Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

John Lucas Video Request

Posts

John Lucas Video Request

#1

John Lucas Video Request

Stuart Johnson

John, you asked for questions for a video and then discussion. I would like to see something showing the difference between a U and V gouge with the same fingernail grind. I find a V gouge easier to use but don't know why.

Re: John Lucas Video Request

#2

Re: John Lucas Video Request

john lucas

Interesting. I'll have to look and see if I have U. I bought a V because I like the thickness of the wings. I will look into it this weekend. If I have a friend with an Ellsworth grind I'll try to get my fingers on one of those as well.

Lets get a discussion going here so I'll understand more what people think about the 2 tools or other grinds that are similar.

Re: John Lucas Video Request

#3

Well that was easy I just found an Ellsworth gouge


Re: John Lucas Video Request

#4

Re: John Lucas Video Request

Guy Bratt

I also find the V easier to control. When using the U I think it's easier to get a heavy catch if the tool rotation goes off. If the flute gets rotated to far up for the cut being attempted there's a lot of cutting edge exposed. ??

Re: John Lucas Video Request

#5

Re: John Lucas Video Request

robo hippy

A V is easier to control? Well, I prefer the Thompson V, which to me is more of a U shape. For a V gouge, I think of the Glaser, or D Way gouges. The "catch" factor seems, to me, to be more related to the wing shape.

A swept back grind, is very catch prone if you are holding the tool more level, and especially so if you have the flutes up rather than rolled away from the wood you are cutting.

A traditional grind/fingernail grind/45-45 degree grind, with shorter wings, will work a bit better here, as in you can cut up on the wings a tiny bit. If you don't drop the handle, the tool is unbalanced and the wing will tip into the wood. If you drop the handle, the tool is balanced, and will cut fine. I call this is the Steve Antonnuchi cut (did I spell that right), and he posted a video of that a few months ago. I had never noticed the difference when you drop the handle till I saw Steve's one handed cut while he held the camera in the other hand.

The bottom of the bowl grinds which are straight across with little or no sweep for wings, and more blunt work best with the handle level, and flutes up or rolled slightly away from the cut. Almost impossible to get a catch.

There are big differences in how the tool cuts, depending on handle level or dropped, and flutes up or rolled over on the side. Actual flute shape makes less of a difference, at least to me.

V flutes clog up often if I try to use them for roughing, but scrapers, to me are far more efficient.

robo hippy

Re: John Lucas Video Request

#6

Re: John Lucas Video Request

john lucas

You might be right although on my V's I have a lot of cutting edge. what I think might be the difference is the angle of the cutting edge. for example the Michelson grind is totally convex. I've heard that it doesn't catch although I did get one when playing. However it might be less prone. I'll run another test while I'm playing with these gouges.

If you at how the wing cutting edge is shaped, there's U then V which has slightly more rounded outer edge, then Ellsworth which I believe is more rounded, and the Michelson which is round. I will have to lay them side by side and possibly make some wax impressions like some one did years ago to show the different shapes and grinds.

Re: John Lucas Video Request

#7

Steve Kubien

Me too

Steve Kubien

I have V-fluted bowl gouges and also find them easier to control. The one U-flute I have (1/2") seems well suited for hogging a lot of material quickly but I have difficulty controlling it when attempting finishing cuts.

Re: John Lucas Video Request

#8

Re: John Lucas Video Request

Jerry Klug

There are a lot of variations to the shape of a "V" flute. I have a Chinese manufactured gouge with a Woodcraft brand name that is almost sure to plug up in any wet wood. My Sorby and D Way gouges have more open "V" shape and work very differently. I don't own a "U" shaped gouge to compare.

Re: John Lucas Video Request

#9

Steven Antonucci

One N, 2 C's no H