Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Concepts

Posts

Concepts

#1

Keith Tompkins

Concepts

Keith Tompkins

I recently finished reading the latest issue of the AAW mag. ...IMO, an excellent issue, with some great articles. One thing I particularly enjoyed was the multi-axis article by Barbara Dill. She obviously understood her topic, and explained it in a very easy-to-understand way. A key part of why I felt it was a successful article was that she didn't show how to make a project using multiple axis points; rather, she outlines the concepts she employs, and leaves it up to the reader to explore, and develop their own style of work. I find articles (or classes) that explain how to make a project, such as a box, with measured drawings, very boring. I usually skip over those, looking for something that really piques my interest. I liked Barbara's approach, and have read her article several times over. What do you think? Would you rather read about concepts, and how to apply them to your work, or would you rather read "how to" type articles? Which type of class interests you most? I thought it would be a good topic for discussion. Also, great article, Lyle.. I've read through that one a few times, too!

Re: Concepts

#2

Re: Concepts

John Jordan

Barbara gave a really nice demo for our class at Appalachian Center for Craft last summer. What makes her presentations good is the amount of work she has done ( a LOT), and her willingness to do it for its own sake-practice some might call it. :) Many are not willing to do those things, particularly in a considered and thoughtful way.

Her approach is what I really find interesting. I also enjoy hearing about why people do what they do more than the technical details.

John

Re: Concepts

#3

Jesper, Denmark

Re: It's like food recipes.......

Jesper, Denmark

Some people need to slavishly follow the recipe and other s see it as a general suggestion, which they can modify i accordance to their desires.

I do not get the magazine, but suspect it needs to cater to a wide audience. Some need to have something measured thay can follow religiously and others are more interested in conceppts and principles.

Personally, I have never followed a recipe slavishly - whether for a cake or building the Norm Router table.

Re: Concepts

#4

Re: Concepts

John Lucas

Keith I'm with you on this one. I like the AAW magazine because it talks about all sorts of thing related to woodturning and lets my mind wander to discover new things. I read the project articles simply to pick up a technique or some other tip that my help me with the concept ideas.

Obviously most people prefer project based articles since that's almost all the other magazines (not just woodturning) cater to.

Even from the beginning I rarely copy a project exactly like it is in the articles. I almost always change something to make it my own. I can really only remember two things I made exactly as described. My first 25 hand mirrors were from Woodsmith magazine and I made 5 roll top breadboxes from the same magazine. Everything else I can remember building had some modification or alteration that made it different than the article.

Re: Concepts

#5

Steven Antonucci

"Projects" are pretty boring reads.

steven antonucci

Didn't see the article, but I think that most project "how-to's" are things that I would avoid with one exception. If a project requires some unique jig or method to hold it, I will read that article. If it's just a straightforward bunch of turning, I usually pass.

Concepts that expand my knowledge are far more interesting, even if I have no interest in doing that type of work. I enjoy understanding almost as much as doing. Someday, I may marry some of the things I understand with some of the things that I do.

Steve

Re: Concepts

#6

Re: Concepts

matt overton

I like the concept approach, especially when it is done as thoroughly as Barbara does in this article. My skills are not as refined as I would like, so the project articles still appeal to me. I am finding, however that I am not mystified by any of the how to projects. I am capable of executing most all of them. I just need to find the "practice" time. This is why articles like Barbara's and Cindy Drozda's chat on finials are resonating with me.

Re: Concepts

#7

Re: Concepts

Bill Neddow

I much prefer articles like Barbara's. Like you, Keith, I have read it several times.

I only skim through practical "how to" articles looking to see if there is maybe one "concept" I can pick up. Barbara has provided us with an entire banquet in one article.

Of course, there is a place for "how to" articles. They are very useful for beginners.

I think there are far too many "how to" articles in most magazines. Part of this is because beginners tend to write the editor complaining if there are "concept" articles. There was a campaign a couple of years ago by beginners to kick all the "concept" material, out of the AAW Journal, along with all the photos and bits of information on what the best wood artists are doing. It was all too "highbrow" for many. I guess many of these beginners don't want to be inspired by seeing what can really be done by the best woodturner.

Happily, the editor did not cave in because the AAW has a wide audience -- not just beginners. It is harder for other editors to resist because they are more dependent on newsstand sales and thus have more beginners in their audience.

Also, part of the problem is that there are more projects out there to write articles on than there are concepts.

Re: Concepts

#8

Re: Concepts

R Henrickson

I suppose I prefer 'concept' over 'how-to' articles, but it depends very much on the quality of the article -- both the text and illustrations. Dill's article is exemplary -- concise text and clearly (and profusely) illustrated with informative photos and drawings. (It also helps that I am interested in the topic!). A poorly conceived or executed concept article (bad text and/or illustrations) can be truly useless -- if the concept is not communicated, there is nothing whatever to use. Conversely, a well-done 'how-to' ought to be clear about the underlying concepts/process, and thus do more than just present an object to reproduce -- you should be able to get something from the underpinnings, whether technical or stylistic.

Re: Concepts

#9

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Concepts

Lyle Jamieson

You nailed it John, Its all about the "WHY". If you teach and understand why we do somethinmg it is a much deeper understanding then just the how or what. I separate it by using, process -vs- project teaching. You might agree or disagree with a method, but the why will allow you to filter out all the conflicting information thrown at us.

The beginner looks for projects but they need to learn how to use the tools, handle the wood, sharpen, yadda, yadda, yadda, in order to do the simplest project. There are a lot of pieces to the turning learning curve.

Re: Concepts

#10

Re: Concepts

bill Crommett

Maybe I better re-up for the AAW !

Re: Concepts

#11

Re: Concepts

Skip Beardsley

Here is a voice from the other side.

Even in my flat work days I never even looked at chair making articles. Just never wanted to go there.

Because of a recent addition to our home, two rocking chairs for in front of the wood stove now seems like a good idea. I would never have thought of trying such a project until a friend gave me an article with a shaker rocker in it. We like that style of furniture and liked the idea that there is lots of turning involved. While I am not scared of the skew, it is not a tool I use much at all. If the article had just been about the concept of how a rocking chair functions I would not have the had the courage to make the leap. With drawings of the project and good explanation of the jigs needed, I started the first turning last night.

So, at least for me, there is room for both concept and how to articles in the turning universe.

Skip

Re: Concepts

#12

Betty Scarpino

Re: Concepts

Betty Scarpino

Keith, thank you for your comments and the excellent question. I'll share a bit of my editing philosophy as it pertains to American Woodturner.

Concept (technique) articles offer readers the tools to explore on their own and come up with creative new applications of those techniques.

Project articles are actually also a vehicle for offering techniques. Within most project articles (at least in AW), there are techniques and concepts, indirectly given. Project articles are important for beginners so that they can learn new techniques by getting excited, "I made this!!"

The "why" articles (profiles and exhibit reviews) make me dream and wonder, "what if this or that?" They provide role models, inspiration, excitement, and connection. Our field is small enough that many of us will most likely have the opportunity to meet some of the "big names" in the field ... heck, John Jordan hangs around on WoodCentral! (Be sure to look for a profile article about John in the June issue of AW!) Role models are important in all aspects of our lives.

The Bylaws of the AAW are fairly specific about the concept for its Journal and I do my best to follow those guidelines and provide something for every level of interest in woodturning.

The Journal shall be a chronicle of issues and events related to the traditional and contemporary art and craft of woodturning. The Journal shall include commentary, reviews of techniques and designs, advertising, and a broad range of articles associated with woodturning techniques and design.

Lots of great reading ahead for 2012, thanks to the many woodturners such as Keith, Bill, Lyle, John L. and John J. who generously share their knowledge! (Yes they get paid, but writing articles is a lot of work, beyond what authors are paid.)

Re: Concepts

#13

Re: Concepts

dick gerard

Amen to what Betty said! It is a hell of a lot of very hard work ... but ... the effort is well worth it as i think the quality of the Journal has never been better. And I'm not saying that because Betty is a friend. She knows that I will call her on it if I see anything not up to the highest standards.

Re: Concepts

#14

Re: Concepts *LINK*

David Walser

Personally, I like both types of articles. If I had to choose, I think I'd go with the project articles over the concept articles, but I'd be terribly disappointed to have to go without either. The quality of the writing is more important than the type of article, which might explain my generic preference for how-to articles -- concept articles are far more difficult to write well.

I think a turner's preference for one type of article over another has to do with both the individual's experience level and with his or her learning style. For example, once a turner has learned to turn a box with a slip-fit lid, an article on how to turn a slip-fit box of a different shape may add little to the turner's knowledge. Instead, the turner might be more interested in the design concepts that make one box more successful than another.

On the other hand, some of us learn "concepts" better when they are taught in the context of a project. Barbara Dill's multi-axis article is an enjoyable read and I learned a lot from it. I'm sure the knowledge will make me a better turner. Still, I also learned a lot from viewing Bob Hamilton's short youtube video on multi-axis turning (linked below). In it, he shows how to use multi-axis turning to make a three-sided screwdriver handle (which keeps the screwdriver from rolling off your workbench and makes it easier for your hand to exert torque on the screwdriver). As I watched the video, I immediately started thinking about how I could use this technique in other contexts -- pepper mills, finials, multi-sided boxes, etc. That's just how my mind works: I go from the specific (project) to the general (concept). Unless I understand how the concept is useful in a specific case (screwdriver handle), I might not understand it well enough to be able to apply it to other situations.

I like Betty Scarpino's approach in editing the AAW Journal. With so many new turners joining us each year, there will always be a thirst for basic how-to-skill-building project articles. There will also always be room for well-written concept articles. Please, Betty, don't make us choose between the two!

One last comment on Barbara Dill's article: It is an instant classic. It is so well written, however, I don't believe it's fair to use it in an argument as to why you prefer concept articles over how-to articles. That's a bit like comparing Shakespeare's Hamlet with a three-act comedy written by David Walser and then proclaiming you like tragedies more than comedies. Dill's writing was exceptional. The typical how-to article pales in comparison. So, too, does the typical concept article. The proper comparison is the typical how-to article against the typical concept article.


Multi-axis turning video

Re: Concepts

#15

I learned long ago that teaching ......

JamieDonaldson

...is most beneficial when the object is to relay "process" rather than just "product." It's like the old saw about "teach a man to fish,................" Knowing how or why something works affords much better understanding of what to do when it isn't working, rather than just looking for a broken part to fix. That's why Philosophy is a basis for all understanding, right Dick!! :D

Re: Concepts

#16

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Concepts

Lyle Jamieson

I agree the Journal has improved but so has the AAW. There are many more advantages to be an AAW member. It has changed, take a look at the web site and journal again if you have been away for a while. I think you will see more benefits and resources.

Re: Concepts

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Concepts

Keith Tompkins

Hi David, I think the reason the article was successful is because Barbara is asking us to THINK, and take something new and unfamiliar and actually use it without being told HOW to use it. The article challenges us to draw from within...something many articles, books, and even classes don't even attempt to do. Eventually, many turners want to develop their own style, or "signature" work, articles such as this one is certainly a step in the right direction...imagine how much time it would take to come up with the configurations shown in the article by the "trial and error" method...probably years. Using a few ideas from the article, a competent turner could create some pretty cool stuff right off. On the other hand, I've seen articles and demos on how to turn a three-sided box. The result is hundreds of three-sided boxes, all pretty much the same. Nice article, good results, but very little innovation or experimentation...or growth. After reading Barbara's article I felt like a kid admiring a new Ferrari....and the owner had just thrown me the keys "Hey kid....go ahead, take her out for a spin".

Re: Concepts

#19

I want a Bugatti Veyron 


Re: Concepts

#20

No you don't John- have you checked ....

JamieDonaldson

... their fuel consumption? :b And there no good place for hauling wood! ;)

Re: Concepts

#21

Keith Tompkins

Re: Keith, can I go with you????

Keith Tompkins

Donna, Have you ever seen me drive!!??!! :D

Re: Concepts

#22

Re: No you don't John- have you checked ....

John Lucas

If you can afford a million dollar car you can buy the gas. And of course you could probably pay someone to cut and haul the wood. Heck if I could afford that car I could buy big leaf maple burl and have it shipped directly to the house.

Re: Concepts

#23

Maybe she wants to ride on the bike 


Re: Concepts

#24

Keith Tompkins

Re: Maybe she wants to ride on the bike 

Keith Tompkins

Well Donna....waddya' think? Not too shabby for forty years old ;)

Re: Concepts

#25

Re: Maybe she wants to ride on the bike

Donna Banfield

Keith, any bike looks good, no matter how old. I bought one when I turned 18 simply because my Dad told me I couldn't.

There's nothing like feeling the wind rushing across your face on a warm summer night..... until a big June Bug hits you in the throat at 50+ miles per hour :-( Aacckkk!