Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Arbortec vs Lancelot

Posts

Arbortec vs Lancelot

#1

Arbortec vs Lancelot

John Lucas

I finally had time to play with those two 4" cutters. I cannot tell the difference in safety or it's ability to run, one vs the other. I jammed it into a dry red oak log and cut in all directions. I did use 2 hands of course.

The Lancelot leaves a cut that looks like tool marks from a gouge when you scrape with it. The Arbortec doesn't which I guess is because of the larger teeth. The Lancelot has 24 chain saw teeth the Arbortec had 3 round carbide teeth.

The way these are dangerous is doing a plunge cut and feeding it in the direction of spin. Then it will try to run. I didn't have any trouble stopping it by backing off the pressure as soon as it tries. If you were cutting into a cove area and going in the direction of the spin of the blade it could be really dangerous. I tried this by forcing it in a slot that I cut and it tried to run. I could stop it short of it getting away from me by pulling back slightly and starting the cut with a smaller bite. My friend Brad Sells who carves all day long says air grinders with high torque are really dangerous with these cutters.

A scraping cut is going perpendicular to the blade shape. These are quite safe as long as you have both hands on the grinder. Take small cuts. It goes easier, is much more controllable and much safer.

Both of these cutters were used and probably not factory sharp. That could be a factor but both cut really well so they weren't that dull.

My advice. If your on a budget the Lancelot works well. I've used mine quite a while and haven't sharpened it yet. One trick I use. It comes with 2 plates that hold the chainsaw cutter. They are hard to get together and to get the chain on them. I put them together with a few drops of medium CA and haven't had to put the assembly back together again. I don't think it will be a problem getting them apart if I need to replace the chain.

The Arbortec is much more expensive but I believe is a better tool and of course has carbide teeth that are easily replaceable. It is a one piece unit and probably balanced better because of this. You do have to be careful how you store it since it's easy to chip the carbide cutter.

Use the proper protective gear and for gods sake use both hands. Clamp or anchor the wood some way to keep it from pulling into the cutters.

Re: Arbortec vs Lancelot

#2

Re: Arbortec vs Lancelot

Jim Breeden

8) I have the Lancelot, and work it exactly as you describe - carefully with both hands ! Got to try the CA trick - thanks :b

Re: Arbortec vs Lancelot

#3

Steven Antonucci

I have the Lancelot, just got the Kutzall

steven antonucci

Million little carbide dots on a 4" disk. Turned it on once. It is a wood eraser. The Lancelot throws wood really hard (like being too close to the output side of a chainsaw) The Kutzall disk throw a coarse saw dust.

I have ideas. I just need time to actually do them.

Steve

p.s. Agree that the Lancelot isn't dangerous if used properly, but it behaves exactly like a chainsaw without anti kickback pawls and no chain brake...

Re: Arbortec vs Lancelot

#4

Re: I have the Lancelot, just got the Kutzall

John Lucas

I agree Steve. You need arm protection because the Lancelot throws sharp shavings right at your right arm. I didn't notice the Arbortec doing that. I love the Kutzall cutters with one exception. You definitely need dust collection near the source.

Re: Arbortec vs Lancelot

#5

One other thing to remember,

Keith Newton

My brother Wood, bought and was using one of the first Arbortecs back in the day when they were teeth ground into the edge of the disk, rather than a chain.

He had been holding on tightly with both hands, working on a sculpture piece in front of him, when he turned off the switch, then turned to get up, or something, while the tool was spinning down. It snagged the work by accident, spun out of his hand, landed just above the knee. He spent hours in surgery getting stitched back together. It looked like a shark had bitten his leg.

I told him that if I had a scar that looked like that, I would have to make up a better story than that. Ha, Nowadays, he could probably set up a shop next to a tattoo parlor and start offering a scaring service. Here in LR, I know a perfect spot between one of those shops to get inked, and NEMS the ambulance service, which would be handy to have close by too. he he

Re: Arbortec vs Lancelot

#6

Re: One other thing to remember,

John Lucas

You are right. They both spin for a long time after turning them off. I keep a scrap of wood handy and after I turn off the grinder I stick the cutter into that wood. It stops the cutter instantly. thanks for reminding me of this. I forgot to mention it.