Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Question on spray finishes - lacquer, acrylic, etc

Posts

Question on spray finishes - lacquer, acrylic, etc

#1

Question on spray finishes - lacquer, acrylic, etc

Donna Banfield

I have a question regarding the use of the following three finishes (sprayed): Lacquer, spray acrylic, Krylon Fixative (trade name). [This question has been cross-posted on two other turning forums I visit]

I am an oil finishes user for all my woodturnings, but some of my work that is highly carved or detailed, oil finishes are not possible - impossible to get the excess out of the tiny crevasses. I have used spray lacquer and spray acrylic, several coats. I recall that some of you have used Krylon Fixative (Andi Wolfe, for one) on some of the carved and painted pieces, and am wondering about the reasons.

One reason for lacquer is that the successive coats 'blend or melt into the previous coats. That would be a plus if I were doing hollow forms like Joe Landon or Andy DiPietro, where that deep luster enhances the appearance. But the type of carving/texturing on my work would not benefit from that luster or Chatoyance. The cons for using lacquer are also numerous - finicky to apply depending on temperature and relative humidity; need of a well-ventilated area in which to spray the finish, and in the winter, where I'm heating my studio in New Hampshire with a pellet stove, open flames are a very bad idea around lacquer.

So that brings me to spray acrylics in the rattle can. They don't see to be as sensitive to heat and humidity, and don't have the same problem with respect to fumes (correct me if I am wrong here, please). They cost more, but the trade off might be worth it? I'm also concerned about the 'flexibility' of acrylics compared to lacquer. Will I see the acrylic finish krackle over time as the wood expands/contracts as it reacts to the changes in weather, temperature and seasons? Is lacquer more flexible a finish allowing for these unavoidable issues?

Any insight that anyone with experience has on these issues would be greatly appreciated.

Re: Question on spray finishes - lacquer, acrylic, etc

#2

Re: Question on spray finishes - lacquer, acrylic,

mjonesrdg

Use a fixative if you want to prevent bleed of one color onto another....otherwise, lets go to a discussion RE: Acrylic vs. Lacquer.

Read the label...particularly the part about clean-up. I suspect that the vehicle use in the rattle can of one is the same as the rattle can of the other. (one or more of the hot thinners) Accordingly, your concerns for spraying lacquer should be the same for spraying the acrylic.

Your studio heated with pellet stove should keep a friendly atmosphere for either or both products. Your occasional spray session should not present much problem with ventilation if you can work near an open door, and/or place a little fan to provide spot exhaust to outdoors.

This leaves the decision to preference of the finishes appearance. Spray a little of each on some scrap of the same kind of wood with the same surface treatment and simply see which you like the best.

Some turners will say that the acrylics dry with a "plastic" look that is undesireable.

Hope this helps....

Mike.....in Redding Ca.

Re: Question on spray finishes - lacquer, acrylic, etc

#3

Re: Question on spray finishes - lacquer, acrylic,

Carole Valentine

I may be wrong, but I believe acrylics are more flexible than traditional lacquers and they don't yellow with age. But they also don't "pop" the grain like lacquer or oil. I use some acrylics (Krylon fixative or the Krylon Crystal Clear Matte) when I want a protective matte finish that does not impart any color to a very light wood, or on my black gesso pieces. Acrylics are water based so there is always the possibility of raising the grain if the wood is not properly prepared. Then there is a water-based "lacquer" which I'm not sure is lacquer at all. Another option is the polys - bolth solvent and water based. I sometimes use Velvit Products Aqua-shield on white woods such as holly or box elder. It's a crosslinking polymer that dries clear and hard and is water based. On many of my lighter pieces (ambrosia maple for instance) I use a first sealer coat of thinned lacquer wiped dry immediately, cured for a couple of days, sanded back, then followed up with Waterlox. On dark pieces (cherry, walnut etc.) I just use the Waterlox alone and yes, it is hard to get the excess out of carved details! Plush terry cloth helps. ;) Just my two cents...and that's probably all it's worth!

Re: Question on spray finishes - lacquer, acrylic, etc

#4

Re: Question on spray finishes - lacquer, acrylic,

Donna Banfield

Thanks, Mike. A fixative for keeping color transfer and separation of different colors makes sense -- guess that explains the name (Duh) :-)

Just like I discovered with oil finishes, there's a learning curve with these spray finishes, as well.

Re: Question on spray finishes - lacquer, acrylic, etc

#5

Re: Question on spray finishes - lacquer, acrylic,

Donna Banfield

Thanks for your reply and at 1:55 in the morning??? You should be sleeping! :-)

Like you, I've used acrylic matte finish on my black Gesso pieces, which is what got me thinking about whether the acrylic I was spraying was flexible enough and would be durable over the long run. Great if it is -- one less thing to worry about in this process!

Re: Question on spray finishes - lacquer, acrylic, etc

#6

Re: Question on spray finishes - lacquer, acrylic,

john lucas

Well actually what Krylon fixatif was designed for is to spray on Pastel chalk drawing to protect them from smearing. It doesn't change their colors at all and keeps them from smearing. It also makes an excellent finish for wood if you don't want it to appear as though it has a finish. Look at John Jordan's pieces. I don't know if he still uses it but he's the one who got me interested in it.

Re: Question on spray finishes - lacquer, acrylic, etc

#7

Re: Question on spray finishes - lacquer, acrylic,

Carole Valentine

Yep, I should have been sleeping. Had to walk over to the other house to be sure the house washing guy had not left a hose attached to the outdoor spigot. The walk in that icy cold and wind woke me up good! LOL

Re: Question on spray finishes - lacquer, acrylic, etc

#8

Detail

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Carole,

Easy(er) way to clear excess (wet) oil finish out of details is to hold your rag near the surface and use a air blow gun to push the excess out of the crevices where you can blot it up with your cloth.