Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

another dangerous video on YouTube

Posts

another dangerous video on YouTube

#1

another dangerous video on YouTube

GaryG in MD

These things make me so appreciative of people like John Lucas!

I get an "Alert" from Google when new "woodturning" things appear.

Got this one today.

The video begins with promise. It has good audio and a two-camera video system. Very professional! The guy starts with a small, roughly-chainsawed, side-grain "bowl" blank. He puts it on the lathe with a screw chuck. So far, so good.

Then he puts the tool rest along the side of it, parallel with the ways, and attacks those square edges side-on with a spindle roughing gouge. I was in shock. They've tried to change the name of that tool away from "roughing gouge", but people still just don't get it.

He put it in a chuck without turning the bottom first, so he had to turn the bottom right up against the chuck jaws, necessarily leaving a lot of material there.

Then he sanded the inside, and what he could of the outside, with a cheap, thin, plastic glove on his hand. An accident looking for a place to happen. I was holding my breath, but I should have saved that for the last step.

He ended the video by reversing it and ripping it out of the chuck two or three times on a simple, "gentle" finishing cut meant to clean up the foot area. It seems to me that we live in a world of cause and effect -- if you do it once, stop and figure out what happened and don't repeat it! Not so here... again and again... same tool, same angle, same result. Surprise!

I have only one question. "WHY?" ...Gary

Re: another dangerous video on YouTube

#2

Lyle Jamieson

Re: another dangerous video on YouTube

Lyle Jamieson

I share your frustration, Gary. There is so much faulty and sometimes dangerous information being "taught" out there. The beginner has no way to filter out the conflicting techniques.

Re: another dangerous video on YouTube

#3

Steven Antonucci

The YouTube Phenomenon

steven antonucci

I think YouTube represents a very unique opportunity to learn, for both the presenter and the viewer. I cannot overemphasize that ALL YouTube videos should be treated as an episode of "World's Dumbest" by everyone.

There is a huge disconnect between seeing and doing. Just because someone can record their actions and upload a video doesn't make them an expert. They may be an expert, but the viewer may not be able to do what they do? There is also the possibility that what they are doing is dangerous or stupid.

I saw the video that you mention and I think that people need to mentally categorize videos into at least two buckets: instruction and demonstration. In a demo, I show you how I do something. I am not trying to teach you how to do it. In an instructional video, I am attempting to convey knowledge for the purpose of the viewer understanding it.

There are videos of people jumping off of cliffs, driving 200 mph, fighting wild animals. I don't think any of these would be considered instructional. I think we need to categorize this type of video as demonstrative and just agree that the guy was a beginning turner who should probably spend more time at the lathe and less time making videos.

Who knows? Perhaps someone that knows him sees the video and offers help to make him a better turner?

Steve

Re: another dangerous video on YouTube

#4

Re:Dangerous video on YouTube

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Gary,

Can you place a LINK here on the thread so us novice turners can see what NOT to do? Having something bad happen and figuring out why is a great point.

Ray

Re: another dangerous video on YouTube

#5

Gary-2 words, "ego" and "ignorance!"


Re: another dangerous video on YouTube

#6

Steve, help me become a better turner. :-)

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

Seriously! I wish I was closer to you so that I could learn more.

Ray

Re: another dangerous video on YouTube

#7

Steven Antonucci

A short, pretty ride north some Saturday?


Re: another dangerous video on YouTube

#8

Ray, my notes for a beginning woodturner...

GaryG in MD

Ray,

I appreciate your comment and understand your rationale. I chose not to post the link because 1) I don't want to publicize it, and 2) my intent is not to embarrass the gentleman who is well-intended but badly misinformed.

Why a rank beginner would chose to post a video at all is beyond me. I think Jamie's "ego" comment is probably close to the mark. If the person put as much time, energy, and money into learning to turn as he has in setting up a professional video system, he would be much better off.

My goals with my post were 1) to remind everyone that you shouldn't necessarily believe what you see, no matter how "slick" and professional appearing it may be, and 2) to emphasize, once again, for everyone reading, that the name of the heavy gouge with the wide flute and small tang is SPINDLE ROUGHING GOUGE. Emphasis on the "spindle". In most catalogs now, there is a bold disclaimer that the tools are not meant for roughing side-grain work, i.e., bowls. There is a actually a video by someone else (to be unnamed) that shows him demonstrating why a SRG should not be used on end grain -- and it ends up unintentionally bloody. QED!

Ray, for you personally, as a beginning turner, I recommend the following:

1) Find and join a Club from the AAW Directory, even if you have to drive an hour. In several of mine, people come from as much as a 4 state area. Take it from me: it's worth the time and energy. 2) Ask questions here on WC. People will give you very good answers. I know; I've done it many times myself. 3) Rent or buy beginning level DVDs by the acknowledged masters. There are many fine ones out there. If you want a list, just ask the question here on WC. 4) Buy a book written by an acknowledged master. Again, there are plenty of good ones out there, and without wanting to slight anyone, I would recommend that you begin with David Ellsworth's. Read it cover to cover at least twice. You'll understand it better the second time through. 5) Read the AAW Safety rules many times and integrate them into your being. There is no reason to learn the hard way -- in this hobby, that can be dangerous. 6) Find a Mentor. One hour with an experienced turner is worth more than almost anything. 7) Your first purchase should be a good sharpening system; learn to use it properly, and use it often; a dull tool is a dangerous tool. Eight8) Start with one tool and practice, practice, practice on waste wood. Just make shavings on a variety of basic cuts that you wish to master. Proper woodturning is not scary; it is not a white knuckle exercise; force is not involved. Technique is everything. Master the tool and move on to another one. There are probably more items to list, but that should get you off to a good start! ...Gary

Re: another dangerous video on YouTube

#9

Re: Ray, my notes for a beginning woodturner...

John Lucas

Excellent response Gary. I agree with everything said.

Re: another dangerous video on YouTube

#10

Thanks Gary

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

I realized your intent and agree with all that you have said but you've peaked my curiosity. (not fair) :D

Send the LINK in a private email. I'm a quick study and would like to see for myself what your talking about.

Thanks Ray

Re: another dangerous video on YouTube

#11

Re: A short, pretty ride north... Someday soon!


Re: another dangerous video on YouTube

#12

Re: Thanks Gary

matt overton

Ray,

if you aren't already a member. Bucks Woodturners meets just 25 minutes from you on the third Monday of every month. This is a group of some of the most talented turners you can find. We have hands on workshops (HOW) and demonstrations by world class demonstrators. If you have any questions, feel free to e-mail me or call 215-778-3091. We are all on this journey together!

Re: another dangerous video on YouTube

#13

Keith Tompkins

Re: another dangerous video on YouTube

Keith Tompkins

HI Gary, You sat through my 'winged bowl" demo.....I've thought about people attempting to turn one of those after seeing my demo...It could be a very dangerous situation, especially if skills are lacking. I do let people know the dangers of turning something like my winged bowl, and the safety precautions one must take. One problem is nobody wants to me turn just another bowl, they want to see "signature" work. I guess I shouldn't put one on youtube. :(

Re: another dangerous video on YouTube

#14

Keith, there's something to what you say...

GaryG in MD

I didn't mention previously that this guy claims to have taken a class from Mike Mahoney. No way are we going to blame Mike for this kind of lack of understanding and misuse. But your point is valid. ...Gary

Re: another dangerous video on YouTube

#15

OK, Ray; will do

GaryG in MD

FYEO ...Gary

Re: another dangerous video on YouTube

#16

Re: Thanks Matt !!!!

Ray Carson - Lawrenceville, NJ

I appreciate the info.

Ray

Re: another dangerous video on YouTube

#17

Re: Ray, my notes for a beginning woodturner...

Bill White

Watching some of the stuff on the "tube" brings to mind the old addage: "Ignorance can be corrected. Stupid is forever."

Bill