I came across some box elder last week, with lots of red, and some spalt. Never turned box elder before, but I've seen some really beautiful works out and about. Put it on the lathe, started to turn, and I thought I had the dullest tools in the world! Talk about tear out! Sharpened my "dull" spindle gouge, didn't make a bit of difference. Put some shellac on it to toughen the wood fibers, or I should say, saturated it, because it kept soaking it in. Waited 2 days, just to make sure the shellac had time to dry throughly, and the same thing happened. Ok - so then I swabbed CA all over it, resharpened my gouge, same thing! What gives? My tools are sharpened and honed to an inch of their life - - - - - so? Anybody out there any ideas
I have had that happen but usually only in a few spots. Sometimes running the too in the opposite direction helps. for example turning from middle to outside in the inside of a bowl instead of the usual lip to middle.
Most often what I've done is to go to a gouge with a sharper tip angle. I use my detail gouge which has a 35 degree bevel or if it's a deep bowl I use the Hunter tool which has an even sharper angle to the cutting edge. This and slowing down my feed rate of the tool as well as turning up the rpm usually works.
I'll often apply wax along with the above and if that doesn't work thinned lacquer.
Never tried wax while turning - I'll try it. I usually turn at 1800 rpm, maybe i'll kick it up a bit to see what happens. What's it gonna do - not work? Sure hate to lose this hunk of wood, what with all the red in it.
If it is, you might want to soak it, then put it in the freezer. You could then open your doors on a cold day, and turn it all the way to finish, before letting it thaw.
After it dries, saturate it, if you feel it needs it.
I have about given up on box elder because of the situation you describe. Apparently, spalted box elder has a very narrow window of opportunity for the woodturner as it goes punky quickly. If you are lucky, you can find some solid colorful wood mixed in with the soft stuff, but this is one wood I toss quickly.
Add me to the list of people that hates box elder. It stinks when turned wet, if it's a little punky it can be a bear to turn, then all that beautiful red goes away with age. A lot prettier material out there to turn.
It's punky. Tried the 80 grit, all it did was make a flat spot. I don't think I want to freeze it, then have water thrown all over my shop. Guess it's going into the burn box. Thanks everybody - not for the burn box - for the advice.
I had a whole log of that stuff once. Hardly a speck of red in the whole log and every bit as hard to turn without tear-out as you describe. I tried saturating with CA and lacquer, cutting in different directions, re-sharpening already sharpened tools and finally resorted to the 60-grit gouge. It didn't work very well either. At least I produced a lot of mulch for someone's garden!
Box Elder is very soft/light/weak to begin with. Turning it dry is no fun, but it usually turns pretty well when green. Freezing it has worked for me, but I have 15 acres of walk-out freezer at about 6 degrees this morning, so that's pretty easy for me to do with no electricity!
When Boxelder starts spalting, it gets soft and punky very quickly (like White/Grey Birch), so yours may be too far gone.
Don't give up on Boxelder; they tend to make spectacular burls under the right conditions. The red streaks fade to orange, and then a dull tan with exposure to light, but the burl figure can be outstanding.
Now that you know what they look like, keep your eyes open for them. Around here (northern New England) they tend to grow along rivers and streams and other damp places, like the various Willow species. In winter they are easy to spot as they tend to hold onto dried seeds, so they can be spotted at a distance by all the light tan colored bits attached to the twigs.
Boxelders seem to form burls where they are stressed -- at the base of a tree leaning over a steep bank, where they are squeezed between a foundation and a fence, etc... If you are lucky enough to find some good Boxelder burl, it's a fine turning wood. If you don't like it, feel free to send it to me .
I found some with a lot of color. Rough turned somewhat green, soaked in DNA, dried, turned some, painted with 50/50 (alcohol/deft) finished, buffed. Quite a bit of CA holding it together. Should not have used the white compound in buffing. Anyway to remove it? Have some more--will try again
I have removed white diamond buffing compound from cracks & crevices on turned pieces using mineral spirits soaked into cloths (terry cloth towels work best for me) and used to rub out the debris by dissolving the wax-based abrasive carrier material; if needed, small brushes (used tooth brushes work OK) and mineral spirits can help to get it out of cracks, holes, etc., although it takes a bit of work. I had the same white diamond accumulation problem once on very open-grained walnut (it was really all over the end grain - it looked really bad), and it was such a royal PITA to try to get it out I just scrapped the entire piece. Lesson learned.
Good luck cleaning up the white diamond.
I've turned a fair amount of box elder and although it can be a "tear-out king" of domestic woods, there have been quite a few pieces coming off my lathe that have been purchased from galleries over the years. The spalting DOES remove a significant amount of fiber strength - box elder (sometimes referred to as 'ash-leaved maple') actually is a soft maple species (Acer negundo) which doesn't have that much hardness to lose, even when not infected with fungi. You can also try a penetrating, solvent-based wood stabilizing material sold for treating dry-rotted wood, such as Minwax Wood Hardener. This has worked well for me when needed. I would not give-up on box elder! It actually is one of my favorite woods to turn!
(BTW - No pic came through on your follow-up post.)
Actually I put the pics in a word document. I think they show up at the end of my 2 posts. Obviously not the way they are supposed to. I need some help from my wife on that. Hopefully it will work this time
Some of that white compound can be blown out with compressed air. Paint thinners can remove most of it also. Last resort? Sand back to bare wood and start over with sealer and finishes...don't buff until it's well sealed.