Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Windsor stool

Posts

Windsor stool

#1

Windsor stool

GolfSteve in Calgary

Following up on my question before Christmas about "is there a comfortable chair to play a guitar on", I built this three legged stool. It was also practice before starting on a set of Windsor chairs, as I am not a very good turner.

The design is based on the Dunbar shop stool article in Popular Woodworking (#178 Oct 2009), but I converted the stool from a four legged stool to a three legged stool.


The seat is poplar (14" diameter). The beads on the OD of the seat were the most frightening turning task for me. The legs were sawn from kiln dried 3-1/2" square quartersawn maple baseball bat blanks, and are about 1-3/8" max. diameter. The legs tenons are tapered and wedged into the seat mortises.

The finish is milk paint - the legs are red over black over red. The seat is blue over yellow over red over black. There are three/four coats of colour because I decided I didn't like the original two colour red/black scheme. Two coats of polymerized tung oil are applied over the milk paint.

There are two things that I liked about this project:-

1. Windsor chairmaking is liberating in that you can screw almost everything up and still get a good looking project. Every leg is a different size and all the holes are drilled at the wrong angle, but it all came together. The important part is getting tight fitting joinery.

2. Milk paint is liberating because you can paint it like your 14 year old son would if you forced him to paint the chair during the summer holiday "because you're part of this family", when all he wants to do is play Nintendo and sleep, and it looks perfect.

On the downsides:

1. Next time I'll turn the tenons oversize, then let the parts dry for a few days before turning the tenons to final dimension.

2. A three legged stool can be unstable if loaded along the periphery of the seat near the mid-point of a stretcher. I have a two year old daughter who loves to climb and I think she could tip this stool over easily when climbing onto it. Perhaps I should have given the legs more splay.

3. When reaming a tapered mortise freehand, it is hard to get the angle exactly the same as the pilot hole.

4. Reaming a round hole is difficult. A slightly dull reamer seemed to make the job a bit easier.



Re: Windsor stool

#2

Re: Windsor stool

Randy Gleckler

Good Lessons learned, and great Project there Steve. You did a good job on it. Now let's see you playing... on it :-D

Re: Windsor stool

#3

Steven Antonucci

Good looking stool


Re: Windsor stool

#4

Dale Jablonski

Re: Good looking stool

dale jablonski

nice job!

Re: Windsor stool

#5

Re: Windsor stool

John Lucas

I like making stools. Your is very nice looking. The extra effort on the paint is worth it. It' looks great. I taught a glass at the craft center once and made everyone use a brace and bit to drill the seat holes. Man you never heard so much complaining.

I'm not sure 4 legs is better than 3. On this style stool it's the heavy top that makes them tippy as well as the legs. What seems to work is to make the stance wider (which doesn't look as good), make the legs out of heavier material and thicker, or make the top out of light material and maybe thinner. 4 legs do help but will rock if not on a flat surface. My 3 legged stools will sit anywhere and still be stable. They just tip over easily.

I learned to correct the angle of the legs as you ream them to a taper. Do a test fit, check the leg, and then ream more forcefully on the side it needs to lean to. This has worked well for me. I do use homemade reamers taken after the John Alexander style of reamer. They work great.

Re: Windsor stool

#6

Hot sand?

A. Kapocius

Ever thot about using hot sand to dry tenons? Kinda remember seeing that tried by Uncle Roy Underhill quite a while back.

Al Kapocius

Re: Windsor stool

#7

Re: Hot sand?

John Lucas

When I took the class from Curtiss Buchannan we wrapped the legs in aluminum foil but left the tenons bare. All the legs were put in a heated cabinet to stay for a few days while we worked on other parts of the chairs. That accomplished the same thing as the sand drying. I still use the sand because I make these so seldom I don't have room for a drying cabinet.

Re: Windsor stool

#8

Re: Hot sand?

GolfSteve in Calgary

I was using kiln dried maple that had sat in my workshop for two years, so I didn't think the tenons would shrink. They didn't shrink much, but enough that the joints were loose. This didn't make any difference to the tapered tenons into the seat, but the tenons on the rungs were loose.

Several years ago I built the Shaken bench shown in the background in the photos of the stool. The legs were originally turned from green elm. They shrunk so much (around 1/8" at the tenon), that I had to discard the legs, and turned new legs from kiln dried oak. I don't recall those shrinking at all.

Re: Windsor stool

#9

Re: Hot sand?

John Lucas

If I remember correctly we super dried the tenons as well but kept the legs covered so they were wet. The chair I made that week is 12 years old now and it's solid as a rock. The only thing that has happened is the tapered tenons for the sink apparently dried further and stuck through the chair about 1/16" or so.