Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Maker-Viewer Schizophrenia

Posts

Maker-Viewer Schizophrenia

#1

Maker-Viewer Schizophrenia

charlie belden

An undeclared war was going on and all males between the ages of 18 and 25 lived under a Sword of Damocles - THE DRAFT. The undeclared war in Viet Nam dominated the Evening News. The United States was coming apart at the seams - young vs old, blacks vs whites, blue collar workers vs "hippies" and"yippies", demonstrations, riots, Law & Order vs Anarchists, Draft Card Burnings and Police Brutality, The Red Menace and the threat of Mushroom Clouds, alcohol, nicotene - and LSD. Revolution was in the air. It was a very tumultuous period in our nation's history.

A darkened college auditorium, every seat filled and people standing in the aisles. On stage, an oriental philosophy professor, seen by most of the audience as a Bodhidharma (one who has attained Enlightenment and can leave this plain of consciousness to become One With Everything but remains to help others attain Englightenment). Oddly enough, he happened to be born and raised in central Texas - and sounded and looked very much like Lyndon Johnson, the President of the United States at the time. What he was saying definitely was NOT Lyndonesque.

The prof was lecturing on The Illusion of Realtiy, walking back and forth behind a large table centered on the stage. On the table was a large thick book. The lecturer was speaking about how we percieve the universe around us in terms of Me / Not Me, I and It/Them - and how that perception creates a barrier to Enlightenment - the realization that Everything Is Everything - and all that goes with that insiight.

The audience was struggling with that concept, concentrating intensely on trying to Get It.

As the prof spoke, his voice got quieter and quieter, his pacing slowing, his path becoming shorter and shorter, now limited to the width of the table in front of him. The audience is now totally silent, straining to hear every word, wantinig desperately to be Enlightened.

The professsor reaches down, picks up the heavy book. The whole audience leans foreward towards the stage - their attention totally focused now on the book. People held their breath. You could hear a pin drop.

The prof SLAMS the book down on the table - a thunderclap fills the auditorium! People come out of their seats, startled by this explosive sound,

The prof waits for his audience to settle down. The audience struggles to regain some semblance of composure - amazed and confused - trying to comprehend what just happened.

When the auditorium is silent again and all eyes - and ears - are focused on the prof, he says "THAT was probably your first pure EXPERIENCE - and now you've ruined it - because you tried to makes sense of what just happened, rather than just experiencing it.".

The lights go on and the prof leaves the stage.

For a brief time the audience lingers, conversations about what they'd just experienced almost deafening. Then they wander off - back to their world of College Student.

Now the reason for that story is to provide a context for these questions:

As woodturner,s can we experience a turning

- without immediately thinking of how it was done

or at least wondering how it was done?

As turners, are our perceptions of turnings schitzophrenic

- seen now as Maker - then as Viewer - oscillating between the two?

Re: Maker-Viewer Schizophrenia

#2

Re: Maker-Viewer Schizophrenia

Donna Banfield

Most of the time, Charlie, I can barely comprehend some of your posts :D, but that's because you have a background in science and engineering -- most know by now that I don't do math :D

But this post, I got.

I can view a turning and enjoy it for the pure aesthetic reasons that it was made, without the need to understand how it was done. Granted, that question may enter my mind some time later, but in some cases it never does.

For example, Michael and Cynthia Gibson's Tea Pot series, in my opinion, are extraordinary works of art in turning, carving and pyrography. I can view all their work with awe and admiration for the skill, expertise and the artwork, and never need to know how it was done. That may separate me from many of the turners that I know (and many I call my friends). Most turners I know like to tinker and make tools, and jigs, and devices that are connected somehow to their woodturning. I've never had that interest or desire; I would much rather spend the time that I have advancing my turning or carving skills, and making jigs and other devices sidetracks me from focusing on the turning and carving.

My view may also have a lot to do with my being mathematically challenged. :D

Re: Maker-Viewer Schizophrenia

#3

Re: Maker-Viewer Schizophrenia

john lucas

Charlie I enjoyed that. I think I'll try to just live in the experience. At least the next time I have some good Chili anyway. The people around me might not enjoy the experience however.

Re: Maker-Viewer Schizophrenia

#4

Steven Antonucci

Performance art

steven antonucci

I was at the Smithsonian recently walking through one of the galleries when I came across a piece that involved video. In the video, it had the appearance of being everyday life, except that you knew that it wasn't and it was completely scripted to portray reality as an illusion.

Wanting to know how and why are a part of me. I can't turn it off.

C'est la vie.

Steve

P.S. I see a performance art piece in San Jose this year... I have a highly intricate turning that I am walking into the Instant Gallery when I accidentally "trip" and the piece shatters into 1000 little pieces... I bet that would be something :)

Re: Maker-Viewer Schizophrenia

#5

Re: Maker-Viewer Schizophrenia

Dale Miner

If you are a problem solver by nature, then the answer is no.

Re: Maker-Viewer Schizophrenia

#6

Re: Maker-Viewer Schizophrenia *LINK*

charlie belden

I can do math AND draw (and paint and sculpt) - apparently an odd combination. I can solve problems - and sometimes create them, the latter more easily than the former ; )

Strangely enough, when you listen to musicians, other artists and mathematicians or physicists discuss their passion - the vocabulary gets around to being very similar - as is their enthusiam - even about that of others who have their own seeminly very different passion.

A friend can look at an equation - and visualize it graphed in 3, sometimes 4D - seeing it as sculpture, in the case of 3D, as a kinetic sculpture in 4D. With software like Mathematica, in the hands of someone who knows how to use it, everyone can do the same, more or less. And even if you don't know how to use Mathematica, you can play with interactive Mathematica models, tweek a parameter and see its effect on the image of the model - in 2 1/2 D. (the attached link will take you to interesting visual models to have fun with - and maybe get an idea or two for a future piece or two.


Find a topic and play with things you find.

Re: Maker-Viewer Schizophrenia

#7

Walt Bennett

?

Walt Bennett

I'm certain in your own mind there is a connection somewhere through your story to the ending questions, but I have to say I can't find it. Since I lived through the period you talked about, spent 20 + years in the USAF, know many who were wounded or died in 'Nam, I think I'm able to make a comment on that part. Where that all goes towards wood turning is what leaves me dumbfounded - although many other things do as well. Would you kindly expound on this?

Re: Maker-Viewer Schizophrenia

#8

Re: Maker-Viewer Schizophrenia

Jim Breeden

John - Chile is spelled with an E. :D

As to the 3D aspect of every day turning, or carpentry, I can see in 3D. For some unexplained reason, this is the way I see 2D drawings. I have never used one of them CAD thingees to draw anything - don't know how I do it - it just happens. I think I learned it from my grandfather, under his guidance of a 2 year apprenticeship with him. He was a master carpenter. "Close your eyes and visualize what you are about to do - boy"! My wife says. "Hah, that's not the reason, you're from from a different planet". 8) Sure wish my grandfather was with me today, as I still have a lot to learn, being from another planet and all.

Re: Maker-Viewer Schizophrenia

#9

Re: ?

charlie belden

Let's see if any of these works for you.

Anyone who has ever been a movie projectionist probably finds it difficult to not look for the "Start the Next Reel" marker when it flashes briefly on the screen, indicating when the next reel should be started so the audience doesn't notice the reel change. Most projectionists, or former projectionist, watch a movie in a theatre differently than the rest of the audience. Too much knowledge gets in the way of enjoying the experience of just watching a movie.

An avid amateur or professional photographer will look at a photograph and see it differently than those who aren't photographers. A jeweler will look at a piece of jewelry and see it differently than a customer.

So the question is, can an experienced turner look at a turning without seeing what should be there but isn't, or what is there that shouldn't be, rather than seeing and experiencing the whole piece in its context as it is?