Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

McNaughton thoughts

Posts

McNaughton thoughts

#1

McNaughton thoughts

Richard Jones

A few thoughts since I got my McNaughton. The other info that I've seen on the web has contained more math in it than I care to use or learn.

When I'm coring bowls with the McN, I've been trying to "track" where my tool post is in relation to the piece to try and get some sort of "standard" data points. The distance between the base and the piece doesn't change that much, so I'm trying to develop a means of measuring where the toolpost is in relation to the interior diameter of the core, depending upon thickness of blank, diameter of blank, and which knife I use. I almost always wind up using the middle sized knife in my set (standard).

Of course, I'm trying to do all this AND not take an hour doing it each time. Currently I'm using a framing square to "extend" the interior diameter line higher, and eyeballing the knife over both it and the McN gate. I also made a very long tool post that will extend up over the bowl, but it has a bit of play in it and I don't trust it as much. The FS system works pretty well so far, haven't made any religious artifacts (hol-e-y bowls) in some time now........ That's when I call the tool the McNaughty................

Any thoughts?

Rich

Re: McNaughton thoughts

#2

Re: McNaughton thoughts

D. Hansen

Rich try putting the point of the knife over the spot where you want the core to be. that is out side the bowl just over the point. Then swivel the knife around the point until it is over the point where you want it to exit the bowl. that is determined by the thickness of the bowl edge you want. that is where the tool post should be started. You can change the position of the tool post as you work if needed so nothing is set in concrete. remember though to start the cut with the knife point perpendicular to the bowl edge.

Measuring where the knife is during the cut is relatively easy. The knife point is directly in line with the center line of the handle. I took a piece of 1/4 flat aluminum about 1/8" thick. Bent it 90 degrees. One leg is long enough to raise it over the top of the bowl. The other is exactly the length from the handle to the point of the knife. When you hold the aluminum tool flat against the face of the handle where the knife comes out of the handle the point of the leg will be over the point of the knife.

Re: McNaughton thoughts

#3

Joe Fleming

Re: McNaughton thoughts

Joe Fleming

Richard,

Send me an email off-line and I'll send you an article that might help.

Joe

Re: McNaughton thoughts

#4

Re: McNaughton thoughts

Barry Irby

Richard, I have the standard set as well and have struggled with it. When I got mine only the middle knife was bent any where near correctly. It helps to understand that the knives must be a segment of a circle. If it is part of an ellipse it can not track inside its own kerf unless you wallow the kerf out really wide and that is exactly what you don't want to do, because that is wasting the blank.

Take a piece of paper and draw some concentric (semi)circles about a half inch apart. You should be able to lay your knives on them and find two that the knife will lie neatly between. That's its path or kerf. If you can't fit the knife between tow of them and it is clearly something other than a part of a circle, it won't work well.

Also, the tip of the knife should be in a direct alignment with the straight part of the blade. If so, you now "know" where the tip is when buried in the cut. You can use a laser for the location if you have a laser pointer set up. You can also use the bent angle or even a plumb bob if you can get ti set up.

When I was struggling with this I used a template for the set up. Lets say your blank is 6" by 12". Use a piece of Plexiglas 6" by 12" and mark the center on one long edge. Clamp it into the chuck between tow of the jaws so that the center is centered in the chuck and the long edge is against the chuck body. Use tape or a dry erase marker to put and image of your bowl on the Plexi. Then you cant set this in the horizontal position and slide you cutter under it and see where it goes. You can set the entry point and angle and then watch the path the knife takes. You can see the bottom thickness. As long as you set the post in a rigid position and slide the knife against the two posts, the path will remain the same. Then you take the Plexi out of the chuck and mount the blank without moving the post and cut the bowl.

I have a piece of plexi I use for this over and over and I can take a picture if you want. I just stick a piece of tape on it where I want to enter the blank and that's pretty much it.

Re: McNaughton thoughts

#5

Joe..........

Richard Jones

I sent you an e-mail from your AAW contact info......

Thanks.

Rich

Re: McNaughton thoughts

#6

Dick Hines

Re: McNaughton thoughts

dick hines

Richard get a cope of Mike Mahoney's DVD and watch it. He makes coreing easy.

Re: McNaughton thoughts

#8

Dick & Tony....

Richard Jones

I do have Mike's DVD, and Reed Gray's. I'm not having too much trouble with my "system", I was just interested in what others are doing to try and take some of the guesswork out of it.

Thanks.

Rich

Re: McNaughton thoughts

#9

Tony Reynolds

Re: Dick & Tony....

Tony Reynolds

I guess there is a bit of "guesswork involved" , but it's like Mike says in the DVD "the more you do it the luckier you get". I can consistently get 3 nice bowls out of a 12" blank just eye balling it. I just need to figure out what to do with the smallest ones. I have piles of them.