Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Carbide Tools?

Posts

Carbide Tools?

#1

Carbide Tools?

Tony - memphis

I've been reading a lot about carbide tipped tools. Then I got a new head for my planer for Christmas that useds lots of carbide inserts. That got me interested in the carbide insert turning tools. When I started looking, I was amazed at all of the offerings. Any tips on aquiring and/or using these tools would be appreciated. Let me qualify my turning interest...I am a furniture builder that mostly turns spindles (legs and such). But I do like to make pens, pepper mills, spoons, etc. I've looked at Easy Wood Tools, Carbide Woodturning Tools.com, a fella in LA, etc. Looks like they are all pretty similar. The CarbideWoodturnignTools.com site sells unhandled versions at a better price. My turning skills are not very good. I turned a pepper mill over the weekend and realized they were worse than I remembered! Anyway, thanks for the help.

Tony

Re: Carbide Tools?

#2

Re: Carbide Tools?

Lewis Dodd

Well, funny you should ask! Lyle Jamieson gives an excelant treatise on carbide cutters in "American Woodturner" in last months (Dec.) issue. Lyle and Mike Hunter are members of this forum.

Re: Carbide Tools?

#3

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Carbide Tools?

Lyle Jamieson

I will send you a copy of the article in case you are not an AAW member. If you turn much you should look into the benefits of AAW. There are huge differences in carbide tools.

Re: Carbide Tools?

#4

Re: Carbide Tools?

GaryG in MD

Tony,

By all means, read Lyle's article. It's a very good one.

In general, there are carbide scrapers and carbide cutting tools.

Many will disagree, but I say a scraper is a scraper is a scraper. I'm not a fan. Scrapers used for roughing, the way most of the commercial ones are advertised, leave tear out and rough surfaces. I see no advantage to them unless you have a thing against sharpening. (Yes, I know you can shear scrape with a few of them.) 'Nuf said about that.

The carbide CUTTING tools, such as Mike Hunter's, offer some real advantages in terms of making clean cuts in hard-to-reach areas that would otherwise be difficult to impossible with a cutting tool. I'm talking about working inside vessels, open and closed. (It's about their shape -- they just happen to be carbide.) That's where they shine (and so does the wood that's being cut cleanly).

John Lucas has posted some excellent video tutorials on YouTube showing the use of the Hunter tools. I recommend you watch those.

BTW, you should have thought about this BEFORE Christmas! ;-)

...Gary

Re: Carbide Tools?

#5

Re: Carbide Tools?

John Lucas

Scraping is an interesting thing. It has it's Place. For example have you ever tried to get a perfectly flat surface to the central portion of a platter. I'm talking about something that won't reflect waves when subjected to side light on a glossy finish. I can't do it with a gouge. Not on a large platter anyway. I can get mighty close and most people would not see the imperfections but when viewed in the right light it looks like subtle ripples in a pond. I can highlight the high spots and take them down with a shear scraper until it's perfectly flat. With a fresh burr it can be shear scraped to leave a finish good enough for 220 grit. Now notice I said fresh burr. You don't have that on carbide scrapers. They do cut pretty well but not as clean as a fresh burr on a HSS tool. The burr does not last long. I think someone once said about 15 seconds. I never timed it but that's isn't far off.

I used to hang out with a machinist who often made wooden molds for casting. He would sneak up a perfect fit using a scraper. These were MDF moulds that had to be within a few thousands of dead on. He was not a skilled turner and couldn't do it with a gouge but I'm not sure I could either, not that accurate.

On the other hand it's quite difficult to cut a long straight taper with a scraper. I can do it with a skew.

The point is, there is a place for scrapers. Scrapers can be very accurate if used correctly. They also require very little if any learning curve to use at the start.

Now that being said I'm I prefer cutting. I can get a cleaner surface and smoother arc faster than I can with a scraper. I'm a firm believer in whatever tool it takes to get there is fine, it's the final product that counts. However there's also that feeling that the process is part of the final product. I don't know how to put it in words but I think your more proud of a piece when you are able to cut every shape cleanly with a gouge or skew. Maybe that's just BS but I think you'll agree with me when your able to do it.

Re: Carbide Tools?

#6

Don Leydens

Re: Carbide Tools?

Don Leydens

Yea, Tony, check out Mike Hunter's site: http://www.hunterwoodturningtool.com/

or his Youtube videos: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nfp2kvhH6Mo

I really love using his tools.

Re: Carbide Tools?

#7

agreed...

GaryG in MD

John,

Yeah, I should have clarified my comment a bit more. I tried but failed.

I do shear scraping all the time and agree that it definitely has its place in our bag of tricks. That burr, when properly angled can remove just the finest fuzz. I agree that it's also important for removing those fine but frustrating wrinkles or waves left by us mortals when using a gouge. Even Stu Batty uses them! It beats going in with heavy grit sandpaper -- in open grained woods that just sands out the early wood preferentially and makes even worse waves. I hate that!

What I was referring to is the current rage of buying an expensive carbide scraper and just jamming it straight into the spinning wood. You don't need carbide to do that; any scraper will give the same crappy results. As far as the only advantage of carbide is concerned, I consider sharpening to be one of the most important aspects of turning. I have nothing against taking a short break and going to the grinder. In fact, I kind of like getting away from the lathe for a few moments. It clears the head and gives me a chance to get a drink of water. Your point about no burr on carbide is also a very important one.

For me, the Hunter tools give me access and results because of their shapes and angles of attack. (A hook tool will do a lot of the same things. I've got two that I'm looking forward to learning to use.) The fact that they don't have to be (can't be) sharpened is just an added blessing.

...Gary

Re: Carbide Tools?

#8

Re: agreed...

Don Thur

One could also check out carbide cutting tools at www.knotsburls.com/kiliantools as an alternative.

Re: Carbide Tools?

#9

link error...

GaryG in MD

Don, Thanks for the link, but that one has an error in it.

To get there you need a dash between "Kilian" and "tools".

I took a quick look, and those are the scrapers I don't care for.

Note that they have a flat top. That makes them no different from any ordinary scraper -- round nose or straight nose.

The Hunter carbide inserts are cup shaped and have a very sharp edge angled back nearly perpendicular to the face of the tool. That's what makes them effective cutting tools, not scrapers. They're more like a hook tool in the way they cut. ...Gary