section and read them all twice. Of course, thanks to modern astronomers and NASA, we now know SO MUCH MORE than we did then. I still love to watch all the astronomy programs on the Discovery Science channel (and the like), and, what's amazing, progress is so rapid in the field that I still learn new things from this form of popular media, even though I now have degrees in engineering and physics. My computer home page is the "Astronomy Picture of the Day". I recommend it to everyone (http://apod.nasa.gov/apod). Today's is a wild one.

Did you notice that the rings of the black locust were even correct down to the darker radial density features whose origins are still in doubt? ;-)

So you have to know that I love your comments and little video of Saturn with rings edge-on. It's clearly an oblate spheroid fatter at the equator. I made the Saturn with equal polar and equatorial dimensions, but it was turned green, so the equator has now been squashed in. It's backwards by 7.6%! Oh no!! Well, now I know the radial shrinkage factor of black locust. ;-)

If I go for the box, I'll have to do a roughout and let it dry before I finish turn it. And you can be sure it'll be an oblate spheroid (with a vertical tangent at the ring plane!).

Thanks for the fun reply, Gary