wanting to attempt a natural edge bowl. I just cut a rough bowl blank out of pecan.. so do i turn it and soak the bark in CA after figuring out my rough shape and letting it sit for 3 months or do i soak the whole top in CA?
course im assuming you do put ca on the edge... heard someone using it for that reason to keep the bark from flying off so thought it might be something normal..
What I do is to cut from the lip down to just below the bark line when doing the outside. This is the opposite direction you should cut because it's against the grain. However with a good sharp tool the cuts are clean and best of all it doesn't pull the bark off. On a lot of woods that I've turned that isn't necessary but some it's a must.
I rarely use then CA. I use it more to stiffen the inner bark layer because it either doesn't cut clean or doesn't sand clean. even then thinned lacquer does the trick.
It's probably just me but I think when the tree is cut and the species has as much to do with keeping the bark on as proper cutting technique.
Darrin, I can never remember this correctly, but I think the rule of thumb is that if the tree was cut in winter when the sap is not running the bark has a much better chance of hanging on and there's no need for gluing the bark on. If it's cut in the sspring or summer the sap is soft and there's a greater chance of it pulling off.
When I turn a natural edge bowl I always turn it start to finish. I never twice turn them. That's not so say that you couldn't. Make sure when you're cutting at the bark you're always cutting toward the bowl and never away from it. Your chances of pulling the bark off will be greatly reduced.
I've turned quite a bit of pecan, both wet and dry. Never had any problems with any of the bark on about a half dozen natural edge bowls. I've still one ~12" natural edge piece that's rough turned and has been sitting for about four years and the bark is still firmly attached. The very large tree blew down in Hurricane Isabel in September 2003, near Kilmarnock, Virginia. I was given the branches and crown (the owner ended up getting over 700 board ft. of 5/4 lumber out of the main trunk). While I think the winter/summer thing is appropriate for some species, I'm not certain about the hickory family, and don't think it applies to pecan - at least not to this particular one!
I agree with the previous comments on direction of cut to keep the bark on the bowl. I have always turned them from start to finish in one turning session. If the bark stays on then you have a bark edge bowl and if not just remove the remainder of the bark and you will have a natural edge bowl. They both are real nice. Go for it and give it a spin.
I agree 100% with Jen. I live in the northern Adirondacks and have the opportunity to turn a lot deciduous timber. It is correct that trees cut after the sap has gone down (the leaves have all dropped) are candidates for bark-on natural edge...but one never knows for sure. As Jen does, I always turn natural edge once and embrace the shape change that comes from drying. If the bark comes off....so be it. Ron.
I have only turned a few pieces of Pecan (not a native wood for me), but I use CA only when needed. In my experience, if the tree is felled during the winter (dormant) period, there will be a lot less moisture in the cambium, and if the log is fresh, the bark has a very good chance of staying on if you are careful.
If spring cut, or not green, the bark has a much greater tendency to separate. Like John says, cut down onto the bark rim from above (rim towards foot), until you are below the lowest part of the bark, then cut from foot towards rim on the rest, taking care to blend these two curves together.
CA will both darken and harden most woods, so when used to help adhere the bark, great care must be taken to control the spread of CA into the sap wood. If you DO get staining of the sapwood, you may need to apply CA to the entire band of sapwood to get away from the blotchy (botched) look.
I've had mixed luck applying CA with the tiny tips that come with most bottles. Eventually, these tend to get gummed up, cut shorter (and larger), and its very easy to apply too much. Stay away from Q-Tips or cotton swabs. Cotton fibers are part cellulose, so they will harden the CA just like the wood will. Instead, try making little applicators out of polyester batting from a fabric store. Cut a little strip (about 1" x 2"), bend in half and twist it into a little tight q-tip sorta part in the middle, and wrap the rest tightly in masking tape to make a little handle. You can make a dozen or so in a few minutes for next to nothing.
All woods are different. Some will develop a punky, fibrous layer which can be filled and hardened with CA (Oaks can do this if not fresh), and others are rough and tend to collect little fibers from your applicators. these have to be removed with tweezers, or sanded through. Once you start adding CA, you may not be able to stop!
A whole 'nuther issue is that the sapwood, the bark, and the cambium layers all shrink in different amounts, so when the wood dries, you can have an unusual edge profile. You'll have to decide how much of an issue this is, and what you want to do about it.
Good luck, and I hope you can show your process and the results.
...and I'd add an aesthetic comment about bark edges: All or None.
If you can't keep all the bark on (or can't repair it to look good), then take all the bark off. I usually do demo's on natural edge work at local clubs and regional symposia in the area, and call this "Brad's rule of natural edge bowls and vases".
If you submit a piece to a gallery or a instant gallery critique with part of the bark on, and part off, then you don't want me on the judging panel! I have to say, I don't think I have ever seen a single example of a turning with partial bark loss that I liked..... I could be wrong, but I can't think of a single example.
I've turned a lot of natural edge bowls, some once turned, some twice turned. There are advantages and disadvantages both ways. Green wood is easier to cut, dry wood is easier to sand.
My experience is the fresher the blank, the more likely the bark will stay on. Don't pass up a perfectly nice piece of wood just because it was cut in the "wrong" time of year.
I've turned a lot of pecan, which happens to be the national tree of Texas. You might want to finish turning your roughed out blank now. When pecan dries, it becomes pecancrete. Don't bother turning off your grinder if you want to turn dry pecan.
Wil is fond of turning natural edge bowls, and he likes them with the bark on. Wil has gotten so proficient at replacing the bark when he has loses that he often brings them to S&T to challenge the audience to "find the fix".
For me, if I lose one bit of bark, I take it all off. I will never have the patience to reattach it and blend the mess back to looking good.