There is Vega Mini duplicator for sale on eBay for a current bid of $152 that I am considering. It this a decent price. This unit is not listed anywhere new seems that it is not made anymore. I have a Nova DVR and need to make 22 - 7/8" dia X 11" long spindles for a cradle for my soon to be here grandson. Does anyone have any experience with this duplicator? Will it do the job?
Or, does anyone in northeast Massachusetts have one they would be willing to rent to me for a couple of weeks.
Hi Ken -- I think that at a relatively short 11 winches, you can live without this. I have used the larger one, and it's a fairly decent rig, but by the time you get a template made and all set up and squared away and understand how it works, etc etc, you'd be through a run of 22 pieces. A Vega duplicator does not, in my experience, yield a finished piece all by itself -- you'd need to touch up small details and sand the whole thing. You may have to make 24 or even more freehand to end up satisfied with their uniformity but still you'd be ahead, I think.
I'd suggest making a good story stick with a fully drawn profile. For 11 inches get a long paint stirring stick from you local paint store and draw it up on that. This will give you placement along the length and you can write your diameters etc on it as well.
Good luck with the project, and be sure to post a photo when it's done!
I'm a fan of the Vega duplicator. Because of the V shaped bit it will not cut every detail depending on your design. However I simply mounted my banjo so the tool rest was on the outboard side of my lathe, turned the lathe in reverse and walked around to the backside and did the few cuts it took to square up some shoulders and that was it.
It does take time to set it up but every spindle matches exactly and I was able to start my sanding with 220 grit. Granted 22 is a small number and if you have the skill you can turn them. However if your not that skilled the duplicator will do the job and do it extremely well.
One trick to using a duplicator is to always cut down hill with the grain. High point to low point. This cuts a lot cleaner. The other tip is to use a freshly sharpened blade.
If the spindles are thin you might have problems with chatter and may need to rig up a spindle steady.
Before you rush out and buy a duplicator, you might want to check out a video posted in this forum by Steven Antonucci on January 3rd, 2012. This video is of Pete Galbert turning a spindle for a windsor chair and shows the use of a story stick and freehand turning.
My wood turning mentor (by the same name ) used to make spinning wheels. He turned wheel spokes, chair legs, and other parts using the big Vega duplicator. I watched him use the duplicator. It took him what seemed like forever to turn down a spindle to the final profile. He would turn a whole bunch of spindles for various components. Then he would take the duplicator off the lathe and put the spindles back on, tweek them with a spindle gouge and sand. It made sense for him to use a duplicator because it got him the exact profiles and uniformity. I looked into buying one way back because I was doing a bunch of stair spindles for remodelers. I didn't and I am glad. No call for it in the last couple of years.
Unless someone has come out with a better system I found Vega to be the top of the line.
I too have the duplicator, and work similar to the way John does. Well, not too similar since I mounted the duplicator on the back (turned the v cutter upside down) and let my tool rest on the front. I upgraded to the carbide v cutter and it really likes the high rpm. Crank the lathe way up and take light cuts to reduce vibration in the spindle, if it is very long. I always have mixed feelings when I use it. It does a nice job, but not as good as quality as hand turned. Call Vega, really swell guys and always willing to help!
One huge advantage with doing them by hand is it will force you to have better tool control. When you get done with the repetitive practice of doing the spindles the next bowl you do will be easier.
Thanks everyone for your input. I have decided to do them without the duplicator. Have to get started soon as I'm sure it will be a learning experience and take some time. Baby is due in April so I do have some time.
A friend of mine says, "Every major woodworking project cannot go by without buying a new tool".
If you are looking for a tool to really speed-up your turning of these spindles, you should seriously consider buying a Galbert caliper ASAP, which is an excellent tool that will undoubtedly be worth its cost given the number of diameters you will need to set. I still occasionally use standard settable calipers, but the Galbert Caliper lets you hold ONE tool and simply cruise down your spindle blank with your parting tool, check your story stick, and accurately set all of the diameters you need. You don't have to measure & set each new diameter with a standard caliper, check it, then re-adjust for the next diameter, repeat, etc. The Galbert caliper is a HUGE time saver! I don't do a lot of spindles for furniture or balusters, etc., but when I do, the Galbert is the first thing I reach for when getting set up for a 'spindle run'.
Have a look at the on-line video available at the Craft Supplies ink below which shows the Galbert caliper in action.
Considering the cost comparison between buying a new, "high tech" caliper versus the duplicator, you'll come out WAY ahead, AND will also gain the skill proficiency when the project is over from the accumulated experience. If you're like me, you will know to cut at least 5 or more extra spindle blanks...
Good luck with your project - I'm sure we'd like to see photos of the final result when you're done! Congratulations 'Grandpa'......!!
I bought about 8 outside calipers from Grizzly for $3 apiece when they had them on sale. I just label them with blue tape and stack them left to right. They never change, I don't have to remember or look up numbers and sizes I just simply grap the next one in line for the next step on the spindle. Faster and less expensive than the other caliper.