Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

New video on roughing bowls and platters. *LINK*

Posts

New video on roughing bowls and platters. *LINK*

#1

New video on roughing bowls and platters. *LINK*

John Lucas

I would say about every other week someone on one of the Forums writes in about getting catchs with a roughing gouge. That's because they are using them to rough out bowls or platters. I had that question just yesterday so I decided it was time to show how I rough out using a bowl gouge and a couple of different spindle gouges. Hope it's useful to some of you.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rd988yk6lSE

Re: New video on roughing bowls and platters. *LINK*

#2

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Clear, concise and......

Jesper, Denmark

...........very useful - as usual.

keep 'em coming.

Re: New video on roughing bowls and platters. *LINK*

#3

Re: Impressive, I now understand

John Kaner

why I was having some problems... Your videos are some of the best I've seen and you make it look so simple. I have learned a lot and I appreciate them.

Thank you and keep them coming!

Re: New video on roughing bowls and platters. *LINK*

#4

Steven Antonucci

Illustrates one of the things I teach

steven antonucci

The other thing you constantly see in Youtube videos is that a lot of beginners try to make a bowl in one cut.

I constant remind them that there is no penalty for going slow(ly).

I use a bowl gouge to rough out this way on the lower left wing. During my class, I got 5x3" rounds into bowl blanks in 13 cuts. 7 outside, 6 inside. It not only works very quickly, but very cleanly too because of the cutting angle and the low handle. It can be done one handed because it is so stable.

Good video...even with the Max Headroom edits :D

S

Re: New video on roughing bowls and platters. *LINK*

#5

Re: New video on roughing bowls and platters.

robo hippy

Well done, but I have one point to contest, and I know I am a minority here. When showing the SRG (spindle roughing gouge) you show the classic error most people make when trying to use that tool on bowls. They present it to the wood the same way they do when they are turning spindles, which is flutes straight up. You do not present your other gouges to the bowl wood that way. If you roll the flutes on the SRG over like you do when using the bowl gouges, the wings will not come into contact with the wood, and the cutting edge of the tool is properly balanced over the tool rest. Using the continental type SRG/wide shallow fluted gouge, you can run into the same problem if you cut above the center line of the tool, rather than on the bottom third.

There was a post here a while back that showed a video from Robbo, an Australian turner who demoed what can go wrong with a SRG when used on bowls, and then I posted one on how to properly/safely use it.

I do not recommend using a SRG for roughing bowls. There are many other tools that perform far better. You can get a very clean finish cut with one IF and only IF it is rolled onto its side for a high angle shear cut.

robo hippy

Re: New video on roughing bowls and platters. *LINK*

#6

Ya Done Good, Appreciate Ya!!!!!


Re: New video on roughing bowls and platters. *LINK*

#7

Re: New video on roughing bowls and platters.

John Lucas

Reed I agree and I was trying to show how it catches. Mostly because that's what beginners tend to do. However if you watched me get a catch with the larger spindle gouge you'll see that this larger shape is still kind of tricky even with the proper orientation.

Granted I was working around a tripod and didn't have the best stance. That being said the detail gouge and bowl gouge are much easier to use with the flute at about 10 oclock than the roughing gouge or larger flat spindle gouge.

Re: New video on roughing bowls and platters. *LINK*

#8

Re: New video on roughing bowls and platters.

robo hippy

One interesting cut you can do with the Continental style gouge is to come off the bevel and to what most call a shear scrape, where bevel is about 45 degrees to the wood surface. Michael Mouse uses this cut outside and inside the bowl. I still find it easier to rub the bevel though.

robo hippy

Re: New video on roughing bowls and platters. *LINK*

#9

Re: New video on roughing bowls and platters.

Wally Dickerman

John, your instructional videos are great and I'm sure much appreciated by most all levels of turners.

My question is: Why use a spindle gouge or a detail gouge when roughing out a bowl? The bowl gouge will do it all, easier and faster, with less moving of the tool rest, because the bowl gouge has a longer reach.

Re: New video on roughing bowls and platters. *LINK*

#10

Re: New video on roughing bowls and platters.

John Lucas

Wally The only reason I showed the spindle gouges was because I was turning a mirror body which is like a platter and many beginners don't have a bowl gouge. Personally I use a bowl gouge somewhere on almost every turning. I am planning to do a bowl gouge video just haven't worked out how to do it right.